Global Warming - What Do You Believe?

Do you believe what you hear about global warming?

  • I believe the earth is getting warmer

    Votes: 15 41.7%
  • I believe global warming is man made

    Votes: 20 55.6%
  • I believe closing power stations and gong by bus will bring the glaciers back

    Votes: 1 2.8%

  • Total voters
    36

buttercup

Active member
Feb 28, 2005
2,564
11
38
I don't want to hear that David (someone-should-so-something) Suzuki says we should reduce our carbon footprint. What I want to know is whether "they" have actually convinced you that closing power stations and going by bus will bring the glaciers back?
 
The evidence is overwhelming, and the stakes are very high. If left unchecked, global warming will destroy the planet as we know it. We all need to do are part to combat it.
 
There's little doubt the glaciers are receding (northern hemisphere anyway). But I don't think it has been proved, at all, that this is due to human action. And I don't have the slightest degree of faith that anything we can do would change it.
 
Denying Climate Change is like believing in Creationism.
 
It's similar to the discussion back in the sixties and early seventies about the affects of cigarettes on a person's health. Smokers and the tobacco companies said there was no proof to confirm that smoking led to poor health and shortened life spans...... They kinda gave up that argument once study after study showed conclusive proof.

Now, that would be a great thread.....why are people still smoking
 
Maybe its too early on a Sunday morning and I realize that I still need more coffee, but this poll doesn't seem to make sense. The question is:

Do you believe what you hear about global warming?

I believe the earth is getting warmer
I believe global warming is man made
I believe closing power stations and gong (going) by bus will bring the glaciers back

Shouldn't the second statement read: "I do not believe global warming is man made"
 
Macator2003 said:
Maybe its too early on a Sunday morning and I realize that I still need more coffee, but this poll doesn't seem to make sense. The question is:

Do you believe what you hear about global warming?

I believe the earth is getting warmer
I believe global warming is man made
I believe closing power stations and gong (going) by bus will bring the glaciers back

Shouldn't the second statement read: "I do not believe global warming is man made"

No

Typically a poll is designed to get desired results.
 
I believe...

...that global warming is real, and some portion of it (and i do not know to what degree) has been caused by man, but the consequences and associated recommended actions by many grossly exaggerate the issue, and hence erode their credibility.

What those who are mildly / appropriately green need to do is two fold:

1) Tell the green Nazi's who are turning everyone else off to STFU. They are accomplishing nothing but creating a movement against going green on the far right, and causing people int he center to tune out the green message. Just as an example...people are NOT going to give up cars...so stop telling them to, and instead do what you can to encourage more reasonable vehicle use. So much can be done with incremental, relatively painless changes (like getting rid of hot water tanks and going with tankless in line hot water heaters), this is where the push and focus SHOULD be.

2) Educate people who are green with FACTS and reality so that they stop eroding the credibility of the green cause. For example, I am amused (and not in a good way) every time someone would take shots at my ULEV SUV while they were sitting on a two cycle engine scooter with NO EMISSION CONTROLS!! Those scooters put more pollutants in the air in a day than my SUV would in a week or more.

http://cleantechnica.com/2008/06/23...as-powered-lawn-mower-vs-the-push-reel-mower/

"According to the EPA the average gas-powered lawn mower emits as much pollution per hour as 11 automobiles do during that same time span. Why? The lawn mower engine is a two-cycle engine which pumps out over 90 times more pollution per gallon of gas than any car or truck."


If green warriors would focus less on spewing knee jerk hate (did you know it takes more energy to make a gallon of ethanol than EXISTS in a gallon of ethanol?? And what type of energy is used to make ethanol? Electricity...which is produced by burning coal...which is a hell of a lot dirtier than burning gas...) and actual rational facts, they would be more persuasive.
 
It is called a natural cycle, global warming is bull$hit.
What are the tree huggers gonna say we shoudl do when we head for an ice age? Fire up the coal burners?

I mean, do what you can to help the environment, we aren't here to trash the place but I don't believe that as a whole we have enough power to drastically change the fate of the earth.
 
Global warming is a liberal lie designed to raise taxes and curtail my consumption of freedom. How's that?


