So you are (in a relative sense) equating the value of large financial institutions to that of the internal combustion engine? If you don't mind, could you list all the great benefits these big banks have bestowed upon society - in particular, those that could not have been provided by a community based banking system?
Sure the community based banking system could work in
local level since they tend to focus on the needs of the clients where the bank holds branches and lending decisions are made by people who understand the local needs. The community bank could be "toasted" when the neighborhood becomes Detroit of the world but hey many people are trying very hard to convince it's not going to happen in his neighborhood.
Large financial institutions, aka Commercial Banks OTOH perform identical function
nation wide and then some. That means as long as they have the robust risk management in place, they should get more clients and have better growth prospect than the community based banks.
And yeah, countries do trade with each other and large commercial banks are critical to finance those activities and it's doubtful
any community based banking system could cope.
Unless we are talking about people advocating Smoot-Hawley Tariff Sequel, on top of embracing community banking system.
I would not be surprised when you are tempted to lash out the same comments to the Big 5 Canadian banks and look forward to dismantling them into hundreds of credit unions from coast to coast.
BTW, the credit unions are now given the authority to do M&A between themselves and hence a potential to be another
big creditable force to compete with the Bay Street Banks. Based on this possibility, are the credit unions sell-out?
There are over 4000 banking institutions in the United States...and there have been a little over 200 bank failures since this financial crisis began. Of those, how many of these "small banks" required anything more than FDIC help to ensure their orderly failure?
Hmm...you do know FDIC is under
Federal jurisdiction just like TARP? No?
Doubtful you know there is a top secret list of banks at risk of failure out of 4000 banking institutions at FDIC either and based on the worst case scenario, there is every possibility that many small banks could not make it and the government is trying to talk and build up confidence so that there is low possibility of bank runs on those institutions, for
both sound and unsound.
For obvious reason, you sound like any small bank is better than all those "evil" big banks.
Now, lets look at the big financial institutions. First of all, how many would have been classified as very big (as far as total assets are concerned)? Maybe 20-30? Do you not realize that in 2008, most of the big banks would have been labeled insolvent if they were forced to mark their assets to the actual market prices? That could have easily forced them to declare bankrupty.....were it not for FED support (like paying interest on excess reserves), and treasury programs like the TARP?
Hmm...interesting to notice that you simply
ignore the fact that both big national and community based banks compete to the
same businesses in the states level.
So if those big national banks are in deep trouble/at risk of being insolvent, wouldn't their local community banks competitors in different states face similar if not as severe risks? Maybe not since for some by "magic/divine intervention" the local community based banks will be spared from getting hit even though both institutions are competing in the same economically stressed region.
BTW, if the majority of the community based banks are that robust like you try to convince, how come they as a group protest the Fed "favoring" the big banks and deny their "rights" for the Fed support? Aren't they as a group supposed to be financially strong enough to weather the financial storm and thus no need to get help from DC? Yes? No? Maybe?
I see. So a bank like Citigroup should be less risky because of its funding and ability to spread risks? I guess the same goes for Bank of America....you know two such big banks that would have failed in 2008 and subsequently caused immense stress to the entire financial sector had they actually been allowed to go under?
That's exactly what I expected you to say.
What about JP Morgan before the Fed asked Jamie Dimon to bail out both Bear Stearn and Washington Mutual? How about Wells Fargo before taking over/bailing out Wachovia? Do you know US Bancorp by any chance? No?
No matter since people nowadays find convenient, too convenient to equate
all big banks are equally fraudulent one way or another, even though many are still having accounts and money deposited to the same "evil doers". They do have the options to close the accounts in those "evil doers" and move the money to somewhere else.
BTW, unlike already dysfunctional Citigroup, Bank of America was a sound bank before they took over Countrywide Financial and Merrill Lynch to stem further systematic breakdown on the system.
Well, lets see...I'm thinking it might be better for a bank to lend money to those individuals & companies who actually have a strong possibilty of repaying those loans. You know, for example individuals who actually earn an income.
It would not matter much this time since different quality of loans were
securitized/packaged and sold to the institutional and high net worth investors.
When institutional investors lose
confidence and
trust on the quality and soundness of loans behind those "securities", who cares those individuals and companies borrowing from the banks are prime borrowers since people are betting, almost counting they are next to go down the tube.
There's nothing to stop from the big investors thinking good/prime borrowers are not as good as they believe and those borrowers are simply guilty until proven innocent. I would not be shocked if the institutional investors demand to get the money back asap.
BTW, if I am not mistaken, it will be equally true there's nothing to stop your banks to change their minds and consider prime borrowers "bad" risks in order to fix their balance sheets. That ranges from wrecking your FICO score by cutting the HELOC limits, to ratcheting up interest rates on any outstanding balances in HELOC account and if floated/variable, increasing the mortgage rate to the point that you wished you had down payment as high as 25% before you bought the house. That's in addition to cutting your credit limits on Visa/Master card.
Moreover, in the states, any damage on your FICO score if I could recall could seriously hurt your job hunting prospect and even job securities. I could be wrong but I would not be surprised if it's true.