"Give Us A Break, Norm" (Warning: do not read this thread)

DonQuixote said:
You're opinion doesn't match up to what's been reported on the 100,000 deaths
estimate.

The report is by Johns Hopkins University and printed in the British medical
journal Lancet. The report was based on legitimate statistical analysis
done by a team that included Iraqi medical doctors. They randomly selected
33 locations around the country and then surveyed households about deaths
in their immediate families or neighborhoods. The survey model and the
numbers have been reviewed for scientific legitimacy by pier reviews.

The numbers are morally challenging and no reasonable person would tolerate
his government being so destructive and inhumane.

As for the suicide bombers we must once again look at the initial invasion and
events during the first six months of occupation. The US military is legally
responsible for the security of the country. Even to this day. The lack of
planning and lack of security that should have been put in place during that
crucial 6 month period has resulted in the lawlessness in Iraq today.

Cheney and Rumsfeld are primarily responsible for this disaster.
Bush was never in the circle. He's a puppet in this endeavor.

Don
Sorry DQ, if "we're" going to start a war on body counts, then 'documented deaths and documented causes of deaths' I believe trumps "estimates" no matter how scientifically based they purport to be. BTW, there are many knowledgable dissenting opinions towards the Lancet "estimate".

Any objective analysis would lead any reasonable person to conclude that since major military operations ceased on May 1, 2003, that it has been the insurgents, terrorists and criminal elements who have been directly responsible for more than 95% of civilian deaths.

"Responsibility" to safeguard civilians during "warfare" and "transition" phases towards stability certainly is valid, but if you are aware of strategies and tactics that can have an immediate or short-term effect in stopping lunatics from strapping on suicide belts and driving suicide vehicles into markets, Mosques, hospitals, crowds of children playing, then please share this with American commanders and Israeli, Jordanian, Indonesian, Russian etc security forces.

Rummy flush with delusions of "war on the cheap", and "victory using surrogates" in Afghanistan did not properly prepare the military "as it was best abled to" for post-May 1/03 Iraq.
 
Last edited:
rogerstaubach said:
Any objective analysis would lead any reasonable person to conclude that since major military operations ceased on May 1, 2003, that it has been the insurgents, terrorists and criminal elements who have been directly responsible for more than 95% of civilian deaths.
Nope, not a chance. Direct US responsibility is around 35-40%, from the stats published here. That strikes me as a credible figure. Trouble is, since all the deaths have occurred undee the aegis of the US occupation, there is a perfectly reasonable case to be made for the US being responsible for all the deaths. If your nephew gets caught in a crossfire, do you think you'll care that it was an insurgent bullet that killed him, and not an American one? You'll blame both sides, but especially the Americans for being there in the first place. Since they get their information from direct experience and not Rush Limbaugh, Iraqis are aware of all the idiotic things the US has done to provoke trouble: firing the civil service, privatizing everything, putting oil revenue ownership under a cloud, using American (and, whenever possible Iraqi) troops (and police) to guard private economic interests.

Don't forget, George W Bush's one truly great talent is his genius for alienating world opinion. On Sept 12, 2001, American popularity was probably higher than it has ever been. By next April or so, it was lower than a snake's belly. The good will of anti-Saddam Iraqis--the majority of the population, by all accounts--has been pissed away every bit as foolishly.

MW
 
maxweber said:
Nope, not a chance. Direct US responsibility is around 35-40%, from the stats published here. That strikes me as a credible figure. Trouble is, since all the deaths have occurred undee the aegis of the US occupation, there is a perfectly reasonable case to be made for the US being responsible for all the deaths. If your nephew gets caught in a crossfire, do you think you'll care that it was an insurgent bullet that killed him, and not an American one? You'll blame both sides, but especially the Americans for being there in the first place. Since they get their information from direct experience and not Rush Limbaugh, Iraqis are aware of all the idiotic things the US has done to provoke trouble: firing the civil service, privatizing everything, putting oil revenue ownership under a cloud, using American (and, whenever possible Iraqi) troops (and police) to guard private economic interests.

Don't forget, George W Bush's one truly great talent is his genius for alienating world opinion. On Sept 12, 2001, American popularity was probably higher than it has ever been. By next April or so, it was lower than a snake's belly. The good will of anti-Saddam Iraqis--the majority of the population, by all accounts--has been pissed away every bit as foolishly.