This poll is retarded. The choices offered are not mutually exclusive, nor do they offer a complete range of options. They don't even talk about the same thing!!

All you can do is agree with the underlying premise that a) Global Warming exists
b) it is man's fault
c) it is reversible

This is an anonymous forum where everyone's ignorant opinion holds equal weight and we can all do Internet searches and cut and paste stuff to support our position.

Global warming is a liberal lie designed to raise taxes and curtail my consumption of freedom. How's that?
 
papasmerf said:
No

Typically a poll is designed to get desired results.

Agreed Papa, but I believe the "desired results" in this case will not be obtained with the three choices. They are very similar. How do you vote if you don't believe.

Buttercup noted in his reply to Stinkynuts:

"There's little doubt the glaciers are receding (northern hemisphere anyway). But I don't think it has been proved, at all, that this is due to human action. And I don't have the slightest degree of faith that anything we can do would change it."

If you agree with Buttercup (we gotta change some of our handles), which choice do you select.....
 
The history of recorded events by humans is very short relative to the age of the planet.
The planet is constantly changing over long periods of time
Only 20,000 years ago 97% of Canada was covered in ice
http://www.nature.ca/notebooks/englIsh/iceage.htm
It could very well be the planet is still warming due to event that happened 200,000 years ago & the effect humans have is not at all relevant

That being said, it would be arrogant & irresponsible of the human race to ignore our possible impact
Reducing our "foot print" is wise, however there must a balance
Davis Suzuki is too extreme & his policies would kill economic development world wide.
Poverty leads to anarchy (inflation, job loss >>>> riots, revolution, Islamic terriorts)
Lets find a balance
 
No one thing will save the world, but tiny steps will help. The problem I think is that in the developing nations (China, India) their use of fossil fuels iis just getting started. If those nations don't get on board, most of what we do will be cancelled out.

I am a huge user (for an individual) of gas... SUV, boat etc. I am trying to do what I can on other ways.... I recently bout a small second car to use to commute etc. and only ise the truck whe required. I figure if I plant about 4,000 trees in my yard, that should do it!
 
Sasha Jones said:
It is called a natural cycle, global warming is bull$hit.
What are the tree huggers gonna say we shoudl do when we head for an ice age? Fire up the coal burners?

I mean, do what you can to help the environment, we aren't here to trash the place but I don't believe that as a whole we have enough power to drastically change the fate of the earth.

DING DING DING

We have a winner and somebody that gets it.
 
buttercup said:
I don't want to hear that David (someone-should-so-something) Suzuki says we should reduce our carbon footprint. What I want to know is whether "they" have actually convinced you that closing power stations and going by bus will bring the glaciers back?
Your simplistic question and poll shine a light on your superficial understanding of this issue.
 
Sasha Jones said:
It is called a natural cycle, global warming is bull$hit.
What are the tree huggers gonna say we shoudl do when we head for an ice age? Fire up the coal burners?

I mean, do what you can to help the environment, we aren't here to trash the place but I don't believe that as a whole we have enough power to drastically change the fate of the earth.

JohnLarue said:
The history of recorded events by humans is very short relative to the age of the planet.
The planet is constantly changing over long periods of time
Only 20,000 years ago 97% of Canada was covered in ice
http://www.nature.ca/notebooks/englIsh/iceage.htm
It could very well be the planet is still warming due to event that happened 200,000 years ago & the effect humans have is not at all relevant

That being said, it would be arrogant & irresponsible of the human race to ignore our possible impact
Reducing our "foot print" is wise, however there must a balance
Davis Suzuki is too extreme & his policies would kill economic development world wide.
Poverty leads to anarchy (inflation, job loss >>>> riots, revolution, Islamic terriorts)
Lets find a balance

Two very good answers. Not much more to say.

As an aside, and not really to support any arguments, Michael Chrichton wrote a book called "State of Fear". Not the best book I've ever read, OK for a plane ride. It's fiction of course, but it does present an interesting, fictitious, look at the possible politics and motivations involved in keeping the global warming fear alive and well.
 
