Great Article on Bill C-36

Ms.FemmeFatale

Behind the camera
Jun 18, 2011
3,111
1
36
www.msfemmefatale.com
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/how-to-fix-the-prostitution-law/article19736589/

It doesn’t take long for the Conservative government’s bill on sex work to go off the rails: In the first sentence of the preamble it declares that “exploitation is inherent in prostitution.” In the context of the exchange of sexual services for consideration between consenting adults, this ex cathedra pronouncement is demonstrably false. It ignores mountains of social science evidence and the testimony of many sex workers. The bill perpetuates stereotypes that marginalize and stigmatize sex workers.

Bill C-36 and the government’s discourse about it draws to a remarkable degree on what the scholar Gayle Rubin identified as deep wells of “sex negativity” in our culture. Sex is neither redeemed nor corrupted by the presence or absence of economic exchange, any more than it is by the social approval or disapproval the relationship receives. Rather, the social value of any sexual activity is determined by the quality of respect and the quantity of pleasures that participants bring to each other.

The stereotype that sex work lacks social value is most commonly expressed by the question, “Would you want your daughter to be a sex worker?” Well, no, not in a society that disrespects her work and degrades the value of sexual pleasure. But if we direct our energies to dismantling the prejudices that undergird the question, the answer might be different.

The proposition that commercial exchange inevitably renders sex exploitative is a moralistic or ideological premise that will not stand scrutiny in the courts in the inevitable Charter challenge.

In rulings limiting the scope of obscenity law (Butler 1992) and legalizing adult swingers’ clubs (Labaye 2005), the Supreme Court of Canada affirmed that criminal offences must be based on concrete harms, not on conventional understandings of right and wrong. The court said that “legal moralism,” where a majority decides what values should inform individual lives and then coercively imposes those values on minorities, cannot serve as a basis for imposing limits on Charter rights. The criminal law, the court has said, should be shaped by “objectively ascertainable harm instead of subjective disapproval.”

Sexual exploitation is an objectively ascertainable harm. Preventing it is an important objective that is part of the definition of many sexual offences. Given the profound imbalances of power that can exist in the sex trade, the criminal law has an important role to play in condemning and punishing exploitative practices and relationships. But before criminalizing adult sexual relationships, exploitation is a harm that needs to be proven, not merely asserted.

Bill C-36 has some laudable provisions that respond to the need to focus on exploitative relationships and protect sex workers from risks of harm. First, the bill amends the bawdy-house provision of the Criminal Code to make it legal for sex workers to work indoors. Second, the bill draws a careful line by targeting people who exploit sex workers, such as pimps and procurers, and exempting those who provide services that can enhance sex workers’ safety, such as security guards. In these two ways, the bill is aligned with the Supreme Court’s ruling in the Bedford case, which found the existing “bawdy house” and “living on the avails” offences to be unconstitutional because they exposed sex workers to heightened risk.

Sadly, the focus on targeting exploitative relationships is completely absent from the proposed offences that prohibit the purchase of sexual services and the advertising of sexual services. Because of the false and moralistic presumption that all commercial sex is exploitative, Bill C-36 makes it an offence to purchase sexual services in any context, and likewise makes it an offence for anybody to advertise sexual services in any context (such as in a magazine or on a website).

Because these two provisions of the bill will heighten the risks faced by sex workers while legally selling their services, their overbreadth renders them unconstitutional. They are easily fixed by confining them to circumstances of exploitation.

Buyers and advertisers of sexual services should face prosecution only if they have failed to ascertain the absence of conditions of exploitation. This should include a duty to take all reasonable steps to ensure that sex workers are 18 or over, are not trafficked or otherwise subject to violence or coercion, and have given meaningful consent to sexual contact that is not compromised by, for example, mental health disabilities, alcohol or drugs.

If Bill C-36 were amended in this way, it would achieve its objective of preventing sexual exploitation more effectively. Police, prosecutorial and judicial resources would not be wasted targeting non-exploitative sexual transactions between consenting adults. Rather than stigmatizing sex workers, their clients and advertisers, they would all be enlisted in eliminating real harms, rather than avoiding prosecution for imaginary ones.

Really really great article. I wish the people in power would take his points to heart.
 
Great article, I think most Canadians would agree with his points.

