Great Article on Bill C-36

DIRTY POLITICIANS Don't care for good Policy or reasons. They are artful at JUSTIFICATIONS for ramming through Policy to gain votes or preserve their base of supporters = Harper & Gang
 
Last edited:
Great piece. How many times do prohibitionists have to be reminded that sex work does not inherently involve 'exploitation'?

Right now, I'm simply reading stuff with a mind to the Charter litigation that we will be involved in soon. I am happy that the Tories are digging themselves in so deeply. The last thing I desire is a law where they get enough "right" to make the legislation somewhat defensible. So far, they're doing a good job of totally fucking up constitutionally and I luv it.
Well said, and thank god for us.
 
You really can't tell the difference between someone who is upbeat and someone who is high? If there is any doubt, move on.

Forget what the guy looks like. He can be wearing a suit for all I care. But have you ever gone to see an SP and have a guy open the door or meet you in hallway first? It's not a good sign.

Interesting. So if a guy meets you, like a booker or a bodyguard, for which Ms. Bedford et al fought so valiantly for ostensibly to safeguard their personal security, that's your basis for questioning the wiling participation of the SP? Wow. Just wow.

As for whether I can tell someone is high.... No, I can't. Nor can anyone without adequate training. Perhaps I can guess. I suppose that's where your "doubt" factor comes into play. So clients are supposed to make snap judgement calls based on their gut feel. Ok. how do you suppose you're going to enforce that? I made a call in the moment. A judge second guesses me based on ???

dude, I know what you're getting at. But there's a huge chasm here between what we *should* do and an enforceable legal obligation.

Incidentally, have you never heard of sexworkers who get high or buzzed so they can do their work? Ask around. Are we to assume that they are all unwilling participants?
 
Interesting. So if a guy meets you, like a booker or a bodyguard, for which Ms. Bedford et al fought so valiantly for ostensibly to safeguard their personal security, that's your basis for questioning the wiling participation of the SP? Wow. Just wow.

I'll clarify what I meant. It obviously depends on how the interaction goes. If all the guy does is pad you down for weapons, that's obviously different.

As for whether I can tell someone is high.... No, I can't. Nor can anyone without adequate training. Perhaps I can guess. I suppose that's where your "doubt" factor comes into play. So clients are supposed to make snap judgement calls based on their gut feel. Ok. how do you suppose you're going to enforce that? I made a call in the moment. A judge second guesses me based on ???

Evidence maybe? It's called constructive knowledge. What did you know or ought to have known. It applies for sexual assault. Did you take reasonable steps to ascertain consent? The only people there are you and her. You explain why you think she was consenting. The Crown explains why you should have known she wasn't. Judge decides.

Buying stolen goods is not illegal. But if you knew, or should have known it was stolen, then it is a crime to buy. Same kind of burden of proof.

These kinds of test exists in all sorts of law.

Incidentally, have you never heard of sexworkers who get high or buzzed so they can do their work? Ask around. Are we to assume that they are all unwilling participants?

They may or may not be willing participants. If you're not sure, ask more questions. Or walk away if you want maximum deniability.
 
From the Oxford Dictionary:

Exploit
verb
Pronunciation: /ɪkˈsplɔɪt

, ɛk-/

[with object] 1. Make full use of and derive benefit from (a resource): 500 companies sprang up to exploit this new technology

2. Make use of (a situation) in a way considered unfair or underhand: the company was exploiting a legal loophole

2.1. Benefit unfairly from the work of (someone), typically by overworking or underpaying them: women are exploited in the workplace
 
I'll clarify what I meant. It obviously depends on how the interaction goes. If all the guy does is pad you down for weapons, that's obviously different.



Evidence maybe? It's called constructive knowledge. What did you know or ought to have known. It applies for sexual assault. Did you take reasonable steps to ascertain consent? The only people there are you and her. You explain why you think she was consenting. The Crown explains why you should have known she wasn't. Judge decides.

Buying stolen goods is not illegal. But if you knew, or should have known it was stolen, then it is a crime to buy. Same kind of burden of proof.

These kinds of test exists in all sorts of law.



They may or may not be willing participants. If you're not sure, ask more questions. Or walk away if you want maximum deniability.


1. So if Mr. Thug pats me down, it's ok? Never seen a mafia movie? lol

2. The test for sexual assault is not taking reasonable steps to ascertain or obtain consent. The test is whether the victim communicated his/her unwillingness. No means no. Once a refusal is uttered, all bets are off.

3. Buying stolen goods IS illegal if you knew about it. That's a very different test than what you propose. I don't have a problem if the law is that a John knowingly patronized a trafficked sexworker. I have a problem with placing the onus on the John to determine whether she is trafficked.

Who needs Harper when you have DigitallyYours proposing these laws? Talk about chilling the industry.



From the Oxford Dictionary:

Exploit
verb
Pronunciation: /ɪkˈsplɔɪt

, ɛk-/

[with object] 1. Make full use of and derive benefit from (a resource): 500 companies sprang up to exploit this new technology

2. Make use of (a situation) in a way considered unfair or underhand: the company was exploiting a legal loophole

2.1. Benefit unfairly from the work of (someone), typically by overworking or underpaying them: women are exploited in the workplace

I guess you don't like the first definition but prefer 2.1?

Let's work that out then, just for shits and giggles - Would you care to define "benefit unfairly"? Is taking up to 50% of the revenue for a nude massage session in a massage parlour fair? Is the MP owner earning an IRR of 75% to 150% per annum fair? (Do you know of many other businesses where you can get a payback of your investment in less than a year?)