MW
Insurgents, terrorists and criminal elements are directly responsible for 95% of civilian deaths since May 1/03.

If my nephew is blown to bits by a suicide bomber, or if he is beheaded by terrorists, or if he is executed by insurgents I will blame those responsible. That being terrorists, insurgents, and criminal elements.
 
maxweber said:
Nope, not a chance. Direct US responsibility is around 35-40%, from the stats published here. That strikes me as a credible figure. Trouble is, since all the deaths have occurred undee the aegis of the US occupation, there is a perfectly reasonable case to be made for the US being responsible for all the deaths. If your nephew gets caught in a crossfire, do you think you'll care that it was an insurgent bullet that killed him, and not an American one? You'll blame both sides, but especially the Americans for being there in the first place. Since they get their information from direct experience and not Rush Limbaugh, Iraqis are aware of all the idiotic things the US has done to provoke trouble: firing the civil service, privatizing everything, putting oil revenue ownership under a cloud, using American (and, whenever possible Iraqi) troops (and police) to guard private economic interests.

Don't forget, George W Bush's one truly great talent is his genius for alienating world opinion. On Sept 12, 2001, American popularity was probably higher than it has ever been. By next April or so, it was lower than a snake's belly. The good will of anti-Saddam Iraqis--the majority of the population, by all accounts--has been pissed away every bit as foolishly.

MW

OK MAX

I will ask you the same question

What methodolgy did you use to extrapolate the data.

You gate a 35 to 40% factor in the deaths.

I would be interested in seeing the formulas you used and running the proofs if the formulas pan out as unbiased.
 
DonQuixote said:
You totally misunderstand the estimates. The deaths are a result of all activities
or lack thereof. The collateral damage of dead Iraqis is the failure of the US
to meet the needs of the population. They may be from direct actions and
the loss of life from a failure to provide for the basic needs of the civilians.
Were you to read the report you would understand the total casualty count.

Such a waste of intellegent thought on a sqweegy kid. Let him yap. He's here do one thing. Paint everyone who disagrees with Israeli expansion in the region a baby killing terrorist. If I'm not mistaken it makes him a Zionist. I am of course a racist and card holding member of the Aryian Nation for pointing that out. He's like a spray can without ears of verbal warmongering abuse.

The road to damascus will be paved with a lot of dead bodies. It's the Wolfowitz and Feith vision.
 
DonQuixote said:
You totally misunderstand the estimates. The deaths are a result of all activities
or lack thereof. The collateral damage of dead Iraqis is the failure of the US
to meet the needs of the population. They may be from direct actions and
the loss of life from a failure to provide for the basic needs of the civilians.
Were you to read the report you would understand the total casualty count.
Hey DQ, I've read the iraqbodycount.net website for many, many months and that is why i am able to state that since May 1/03 civilian deaths due to indirect American military actions(colateral deaths) is less than 3000 and this I have repeatedly stated on Terb. Furthermore since May 1/03, civilian deaths attributed to the direct actions of terrorists, insurgents and criminal elements has been between 17,000-20,000.

The total deaths of between 27,000 and 30,000 which Iraqbodycount.net state have occurred since the beginning of "Operation Iraqi Freedom" include deaths due to a breakdown of law and order, lack of sanitation and healthcare. "Providing for law and order, sanitation and healthcare are a binding obligation according to the Geneva Convention and The Hague". So I understand your point of view.

That said, reports of deprivation or deaths due to lack of food, sanitation and healthcare are very rare, if existant at all. Reports of terrorists, insurgents, and criminal elements murdering and maiming innocent civilians are sadly commonplace. In fact between 17,000-20,000 since May 1/03.

As I stated before if you are aware of any immediate or short-term tactics that could prevent insurgents, terrorists and criminal elements who are hellbent on murdering civilians then please inform the populace and governments of these civilians so that they can take actions to prevent these atrocities from occurring.

Anyway, these are the facts.
 
DonQuixote said:
The Johns Hopkins study is the only one that is scientifically
verifiable. Its based on statistical analysis based on the entire
country's loss of life. Its a survey of all deaths directly or
indirectly resulting from the war.

The other sites referring to Iraqi fatalities are not based on
statistically significant studies. Understand, the sites you
refer to are more anectdotal than analytical.

War is the devil's playground. Death is the norm and not
the exception. Lack of medical care and collateral damage
can greatly increase the body count. I'm not proud of these
fatality numbers. They torment me when the numbers don't
numb me.