I'd have a small quibble with this though.
Buyers and advertisers of sexual services should face prosecution only if they have failed to ascertain the absence of conditions of exploitation. This should include a duty to take all reasonable steps to ensure that sex workers are 18 or over, are not trafficked or otherwise subject to violence or coercion, and have given meaningful consent to sexual contact that is not compromised by, for example, mental health disabilities, alcohol or drugs.
I don't think I should be prosecuted if I paid for sex with someone with mental issues, or if she has alcohol or drug problems. My employer wouldn't be charged if I was hired having these problems.
 
Great article, I think most Canadians would agree with his points.

I'd have a small quibble with this though.

I don't think I should be prosecuted if I paid for sex with someone with mental issues, or if she has alcohol or drug problems. My employer wouldn't be charged if I was hired having these problems.

A different angle on the topic that is refreshing and would appeal to the populus.
 
I think your quibble is addressed by "take all reasonable steps". I suppose you might want to soften that a little. I would prefer "take reasonable steps". "All" is probably unreasonable.
 
Good article. Right now, I'm simply reading stuff with a mind to the Charter litigation that we will be involved in soon. I am happy that the Tories are digging themselves in so deeply. The last thing I desire is a law where they get enough "right" to make the legislation somewhat defensible. So far, they're doing a good job of totally fucking up constitutionally and I luv it.
 
Really really great article. I wish the people in power would take his points to heart.

Might as well explain the concept of colours to the blind. They are comfortable to live their lives in a grey box bordered by archaic rules and fear others that could threaten that dull but predictable existence. They are more afraid of the prospect of themselves living without the rules than the well being of anyone else.
 
Great article, I think most Canadians would agree with his points.

I'd have a small quibble with this though.

I don't think I should be prosecuted if I paid for sex with someone with mental issues, or if she has alcohol or drug problems. My employer wouldn't be charged if I was hired having these problems.
I'm not at all sure your employer would get off their responsibility for exploiting your mental disability, addiction or being underage. They certainly would face possible legal punishment if they used physical violence or coercion against you. In any case, the employer-employee relationship isn't exactly parallel with C36.

Unless you're running a service, you're a client/customer (or provider). Consider: Customers of your nasty employer's evil business who were unaware of your misfortunes and mistreatment would face no criminal penalties, not unless their knowledge amounted to aiding and abetting. While a customer of even the finest, most scrupulously managed employee-owned incall would, any and all evidence there was neither exploitation nor anything but mature and considered free choice of the employees notwithstanding. If criminal charges similarly threatened those who bought the sawdust-filled putrifying sausages underage slave-labour produced for your brutish employer, who would report the operation and save you? Or stop their continuing sale to unscrupulous hot-dog vendors and fast-food operators?

If you're worried about being prosecuted as a john, the answer is legalization so the same sort of reasonable laws that protect us in every other aspect of life can protect the sexual part of our lives as well. But under C36, neither of us will be eager to report any nastiness we may encounter, will we?
 
The criminalizing of buying only in circumstances of exploitation is not new and is the way the prostitution law works in England. Boivin even mentioned this option of only criminalizing where there is exploitation during the Committee meetings. It's certainly nice to see an academic write about it and in a national paper like the Globe.

It's quite obvious that the Conservatives went into their 'consultations' with an answer already in mind and then just looked for 'evidence' to support it. They never even considered other models like New Zealand and England. They're certainly not going to consider them now.
 
I'm not at all sure your employer would get off their responsibility for exploiting your mental disability, addiction or being underage. They certainly would face possible legal punishment if they used physical violence or coercion against you. In any case, the employer-employee relationship isn't exactly parallel with C36.
I see a case for exploiting me and my employer being charged if I were underage, but if I was a heroin addict or a schizophrenic they aren't breaking any laws for hiring me.
 
Good article. Right now, I'm simply reading stuff with a mind to the Charter litigation that we will be involved in soon. I am happy that the Tories are digging themselves in so deeply. The last thing I desire is a law where they get enough "right" to make the legislation somewhat defensible. So far, they're doing a good job of totally fucking up constitutionally and I luv it.

Yup!
 
There is one important issue that I really haven't seen any real discussion on yet.

What's the definitive of 'exploitive'?

Is there a definition that would make pimping (the stereotypical way we think of it) illegal, but make legitimate reputable agencies legal?
 
I'm not at all sure your employer would get off their responsibility for exploiting your mental disability, addiction or being underage. They certainly would face possible legal punishment if they used physical violence or coercion against you. In any case, the employer-employee relationship isn't exactly parallel with C36.

