Global Warming - What Do You Believe?

Do you believe what you hear about global warming?

  • I believe the earth is getting warmer

    Votes: 15 41.7%
  • I believe global warming is man made

    Votes: 20 55.6%
  • I believe closing power stations and gong by bus will bring the glaciers back

    Votes: 1 2.8%

  • Total voters
    36
from review of henriks book

For scientists, the archetypal romantic hero is the unappreciated pioneer working long hours while being scorned for his unorthodox, but ultimately correct, ideas. Galileo is the defining case, though picking just from the field of earth science, Svante Arrhenius, Milutin Milankovitch, Louis Agassiz, Guy Callendar and Alfred Wegener all endured their time in the wilderness before their ideas were finally vindicated. It is unsurprising then that many lone researchers who find their ideas criticized by the scientific establishment like to portray themselves in this light.


Unfortunately, while this "Galileo syndrome" is commonplace, most such ideas turn out to be wrong. The authors of The Chilling Stars would like you to believe that Danish physicist Henrik Svensmark's controversial view of climate change is the genuine article. But since Svensmark himself is the lead author of this hagiography – irritatingly written in the third person with journalist Nigel Calder – one might be wise to take this declaration with a pinch of salt.

Svensmark's idea, first mooted decades ago, is that the formation of clouds, and hence the climate, can be influenced by changes in the flux of galactic cosmic rays (GCRs). Claiming that GCRs have an impact on the climate by increasing the density of cloud-seeding aerosols is controversial in itself, as this mechanism has not been well established. But the authors go much further, stating that GCRs are actually the dominant driver of climate change on all timescales from days to billions of years, thus usurping humankind's supposed contribution to 20th-century global warming through the release of greenhouse gases.

These are extraordinary claims, which will require extraordinary evidence to be accepted. It is therefore unfortunate that the book is more reminiscent of Immanuel Velikovsky's 1950 bestseller Worlds in Collision – in which the author used ancient mythology to claim that the planet Venus was formed by a comet 3500 years ago – than it is of Galileo's Dialogue. The link between GCRs and clouds is presented as fact, vague correlations are offered as proof, and everything in history – from the ice ages to the evolution of birds – is reinterpreted in the light of the "new" theory.

A clear example of the authors' poor logic concerns trends in the Antarctic climate. They take two valid observations – that clouds have a net warming effect on Antarctica, but a cooling effect elsewhere; and that warming in the Antarctic has been less pronounced than across the rest of the globe – and declare that the two facts must be linked via a cosmic-ray effect on Antarctic clouds. Nowhere is there any evidence that Antarctic clouds are in fact correlated to GCRs; no other valid hypotheses (such as the known impact of the ozone hole on polar winds) are discussed, let alone disproved; and the "continental" temperature trend the authors use consists mainly of data from just one Antarctic island. But from this flimsy premise, they unquestioningly attribute all the anomalies of Antarctic climate (of which there are many in the climate record) to cosmic rays. This is scientific chutzpah of the highest order.

The dramatic centre of the book is the description of a recent experiment conducted by Svensmark and colleagues in which GCRs were shown to create small aerosol particles in "surprising" numbers in the lab. This is indeed interesting, and was rightly written up as a paper and published (Proc. R. Soc. A 463 385–396). However, it is far from the ultimate proof of their ideas that the authors claim. The researchers did not show that GCRs could actually produce much larger cloud condensation nuclei, even in the lab, nor how they would affect clouds in the real world even if they did.

