good-bye katherine

Let's not fool ourselves, American Idol has become big business, and I mean big, big business. Not only are they selling ad space with a viewing/voting audience as high as 40,000,000 which translates into $$millions of revenue for each show, but also the established stars are seeing a positive impact on their record sales. The last few singers like Stevie Wonder, Rod Stewart, have seen a burst in their sales, in fact I heard on NBC this morning they expect a big burst in Elvis Presley CD sales due to this week's show.

When there seems to be an obvious winner for weeks like Chris, it became boring because everyone started to see the winner way before the final and the mystique was waining. So by eliminating Chris, everyone gasps and the supense continues that will keep the audience glued to the TV set until the final, it's the unknown factor that will keep people watching and keep the ad revenue coming in till the end. Brilliant strategy by the producers, I believe this is all contrived to keep eyeballs on their show and the most talented singer probably never wins. As someone mentioned before the voting system is unfair, the producers edit segments to slant it to whoever they want, and the judges also have an impact on the voting.

It's all about the money.



This is my take on it anyway.
 
fun-guy said:
Let's not fool ourselves, American Idol has become big business, and I mean big, big business. Not only are they selling ad space with a viewing/voting audience as high as 40,000,000 which translates into $$millions of revenue for each show, but also the established stars are seeing a positive impact on their record sales. The last few singers like Stevie Wonder, Rod Stewart, have seen a burst in their sales, in fact I heard on NBC this morning they expect a big burst in Elvis Presley CD sales due to this week's show.

When there seems to be an obvious winner for weeks like Chris, it became boring because everyone started to see the winner way before the final and the mystique was waining. So by eliminating Chris, everyone gasps and the supense continues that will keep the audience glued to the TV set until the final, it's the unknown factor that will keep people watching and keep the ad revenue coming in till the end. Brilliant strategy by the producers, I believe this is all contrived to keep eyeballs on their show and the most talented singer probably never wins. As someone mentioned before the voting system is unfair, the producers edit segments to slant it to whoever they want, and the judges also have an impact on the voting.

It's all about the money.



This is my take on it anyway.


Fun-Guy...I have to whole heartedly disagree with some of the above. If you look at the total votes by contestants for the last 3-4 weeks you'll see that Chris was not the front runner. He was not the clear choice. Katherine is right there too. As for rigging the vote...no way. Remember you said so yourself, Idol is big business and it would be waayay to difficult to keep this a secret. Major fallout if it was ever leaked.
 
Spode, there are way more things happening in this business than just simply allowing America to vote and sit back and see who gets the most votes.


1)The videos on the contestants are being slanted by the producers to give an edge to certain singers, this has been noticed by many people who have complained,

2) The voting system sucks, what kind of contest is this when someone can vote all night long for the same person, should be one vote per person,

3) It's more than just a talent competition, it has a lot to do with charisma, looks, image, popularity, how you act outside of singing and you're caught on video that the producers conveniently happen to show to millions of people on TV, etc, it's not necessarily the best singer, Chris is still the best singer and has the purest voice, IMO, and the majority of people that I've talked to agree

Are the votes rigged? I don't really know and I can't prove it, but would I be surprised if it was??? Absolutely not. Does anyone know who supervises the voting? How is it kept honest? Accounting firm involved like the Oscars?

Should they have a voting system where the judges vote and have some impact on the voting like Dancing with Stars did? Should professionals in the industry have some say in the voting, again like the Oscars, and weigh all the votes together including America, judges and music industry professionals? Just food for thought.
 
Not all bad news for Chris. Apparently he has an offer to become lead singer of Fuel.
 
fun-guy said:
Are the votes rigged? I don't really know and I can't prove it, but would I be surprised if it was??? Absolutely not. Does anyone know who supervises the voting? How is it kept honest? Accounting firm involved like the Oscars?

While I tend to doubt the votes are rigged, I do think having a third party involved in the voting procedures is a good idea. I understand that your favorite, Chris, got voted off, but this is not the first time some strange things have happened in the course of AI voting. In Season 1, Tamara Gray got voted off, ahead of questionable talents like Nikki McKibbin and Justin Guarini. In Season 3, how did Jasmine Trias and Diana DeGarmo outlast Latoya London? Last season, how in the world did the fat fuck last so long?