Unless you're running a service, you're a client/customer (or provider). Consider: Customers of your nasty employer's evil business who were unaware of your misfortunes and mistreatment would face no criminal penalties, not unless their knowledge amounted to aiding and abetting. While a customer of even the finest, most scrupulously managed employee-owned incall would, any and all evidence there was neither exploitation nor anything but mature and considered free choice of the employees notwithstanding. If criminal charges similarly threatened those who bought the sawdust-filled putrifying sausages underage slave-labour produced for your brutish employer, who would report the operation and save you? Or stop their continuing sale to unscrupulous hot-dog vendors and fast-food operators?

If you're worried about being prosecuted as a john, the answer is legalization so the same sort of reasonable laws that protect us in every other aspect of life can protect the sexual part of our lives as well. But under C36, neither of us will be eager to report any nastiness we may encounter, will we?


Well said. I fully agree. I've seen my share of "enthusiastic, willing and happy sexworkers" who, in private moments, have caused me to question her "voluntariness". While I wholeheartedly support the intent to eradicate human trafficking, I don't think it is fair or practical to put the burden on clients. It's unreasonable to expect us to identify problems when a fundamental element of our interaction is the creation of "fantasy". We are paying for an illusion. To penalize us for failing to detect exploitation in fact is patently ridiculous.
 
There is one important issue that I really haven't seen any real discussion on yet.

What's the definitive of 'exploitive'?

Is there a definition that would make pimping (the stereotypical way we think of it) illegal, but make legitimate reputable agencies legal?

I discussed this in one of my rambling babbles. The context was MPs and the idea of "profiteering" As I recall, not really. Profiteering is inherently exploitive.
 
Well said. I fully agree. I've seen my share of "enthusiastic, willing and happy sexworkers" who, in private moments, have caused me to question her "voluntariness". While I wholeheartedly support the intent to eradicate human trafficking, I don't think it is fair or practical to put the burden on clients. It's unreasonable to expect us to identify problems when a fundamental element of our interaction is the creation of "fantasy". We are paying for an illusion. To penalize us for failing to detect exploitation in fact is patently ridiculous.

I think the key word is "reasonable".

If she looks *really* young, ask for ID. If she has no idea what town she is in, maybe it's time to walk away. If she seems high or drunk, get out of there. If your first point of contact is some guy who looks like he belongs in a motorcycle gang, you should probably leave. Basically, anything that a reasonable person should be able to pick up on.

A comment from the girl like "yeah, i needed a few bucks to cover rent this month" doesn't really count in my opinion of non-voluntariness.
 
If there's an agreement, it isn't exploitive. Both sides profit in different ways.

Apparently, for many prostitutes, their pimp is their boyfriend. My gut reaction is that this is exploitive but it's also voluntary so I'm not sure what to do with these kinds of circumstances.
 
If there's an agreement, it isn't exploitive. Both sides profit in different ways.

You presume that exploit means an unfair or unequal exchange. That's not the common definition. Look it up.

I think the key word is "reasonable".

If she looks *really* young, ask for ID. If she has no idea what town she is in, maybe it's time to walk away. If she seems high or drunk, get out of there. If your first point of contact is some guy who looks like he belongs in a motorcycle gang, you should probably leave. Basically, anything that a reasonable person should be able to pick up on.

A comment from the girl like "yeah, i needed a few bucks to cover rent this month" doesn't really count in my opinion of non-voluntariness.

Right, when's the last time you asked for ID from an SP? How did that work out for you? Does that make it ok for an SP to ask for your ID? Would you? Why don't you put that out in the thread about being burned by SPs/MPS?

If she seems high or drunk? What if she's just ebullient by nature? I've never taken the SafeServe course. I don't party or hang around people who enjoy recreational drugs. how am I supposed to know the symptoms? Some guy who looks like he belongs to a motorcycle gang. Are you serious?!?! What about black guys? Or Asian guys dressed in black? Are you really advocating profiling? So it's ok to legislate that Johns profile potential criminals but not for the Toronto Police Service?

Seriously......
 
If she seems high or drunk? What if she's just ebullient by nature? I've never taken the SafeServe course. I don't party or hang around people who enjoy recreational drugs. how am I supposed to know the symptoms? Some guy who looks like he belongs to a motorcycle gang. Are you serious?!?! What about black guys? Or Asian guys dressed in black? Are you really advocating profiling? So it's ok to legislate that Johns profile potential criminals but not for the Toronto Police Service?

Seriously......

You really can't tell the difference between someone who is upbeat and someone who is high? If there is any doubt, move on.

Forget what the guy looks like. He can be wearing a suit for all I care. But have you ever gone to see an SP and have a guy open the door or meet you in hallway first? It's not a good sign.