In fact, in claiming that GCRs would only affect low-lying clouds and thus produce a cooling effect the authors display a breathtaking ignorance of the complexity of aerosol–cloud interactions. Yet these missing steps did not stop Svensmark from claiming that he had proved that GCRs have "an effect on everyday weather" in the press release accompanying the paper's publication. For comparison, his theory is not even at the same historical point as the theory of greenhouse gases after John Tyndall's experiments on the thermal properties of gases in the 1860s. Svensmark and colleagues do not seem to be aware of the huge amount of work that was necessary to get from there to the latest report from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

The last few chapters of the book are simply exercises in unconstrained speculation. Any event even vaguely correlated to a hypothetical change in GCRs must have been caused by it, regardless of the absence of evidence. A good example is the onset of the quaternary ice ages 2.6 million years ago. Preliminary work suggested that a large supernova occurred at this time, and the authors discuss at length how this would have led to cooling. Unfortunately for this hypothesis, the dating of the supernova was later revised; but rather than abandon the idea, the authors simply postulate that another as-yet-undetected event must have caused the change instead.

The common thread that is running throughout the book is that since GCRs must affect climate, it is just a question of finding the evidence. If one tack does not pan out, it is discarded and the next one picked up. This is a recipe for being led astray by spurious correlations and turns normal scientific practice on its head.

In reading the book, I was struck by some odd omissions. Nowhere is it mentioned that the first set of correlations between total cloud cover and GCRs published by Svensmark in 1997 disappeared in the light of new data. His second set of correlations, this time only with low cloud cover, are shown, but the fact that those correlations also broke down as the dataset was extended does not get a mention either. Nowhere is there a graph showing cosmic-ray fluctuations in recent decades. In fact, measurements show no significant trends and, since that undermines the authors' claim that a reduction in GCRs is responsible for the current global warming, it is rather disingenuous to omit this information.

However, this just underlines the clear agenda evident throughout The Chilling Stars. It is not enough for the authors' theory to succeed, they want the "opposing" greenhouse-gas theory to fail too. Computer modellers are apparently "silly" to be working on "fashionable" theories of anthropogenic global warming. But the reasons why are completely unclear. Are the calculations for the warming effects of carbon dioxide and methane incorrect? Do greenhouse gases have less effect on climate than GCRs? There is no mention of either here.

The authors would do well to consider that the criticism they have received is not due to the implications of their ideas, but to their track record of dubious and premature claims. The sad thing is that their underlying idea may have some merit, but a credible theory is unlikely to emerge from under the weight of this embarrassing bunk.
 
smiley27 said:
Now this is interesting: no meteorological model today deals with clouds and they are highly reflective, reducing the temperature. Second: the official science doesn't understand how clouds are formed.
red said:
How do clouds form?
Clouds form when water evaporates from rivers, ponds, oceans, and lakes. The air containing this evaporated water vapor rises and expands at higher altitudes where the air pressure is lower. The expanding air cools, and as this cooling occurs, the water vapor condenses (changes) from a vapor to a liquid. Many tiny water droplets form and a cloud is born.

Conditions have to be just right for clouds to form. Nature needs tiny droplets of water, something for the droplets to cling to (particles like dust, salt, or smoke) and the right temperature.
You've done it red. You cracked the mystery, solved the puzzle. Clouds come from evaporating water! You are a shoe-in for the Nobel Prize.;)
 
Questor said:
You've done it red. You cracked the mystery, solved the puzzle. Clouds come from evaporating water! You are a shoe-in for the Nobel Prize.;)
i took it from my official science text book.
 
My belief:

Global warming is happening, it has happened before and it will happen again, there's enough evidence to prove that the earth has cycled between hot and cold long before us humans were around.

Does humanity have an effect? Of course. And so do the cows, termites, volcanoes, solar output of the sun, and everything else in the universe.

Does humanity have a significant effect? I don't believe so. I believe a combination of ego and sloppy/slanted media reporting have us believe that we are having much more of an effect than we are.

What if I'm wrong? If we can affect the global conditions the question becomes how do we know what to do? People who believe that we can affect the environment with 100% surety of the results are deluding themselves. It has been proven again and again that we have no clue how to affect local environment in a planned manner let alone try and manage the globe.

Does that mean I think we should do nothing?

