What's the general consensus on Project Hail Mary? Is it good enough to actually go watch at the theatre or is it better to just wait?
It's 8.5 in IMDB. That's a very high rating
An update to my earlier post. I saw PHM in the theater last week. I was absolutely spot on with the earlier comments. In my view they ruined the movie with all the comedic bits. The overall vibe of the movie is completely wrong. The book is about a civilization ending event: end of humanity and other alien cultures. The main protagonist is acting like a goof throughout the entire movie. Given the stakes it makes zero sense, and it is NOT accurate to the tone of the book. The science parts from the book are also heavily under-represented. I can understand and put up with this given it's intended for all audiences. But I cannot forgive the change in tone from the book, it is jarring and dissonant with the script.I've been dreading the comedy part ever since they released the trailer. I read the book which is amazing btw but pure drama. They should have left it alone a la Interstellar and not try to inject humour in it. I'm going to post an updated take after I watch the movie but like I said, as a huge Sci-fi fan (I average one book a week), I am apprehensive about the end result.
The Martian is also originally a book and the movie is more true to the tone of the book and the science.An update to my earlier post. I saw PHM in the theater last week. I was absolutely spot on with the earlier comments. In my view they ruined the movie with all the comedic bits. The overall vibe of the movie is completely wrong. The book is about a civilization ending event: end of humanity and other alien cultures. The main protagonist is acting like a goof throughout the entire movie. Given the stakes it makes zero sense, and it is NOT accurate to the tone of the book. The science parts from the book are also heavily under-represented. I can understand and put up with this given it's intended for all audiences. But I cannot forgive the change in tone from the book, it is jarring and dissonant with the script.
My final rating: a 7 at best, because it was entertaining and filmed well. But if you are into SciFi with a reasonable understanding of typical hard SF concepts and science, the book is a 10.
Yes indeed!The Martian is also originally a book and the movie is more true to the tone of the book and the science.
I wanted to watch it in IMAX but they sold out almost immediately...Definitely some questionable casting choices for The Odyssey, but I'm still kind of excited to watch it, not all that often we get epic's anymore
You can say that again. I've never seen someone be out acted by a plank of wood beforeThere's no comparison between Supergirl and Snow White. Matthias Schoenearts has more talent in his hangnail than Gal Gadot has in her entire body.
agree wholeheartedly what an incredible movie overall with an amazing castDElroy Lindo deserved the Best Supporting actor award for Sinners.