Why I recanted
'There is no evidence to support the idea that carbon emissions cause significant global warming'

David Evans, Financial Post Published: Saturday, August 30, 2008
<snip>
1. The greenhouse signature is missing. We have been looking and measuring for years, and cannot find it.
<snip>
2. There is no evidence to support the idea that carbon emissions cause significant global warming. None.
<snip>
3. The satellites that measure the world's temperature all say that the warming trend ended in 2001, and that the temperature has dropped about 0.6 degrees Celsius in the past year (to the temperature of 1980).
<snip>
4. The new ice cores show that in the past six global warmings over the past half a million years, the temperature rises occurred on average 800 years before the accompanying rise in atmospheric carbon. Which says something important about which was cause and which was effect.

None of these points are controversial. The alarmist scientists agree with them, though they would dispute their relevance.
<snip>
So far that debate has just consisted of a simple sleight of hand: show evidence of global warming, and while the audience is stunned at the implications, simply assert that it is due to carbon emissions.

In the minds of the audience, the evidence that global warming has occurred becomes conflated with the alleged cause, and the audience hasn't noticed that the cause was merely asserted, not proved.
IF what this article purports to be true, and IF in fact the science behind global warming is bogus and has been disproved, then I would be facinated to know which reputable scientific journals have published Mr. Evans' allegations. The fact that the National Post would publish an article trashing the link between global warming and carbon emissions is hardly surprising. It would carry more credibility in a scientific journal like some of the following, copied from David Suzuki's web site
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/306/5702/1686:
The scientific consensus is clearly expressed in the reports of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Created in 1988 by the World Meteorological Organization and the United Nations Environmental Programme, IPCC's purpose is to evaluate the state of climate science as a basis for informed policy action, primarily on the basis of peer-reviewed and published scientific literature (3). In its most recent assessment, IPCC states unequivocally that the consensus of scientific opinion is that Earth's climate is being affected by human activities: "Human activities ... are modifying the concentration of atmospheric constituents ... that absorb or scatter radiant energy. ... [M]ost of the observed warming over the last 50 years is likely to have been due to the increase in greenhouse gas concentrations" [p. 21 in (4)].

IPCC is not alone in its conclusions. In recent years, all major scientific bodies in the United States whose members' expertise bears directly on the matter have issued similar statements. For example, the National Academy of Sciences report, Climate Change Science: An Analysis of Some Key Questions, begins: "Greenhouse gases are accumulating in Earth's atmosphere as a result of human activities, causing surface air temperatures and subsurface ocean temperatures to rise" [p. 1 in (5)]. The report explicitly asks whether the IPCC assessment is a fair summary of professional scientific thinking, and answers yes: "The IPCC's conclusion that most of the observed warming of the last 50 years is likely to have been due to the increase in greenhouse gas concentrations accurately reflects the current thinking of the scientific community on this issue" [p. 3 in (5)].
The scientific journals referenced here (go to the source at the link above to see references) seem to contradict what Evans claims and in my opinion carry more credibility and weight than the National Post.
 
How do clouds form?
Clouds form when water evaporates from rivers, ponds, oceans, and lakes. The air containing this evaporated water vapor rises and expands at higher altitudes where the air pressure is lower. The expanding air cools, and as this cooling occurs, the water vapor condenses (changes) from a vapor to a liquid. Many tiny water droplets form and a cloud is born.

Conditions have to be just right for clouds to form. Nature needs tiny droplets of water, something for the droplets to cling to (particles like dust, salt, or smoke) and the right temperature.
 
In April 2008, Professor Terry Sloan of Lancaster University published a paper in the journal Environmental Research Letters titled "Testing the proposed causal link between cosmic rays and cloud cover",[9] which found no significant link between cloud cover and cosmic ray intensity in the last 20 years

Mike Lockwood of the UK's Rutherford Appleton Laboratory and Claus Froehlich of the World Radiation Center in Switzerland published a paper in 2007 which concluded that the increase in mean global temperature observed since 1985 correlates so poorly with solar variability that no type of causal mechanism may be ascribed to it, although they accept that there is "considerable evidence" for solar influence on Earth's pre-industrial climate and to some degree also for climate changes in the first half of the 20th century