No, for one thing reducing pollution and increasing conservation improve local conditions. But we must not perform these improvements rabidly. It does no good to Canadians or the planet to force manufacturers to close down here only to reopen in other countries that do not have the same rules. If we are going to force our manufacturers to follow certain requirements than the countries we import stuff from must either follow the same requirements or accept being tarriffed the difference in costs in order to allow our manufacturers to both reduce their impact and remain competitive.

The other thing we should be doing is accepting that global change is going to happen regardless of what we desire since even if we could reduce our impact to zero the planet is still going to undergo change (A fact which seems to elude most of the green-nazis who seem to feel that if we could remove our influence somehow the planet will stay forever as it is). We would be much better served preparing to deal with the change. Regardless of what direction the change goes some of humanity will benefit, some will suffer. Mitigating the suffering is all we can do.
 
nathan_wong0 said:
Yes climate change or global warming is happening!! But it would not effect me now... ...I am getting too old ...As long as it does not presently effect my pocket ...I do not care... So let it be the next future generations problems....I would be dead of old age and it would be not my problem.

Selfish, self indulgent & parasitic are three words that come to mind

I hope you do not have any kids (for multiple reasons). grandkids , nephews, nieces etc that have to deal with these issues
 
I don't believe in Global Warming caused by man for 1 second.

It's a mathmatical model in which there are several assumptions made, based on un proven theories. Furthermore, there is absolutely no proof whatsoever that it is occuring. (And after this summer, last summer, and last winter, you'd be hard pressed to convince me otherwise.)

Never the less, controlling pollution is a good thing no matter what (though I oppose any sort of carbon tax as Dion is proposing since it will only bennefit the few and will lead to wholesale higher prices, and make Canadians less competative on the world market)

I don't care if you ban SUV's, enact tougher mileage and emmission requirements for vehicles, or better yet, do something to prevent water pollution.

But Global Warming / the sky is falling. Bah, just a bunch of scientists who get no respect braying away about another "the sky is falling doomsday scenario". They just want to attend conferences in various exotic locals all over the world on my dime. Try booking an escort that week.
 
nathan_wong0 said:
Thank you ....I guess that also applies to President George Bush gov't & Prime Minister Stephan Harper gov't & Oil companies & OPEC too. And everyone who does not support the greenshift alternative . :D And everyone who does not believe in global warming or climate change. .


No!!

If you stance was you did not belive in Global Warming then fine

Your response was that you did not care & it was not your problem as you will be long gone.

Originally Posted by JohnLarue
Selfish, self indulgent & parasitic are three words that come to mind....

Did not refer to whether you believe in Global Warming or climate change or if you do believe, Rather it was directed to your "Its not my problem" Let future generations worry about it" approach to the subject.

I did not really care for that statement as some of my family will comprise that future generation and they may wind up paying for your self indulgence

Its easy for you to lay the blame at the feet of Politicians and Oil Executives, however they have not said "Its not my problem"

Blaming others will not absolve you of your indifferent attitude or your responsibility to the future.
 
nathan_wong0 said:
Thank you ....I guess that also applies to President George Bush gov't & Prime Minister Stephan Harper gov't & Oil companies & OPEC too. And everyone who does not support the greenshift alternative . And everyone who does not believe in global warming or climate change. Also everyone who pollute the environment directly or indirectly. Majority of Canadians will elect a conservative gov't therefore it mean they support in Harper policies in the environment too. So selfish, self indulgent & parasitic applies to them also. With exception of other countries who supported the Koyto Proctol.

Given that the Kyoto Protocol was completely impossible to achieve all that is shown by the supporters of Kyoto was their lack of knowledge on what they were supporting.


nathan_wong0 said:
Remember the bullshit that the tobacco industries , gov'ts and doctors who
said smoking does not causes cancers in 1940's 50's 60's and 70's and 80's. 90's.. Only after decades they finally admit smoking causes cancer and after they lost their USA civil court case on smoking caused cancer case.

This is the exact same bullshit here on green house emission...only after decades when it is too late to safe the planet.

