God's Law

Status
Not open for further replies.
Repeating your lie will not make it any more real.

1999 is old news, although I happily admit I have not read that article. If you are talking Oxford you really should be talking Barret and Trigg, the people doing the cutting edge research shouldn't you? Are you suggesting that their data and the Pew data is not good data?

And you still cannot name a denomination that "ignores" the OT in the way you describe. You have missed the basic foundations of theology and history of that whole issue. Even if you don't accept it, you should try to understand it.
You really go out of your way to advertise your ignorance. I have no idea why you bought up Oxford unless it is in reference to the press that publishes the journal. If you think the publisher is important for some reason, you can get yourself a hardcopy of the following from the same publisher (published this year): http://books.google.ca/books?hl=en&...lK2R7_PlAP4wNHVdB39gaPNqM#v=onepage&q&f=false

I cited the Stark paper because I figured you might be able to read it. For some recent papers that I’m sure would be above your head, see http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00036840802600442
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1538-4616.2009.00284.x/full
http://www.bepress.com/bejeap/vol11/iss1/art14/

You may not be able to understand all the details without knowing a bit of math. However, they address the issues and make clear the debate did not suddenly end in 1999 (as is clear from the 10 pages of citations for the Stark paper that google scholar lists for 2011 alone). In addition, they all include at least a very basic literature review.

If you knew anything about the literature, you should know about the problems with international cross sectional survey data on religiosity.
I would suggest you stop digging yourself in and let the thread die. Besides, I am tired of trying to educate you.
 
Last edited:
Seems to work for those who KNOW their is a God!
Even many religious people are not as dense as rid is. Most of the names I gave him in post #101 are actually religious people in their personal lives. I personally think it colours their research. However, no one who has read ”almost all” the recent research in the area could possibly be unaware of them.
 
You really go out of your way to advertise your ignorance. I have no idea why you bought up Oxford unless it is in reference to the press that publishes the journal. If you think the publisher is important for some reason, you can get yourself a hardcopy of the following from the same publisher (published this year): http://books.google.ca/books?hl=en&...lK2R7_PlAP4wNHVdB39gaPNqM#v=onepage&q&f=false

I cited the Stark paper because I figured you might be able to read it. For some recent papers that I’m sure would be above your head, see http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00036840802600442
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1538-4616.2009.00284.x/full
http://www.bepress.com/bejeap/vol11/iss1/art14/

You may not be able to understand all the details without knowing a bit of math. However, they address the issues and make clear the debate did not suddenly end in 1999 (as is clear from the 10 pages of citations for the Stark paper that google scholar lists for 2011 alone). In addition, they all include at least a very basic literature review.

If you knew anything about the literature, you should know about the problems international cross sectional survey data on religiosity.
I would suggest you stop digging yourself in and let the thread die. Besides, I am tired of trying to educate you.

I was quoting the much more up to date research to try and demonstrate in a civil way how my interest differs from yours. Clearly civility was not on the agenda in your "non-liberal arts" training. Pity.

So I read the article last night and realized that it is almost of no interest to me. I am not interested in secularization as a question stretching back over 2000 years, and would suggest that attempts to quantify the religiousity of the people in the middle ages and before is a mug's game that cannot be done (there is some value in a liberal arts education after all). The only part I found of any interest was a repeat of survey data I already knew about amongst scientists.

And while you have childishly insulted me, and simply ignored the hard questions I have asked (still waiting for you to name that magic "ignoring" denomination), you have surely not educated me in the slightest.

The premise you suggested about why churches changed remains factually and theologically incorrect.
 
I was quoting the much more up to date research to try and demonstrate in a civil way how my interest differs from yours. Clearly civility was not on the agenda in your "non-liberal arts" training. Pity.

So I read the article last night and realized that it is almost of no interest to me. I am not interested in secularization as a question stretching back over 2000 years, and would suggest that attempts to quantify the religiousity of the people in the middle ages and before is a mug's game that cannot be done (there is some value in a liberal arts education after all). The only part I found of any interest was a repeat of survey data I already knew about amongst scientists.

And while you have childishly insulted me, and simply ignored the hard questions I have asked (still waiting for you to name that magic "ignoring" denomination), you have surely not educated me in the slightest.

The premise you suggested about why churches changed remains factually and theologically incorrect.
I’ll take your statement that you have absolutely no interest in the literature as basically admitting that you made an incorrect statement (note how diplomatic I’m being in my choice of wording) when you claimed you read "almost all" of it. Given it took you this long to admit that, I’ll just refer you to the links for answers to your question. If I recall correctly, the Eswaran paper has some references connected with your question.
 
I’ll take your statement that you have absolutely no interest in the literature as basically admitting that you made an incorrect statement (note how diplomatic I’m being in my choice of wording) when you claimed you read "almost all" of it. Given it took you this long to admit that, I’ll just refer you to the links for answers to your question. If I recall correctly, the Eswaran paper has some references connected with your question.

You can take it any way you like. I would phrase it that I was unclear that my interest lies in the data available on the question in this century, not the broader historical question, which I suspect would be almost impossible to answer.
 
[
You can take it any way you like. I would phrase it that I was unclear that my interest lies in the data available on the question in this century, not the broader historical question, which I suspect would be almost impossible to answer.
LOL, you don't know when to stop do you? As I previously stated Post 119), the last 4 references I posted all involved recent data or explanations of recent data. The last three papers were all published in 2011. The only way to be more recent would be to give you links to working papers that have not yet been published. However, you would then respond that they had not been peer-reviewed yet. You cannot have it both ways. Look, you were caught lying about your knowledge of the area. The best thing to do now is to just let the thread die and in time people will forget your foolishness.

BTW, I also found it really funny when you criticized Stark by stating “there is some value in a liberal arts education after all” (post 121). Clearly you did not read the paper closely enough to even notice that he is affiliated with a liberal arts department. LOL, his Phd is in sociology: Not exactly a rigorous discipline. I have to admit that you can be funny. BTW, the point is not whether or not Stark is right. Indeed, none of my posts indicated a view one way or the other on that question. The point is that anyone who says he has read “almost all” the literature would know about his work.
 
[
LOL, you don't know when to stop do you? As I previously stated Post 119), the last 4 references I posted all involved recent data or explanations of recent data. The last three papers were all published in 2011. The only way to be more recent would be to give you links to working papers that have not yet been published. However, you would then respond that they had not been peer-reviewed yet. You cannot have it both ways. Look, you were caught lying about your knowledge of the area. The best thing to do now is to just let the thread die and in time people will forget your foolishness.

BTW, I also found it really funny when you criticized Stark by stating “there is some value in a liberal arts education after all” (post 121). Clearly you did not read the paper closely enough to even notice that he is affiliated with a liberal arts department. LOL, his Phd is in sociology: Not exactly a rigorous discipline. I have to admit that you can be funny. BTW, the point is not whether or not Stark is right. Indeed, none of my posts indicated a view one way or the other on that question. The point is that anyone who says he has read “almost all” the literature would know about his work.

Actually, I was refuting your comments about liberal arts with that comment. But I thought a bright chap like you would not have to be spoon fed that information.

I was not caught lying about anything, despite your protests to the contrary. But since you will not engage the hard questions I will leave you to your own devices.
 
I was not caught lying about anything, despite your protests to the contrary.
Rather than repeat myself, I will simply refer everyone to post #115 which summarizes my position and let them decide for themselves.
 
"...follow another Biblical instruction, this one from Paul's letter to the Romans: "Be transformed by the renewing of your mind."


Amen!!
I let my mind be renewed by the use of critical thinking and reason...and now I no longer believe the Bible. Go figure.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.