Don.

PS: I too have blood on my hands.
There have been many, many differing opinions regarding the Lancet study. 3,000 plus "reported" incidents detailed on Iraqbodycount is hardly anectdotal. Quite the contrary, it is detailed and factual and not an analytical study and is much more closer to the truth than any other study.

What did Stalin say? "One death is a tragedy. One million deaths is a statistic."
 
Mcluhan said:
Such a waste of intellegent thought on a sqweegy kid. Let him yap. He's here do one thing. Paint everyone who disagrees with Israeli expansion in the region a baby killing terrorist. If I'm not mistaken it makes him a Zionist. I am of course a racist and card holding member of the Aryian Nation for pointing that out. He's like a spray can without ears of verbal warmongering abuse.

The road to damascus will be paved with a lot of dead bodies. It's the Wolfowitz and Feith vision.
From intelligent debate with DQ, to the depths of insanity with the above. Go figure.;)
 
harleycharley said:
iraqbodycount for example onlyh counts deaths that it finds reported in two mainstream news sources. they themselves say that there are far more death's then are reported. when in the opening day s of the war bunker busters killed hundreds of innocent civlians, obliterating their bodies, the individual deaths did not appear in newspapers and thus were not counted by iraqbodycount.com.....
Wrong again harley. Casualty reports are derived from a "comprehensive" online survey of media web sites, media reports and by reports of contributing sources. Not the "two mainstream news sources" that you opined.
 
DonQuixote said:
So, if there's no journalists around then there's no deaths, eh?
Using media reports as your authority is anything but reliable.:confused:
This has been the most "media covered" conflict in history. The scope and depth of the media coverage in this conflict is exponentially greater than any other. Information from broadcast, print, internet, satellite, cable, etc both objective and subjective. Information, disinformation. Fact and rumors. Relevance and propoganda.

The facts about "civilian deaths" are there on iraqbodycount.net. And since May1/03 insurgents, terrorists and criminal elements have been the direct cause of 95% of civilian deaths in Iraq. 17,000-20,000 innocent Iraqi men, women and little children intentionally targeted and gruesomely murdered by insurgents, terrorsists and criminal elements since May1/03.

These are the detailed facts.

You'd have to be completely blind, deaf and dumb to the constant media reports of "terrorists car bomb kills 42 civilians, suicide bomber kills 27 children, 72 men praying at a Mosque slaughtered by terrorists" etc, etc, etc, that has been reported on almost a daily basis for almost 2 years now to believe other wise.

A "Probability Study" such as the Lancet Report is based on suppositions that may or may not be true and has been widely criticized by many, many, knowledgeable sources. Any reasonable person would believe that detailed evidence is much more factual and truthful than an "academic analysis of probability".
 
harleycharley said:
i've got rogerstabach on Ignore, but i see by his response quoted in your post DQ that i wasnt clear. i didnt mean that iraqbodycount only uses two media sources but that they only count death's coroborated in at least two of their media sources'.

even iraqbody count say's "It is likely that many if not most civilian casualties will go unreported by the media. That is the sad nature of war."

so since theyre only counting deaths that are reported in at least two of there media sources, if theyre saying that MOST civilan casualties go unreported, that would mean there are over 60,000 deaths, not the 30,000 they have counted......

and note that their counting is by their admission "civilians reported killed" not "civlians killed".
Good point harley. This means that terrorists, insurgents and criminal elements are directly responsible for the intentional targeting and gruesome slaughter and murder of 45,500-48,500 innocent Iraqi men, women and children since May 1/03.

Thanx for the clarification. It certainly portrays the terrorists, insurgents, and criminal elements for what they are.
 
DonQuixote said:
Lets just say we have a difference of opinion. Regardless of the number of
media types, they are not equally distributed throughout the country. Most likely
they are in the largest cities for various security and job related issues.

Your dispute about the use of probability studies is considered to be critical
by those that use such models to determine population trends, etc.

We just disagree. I personally think your position is not tenable. The Lancet
study is the most objective study to date.
Population studies have more consistent time and condition based variables. Whereas a study such as conducted by the Lancet project is much more susceptible to time and condition variables which inherently makes it much less reliable, accurate and truthful. Too many variables based on time and conditions predisposes it to unreliability.

Evidence is fact. Probability is a supposition and not fact.
 