The planet doesn't care what it's temperature is or what the % of CO2 is in the air mix. If we can't adapt to global warming or the next ice age then we will just go the way of the dinosaurs and every other plant/animal/microbe that couldn't adapt to it's changing environment. There isn't anything that says we are guaranteed an existance. So again I will say that all this money being spent trying to freeze the planet in time would be better spent coming up with ways to adapt to the changes.

nathan_wong0 said:
Who fault is it going to be? By then we would all be dead...because we are willing to gamble our planet future...by spreading & believing in false lies....and not doing anything about it to curb our green housegases uses.

Actually it's the creating not the using of greenhouse gases that the Greens are in a snit about. :) What are we to do when the results of our actions are unknown? It's a fool that experiments on his/herself.
 
Some responders have mentioned that the poll choices do not fit properly with the posed question. But they seem OK to me.

I believe the earth is getting warmer - Do you believe it, from what you read, listening to experts etc?
For my own part, I feel the evidence is inescapable, and unmisinterpretable, that glaciers are melting and the arctic is getting warmer -- so yes, I believe global warming is indeed happening.

I believe global warming is man-made - Obviously, this choice would only be meaningful if you believe the earth really is getting warmer. Given that belief, have the experts also convinced you that GW is caused by extra carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, which in turn is caused by humans burning carbon? (Coal, oil = carbon.)
For my own part, as far as I can see, the acknowledged consensus of scientists is that the GW = CO2 link is still nothing more than speculation and computer modelling. There is no actual proof that extra CO2 is to blame.
Furthermore, even if extra CO2 in the atmosphere really is the cause of GW, I have seen nothing that convinces me that the extra CO2 has been caused by humans burning carbon.
How about you? Do you think GW is mankind's fault, or not>

I believe closing power stations and going by bus will bring the glaciers back. - Again, obviously, this choice would only be meaningful if you accept the first two choices.

For my own part, since I do not believe there is any evidence that humans are causing GW, it follows that I don't believe humans can do anything to change it.
How about you? Do you believe we should go where Al Gore, and our own David Suzuki, want to lead us?


That all seems to follow sensibly enough. Why the critical comments?
 
smiley27 said:
Why do you think that I give a fuck about it? If you read carefully my post, I just said that Svensmark's ideas were compelling. Nothing more, nothing less. Where did I say that I believe it?
Who put a burr up your ass? Someone isn't having a very good day. LOL
 
buttercup said:
Some responders have mentioned that the poll choices do not fit properly with the posed question. But they seem OK to me.

I believe the earth is getting warmer - Do you believe it, from what you read, listening to experts etc?
For my own part, I feel the evidence is inescapable, and unmisinterpretable, that glaciers are melting and the arctic is getting warmer -- so yes, I believe global warming is indeed happening.

I believe global warming is man-made - Obviously, this choice would only be meaningful if you believe the earth really is getting warmer. Given that belief, have the experts also convinced you that GW is caused by extra carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, which in turn is caused by humans burning carbon? (Coal, oil = carbon.)
For my own part, as far as I can see, the acknowledged consensus of scientists is that the GW = CO2 link is still nothing more than speculation and computer modelling. There is no actual proof that extra CO2 is to blame.
Furthermore, even if extra CO2 in the atmosphere really is the cause of GW, I have seen nothing that convinces me that the extra CO2 has been caused by humans burning carbon.
How about you? Do you think GW is mankind's fault, or not>

I believe closing power stations and going by bus will bring the glaciers back. - Again, obviously, this choice would only be meaningful if you accept the first two choices.

For my own part, since I do not believe there is any evidence that humans are causing GW, it follows that I don't believe humans can do anything to change it.
How about you? Do you believe we should go where Al Gore, and our own David Suzuki, want to lead us?


That all seems to follow sensibly enough. Why the critical comments?

And which box do you check if you don't believe the earth is getting warmer?

Now does it make sense?

I'm happy that you started this discussion. Very entertaining.

I'm also happy that you're not charged with collecting any official data about global warming.