Yes, you could argue the voting system is flawed. You could argue that since there is no reason why an individual can't vote 1000 times for the same person, that the voting system favors those with time on their hands. I would agree that a one vote per phone number would be preferable.
 
Last edited:
I usually like the final 3 show when they each sing 3 songs. Coming into tonight, I would have said Elliott needed to hit 3 home runs to continue, whereas Katharine and Taylor had some margin for error. I don't think he got them.

I thought Elliott was just okay. Clay Aiken did 'Open Arms' back in Season 2 and he nailed it. Elliott didn't quite have the range on the chorus. He was considerably better on his last two songs, but I don't think he was as good as he needed to be.

Katharine is easily the best looking female Idol ever, and you know Simon wants to do her. I can't stand that R. Kelly song, and her version was just okay. She hit a grand slam with 'Over the Rainbow' though. I sort of groaned when I heard Simon picked that song for her, and besides, Kimberly Locke did that song also back in Season 2. But she was great. The last song was kind of a throwaway, kind of a heat check almost.

I actually thought 'Dancing in the Dark' was kind of an inspired choice for Taylor, and he did an okay job with it. You knew he was going to get some girl in the audience to dance with him, I just wish it hadn't been Paula. He was decent with the last two songs too.

I'd have to say it's Katharine and Taylor in the final.
 
Elliott was the odd one out tonight...even though he was close with 33.06 % of the vote. As for the other 2, one received 33.26 %, and the top(they didn't say who) vote getter received 33.68 %. VERY close.
 
Rumor has it that William "I'm extremely well" Hung will be part of the finale.
 
The Bandit said:
Elliott was the odd one out tonight...even though he was close with 33.06 % of the vote. As for the other 2, one received 33.26 %, and the top(they didn't say who) vote getter received 33.68 %. VERY close.

That's amazingly close. Off a base of 50 million votes, the difference between 2nd and 3rd is only 100,000 votes. I feel my 4 votes for Katharine last night made all the difference.

Going into the final, you have to say it's wide open. I have underestimated Taylor's fan base to this point, but let's see if my 'America always chooses the cute girl' theory plays out.
 
I think Katherine might have lost out considering tonights final showdown.

But, it depends on whether the voters go by tonights events, or vote for Katherine because of her looks, and previous performances.:D

She'll still get a instant record deal regardless...
 
Like I said last night, Katherine didn't step-up, and Taylor was crowned the winner tonight.:(
 
So much for America always choosing the cute girl. America's gay!

As much as I lust after Katharine, Taylor deserved to win. He is a better performer anyway.
 
homonger said:
America's gay!
They certainly hammered that point home with several Brokeback Moments during the show.

I couldn't have predicted how the voting went but the poll on CFTO News clearly pointed to Taylor winning so it ended up being no surprise. Katharine's hot but her voice just isn't distinctive. If you heard her on the radio, would you know it's her?
 
homonger said:
As much as I lust after Katharine, Taylor deserved to win. He is a better performer anyway.

He is definitely more consistent... but the guy should be singing in the Holiday Inn. He has a lot of that bar band competence working for him... but noone is gonna buy from Mr Soul Patrol.. put him against a real soul singer and his overwraught chicken dancin' self will look ridiculous.

Katherine to me never came off as likeable... a little too princess like. However, you know you can turn her into something... knock off 20 pounds... do some studio magic... and she may have a chance.
 
I don't know about the rest of you, but I'm tired of Taylor's style already(just from the show)....it was getting old.
 
The real finale should have been Chris vs Paris.

Out of the two finalists, Taylor definitely deserved to win. Was it just me or did some of Katherine's outfits make her look like a bloated c-u-n-t? This asshole needs to drop a few pounds before she starts wearing the formfitting dresses.

PS It was great to finally have a show where we didn't have to listen to the drugged up Paula Abdul spewing her incoherent bullshit. Hopefully someone abducts her soon.
 
the rusty tromb said:
Was it just me or did some of Katherine's outfits make her look like a bloated c-u-n-t? This asshole needs to drop a few pounds before she starts wearing the formfitting dresses.

It's just you. Just because she's a normal, healthy size doesn't mean she needs to drop weight.

Taylor has a superior voice that was unfortunately overshadowed most of the time by his annoying antics. If he manages to evolve and doesn't rely on what made him endearing on the show to build his career, he might have a solid go in the business.