Economists would be tripping over themselves proving the inequity of the profit split between owners and workers. I can already see the bulge in UNIFOR's proverbial pants as they look to organize the sexworkers of Canada.
 
2. The test for sexual assault is not taking reasonable steps to ascertain or obtain consent. The test is whether the victim communicated his/her unwillingness. No means no. Once a refusal is uttered, all bets are off.

I was referring to section 273.2 of the CCC:

273.2 It is not a defence to a charge under section 271, 272 or 273 that the accused believed that the complainant consented to the activity that forms the subject-matter of the charge, where

  • (a) the accused’s belief arose from the accused’s
    • (i) self-induced intoxication, or
    • (ii) recklessness or wilful blindness; or
  • (b) the accused did not take reasonable steps, in the circumstances known to the accused at the time, to ascertain that the complainant was consenting.

3. Buying stolen goods IS illegal if you knew about it. That's a very different test than what you propose. I don't have a problem if the law is that a John knowingly patronized a trafficked sexworker. I have a problem with placing the onus on the John to determine whether she is trafficked.

They're related. You can either know for sure she is trafficked, or maybe you should have known, based on certain indicia, but chose to ignore it. In the latter case, you probably should have taken *reasonable* steps to ascertain the situation. And if you did take reasonable steps and everything is ok, you have nothing to worry about.

Who needs Harper when you have DigitallyYours proposing these laws? Talk about chilling the industry.

What are you talking about? Out of the SPs and MPAs I have seen, only once has my radar gone off that she was on some sort of subtance, but she was someone I had repeated with over 10 times, so I just chalked it up to an off day.

If you should have known a girl was trafficked and turned a blind eye to it, then yeah, I think you're part of the problem.

It shouldn't be an issue in 99.9999999% of the cases.
 
What are you talking about? Out of the SPs and MPAs I have seen, only once has my radar gone off that she was on some sort of subtance, but she was someone I had repeated with over 10 times, so I just chalked it up to an off day.

If you should have known a girl was trafficked and turned a blind eye to it, then yeah, I think you're part of the problem.

It shouldn't be an issue in 99.9999999% of the cases.


Well now that's interesting....I know firsthand that many of the girls at one of your favourite hangouts make a habit of smoking over the course of their shifts. I don't know if you've specifically seen any of the girls, but based on the number of times you've been there, I'm sure you must have crossed-paths with more than one. Or, I guess it isn't that easy to tell, is it?
 
Well now that's interesting....I know firsthand that many of the girls at one of your favourite hangouts make a habit of smoking over the course of their shifts. I don't know if you've specifically seen any of the girls, but based on the number of times you've been there, I'm sure you must have crossed-paths with more than one. Or, I guess it isn't that easy to tell, is it?

In cases where a *reasonable* person cannot tell, then you're in the clear. Obviously, the law cannot expect everyone to be experts in ferreting out who is being exploited or not. Your example is not one where in the circumstances, you should have known that a girl is being exploited or that there is even a problem. If the girl you are seeing is smoking marijuana (or anything else) during her day, but she speaks normally and coherently, has control of her faculties, isn't glassy eyed, no weird odours, etc. you cannot possibly suspect that anything is wrong. Why would anyone accuse you that you should have known she was being exploited? That's not something the Crown would ever charge you with if those are the circumstances.
 
I see a case for exploiting me and my employer being charged if I were underage, but if I was a heroin addict or a schizophrenic they aren't breaking any laws for hiring me.
No, but they could most assuredly be breaking laws if they failed to properly consider and adjust the work requirements they imposed on you according to those disabilities. I may be speaking more broadly than the swords of those particular statutes (which focus on encouraging such employment) but their purpose is to ensure fair and equal treatment. Somehow I cannot see an employer's demonstrably exploitive actions meeting that standard any better than their failure to accommodate.

In any case, for most of us, C36 speaks to our status as customer or client, not as employer. In line with your point, customers have much less opportunity to detect such possible disqualifications, and somewhat more personal latitude in how they respond. But by assuming all providers are deluded, deranged, immature, and /or coerced and exploited, C36 has freed us of any such decision-making.

Why it doesn't go the last mile and provide for mandatory treatment and cure of our victims I can only ascribe to the Cons' anti-healthcare dogma. 'Let 'em suffer for their mad, bad choices. But they cannot work'
 
No, but they could most assuredly be breaking laws if they failed to properly consider and adjust the work requirements they imposed on you according to those disabilities. I may be speaking more broadly than the swords of those particular statutes (which focus on encouraging such employment) but their purpose is to ensure fair and equal treatment. Somehow I cannot see an employer's demonstrably exploitive actions meeting that standard any better than their failure to accommodate.

In any case, for most of us, C36 speaks to our status as customer or client, not as employer. In line with your point, customers have much less opportunity to detect such possible disqualifications, and somewhat more personal latitude in how they respond. But by assuming all providers are deluded, deranged, immature, and /or coerced and exploited, C36 has freed us of any such decision-making.

Why it doesn't go the last mile and provide for mandatory treatment and cure of our victims I can only ascribe to the Cons' anti-healthcare dogma. 'Let 'em suffer for their mad, bad choices. But they cannot work'


As usual, well thought and said.

The last bit is what I find most offensive about the C36. We can quibble about their (faulty) presumptions about the industry. But, if they truly believed their own bullshit, they would make a serious effort to help the "victims".
 
There is one important issue that I really haven't seen any real discussion on yet.

What's the definitive of 'exploitive'?

Is there a definition that would make pimping (the stereotypical way we think of it) illegal, but make legitimate reputable agencies legal?

It would be something to the effect of "Any individual who hires out another person to perform sexual services under threat or duress." Pretty simple.