DonQuixote said:
But your use of media reports is incomplete evidence.
Probability studies are far more accurate than scewed
evidence from media reports. Were the reporters equally
distributed across the country the size of California your
reliability factor would be much higher. But, they aren't.
Also, they don't account for illnesses and injuries. Only
deaths resulting from conflicts.
Evidence trumps suppositions based on probability. The evidence (ie: a death) is not "skewed", it is a fact. This is the most widely covered conflict in history, exponentially so.

The Iraqbodycount includes deaths attributable to "a breakdown of law and order, inadequate sanitation, food and healthcare".
 
DonQuixote said:
It is evidence, that I agree. It is not comprehensive in its scope.
Nor does it compare the mortality rate prior to the invasion. A key
point by the way. Your approach does not provide a base line
that can only be determined by statistical analysis.
The iraqbodycount is evidentuary, is factual and is as comprehensive and complete a report as there is available. A database of 3,000 plus reported incidents provides a very detailed and reliable a report into civilians deaths.

It does not suppose about "probabilty" based on variables that are too inconsistent and variable to be considered accurate and reliable.

To state that terrorists, insurgents and criminal elements have been directly responsible for the intentional targeting and horrific murder of 17,000-20,000 innocent Iraqi men, women and children since may 1/03 is not a supposition nor is not a probability based on inconsistent variables. It is a statement of evidence, a statement of fact, a statement of truth, and a statement of sheer horrific reality.

BTW, Iraqbodycount DOES provide a baseline. That baseline is ZERO.
 
DonQuixote said:
It is evidence, that I agree. It is not comprehensive in its scope.
Nor does it compare the mortality rate prior to the invasion. A key
point by the way. Your approach does not provide a base line
that can only be determined by statistical analysis.

Didn't UNICEF state that 35,000 children under the age of 10 were dieing every year in Iraq, some due to the UN for bribe sanctions? That would be a start of a baseline, you could add rapes, other murder and disappearances...... I think you'd end up with a pretty brutal picture of pre-war Iraq not highlighted in Mr. Mooreon's latest propaganda film.

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Didn't UNICEF state that 35,000 children under the age of 10 were dieing every year in Iraq, some due to the UN for bribe sanctions? That would be a start of a baseline, you could add rapes, other murder and disappearances...... I think you'd end up with a pretty brutal picture of pre-war Iraq not highlighted in Mr. Mooreon's latest propaganda film.

OTB

I can understand (and accept) the argument that the UN food bribe scandal contributed to the increased infant mortality rate, but I’m sure you are fair minded enough to also account for the human cost of war and the prolonged effects of war sanctions on iraqi society in general.

In addition to proper accounting, there is also the responsibility for war, which can not be layed off on the UN's shoulders. By that I mean, It now seems likely that the US plan for a war of aggression dates back to about 1993; (assuming the nation takes ownership for deeds of the Cabal that executed the war plan. Or maybe they are a splinter group, and do not represent the moral majority. This matter could come before the courts eventually)


What the unicef report said:

The surveys reveal that in the south and center of Iraq -- home to 85 per cent of the country's population -- under-5 mortality more than doubled from 56 deaths per 1000 live births (1984-1989) to 131 deaths per 1000 live births (1994-1999). Likewise infant mortality -- defined as the death of children in their first year -- increased from 47 per 1000 live births to 108 per 1000 live births within the same time frame. The surveys indicate a maternal mortality ratio in the south and center of 294 deaths per 100,000 live births over the ten-year period 1989 to 1999.

Ms. Bellamy noted that if the substantial reduction in child mortality throughout Iraq during the 1980s had continued through the 1990s, there would have been half a million fewer deaths of children under-five in the country as a whole during the eight year period 1991 to 1998. As a partial explanation, she pointed to a March statement of the Security Council Panel on Humanitarian Issues which states: "Even if not all suffering in Iraq can be imputed to external factors, especially sanctions, the Iraqi people would not be undergoing such deprivations in the absence of the prolonged measures imposed by the Security Council and the effects of war."

BTW...Saddam was an evil guy I know. I have not checked Baghdad's stats 1980 to 1993 but here are some interesting NCY stats to think about, comparatively that is. Might be good to check the frame of reference of what normal is for you, as regards infant mortality and child poverty.

25% of New Yorkers are children.


Some stats on The Big Apple

762,000 children live in poverty.

181 babies are born into poverty each day.

10,000 children are homeless. This number has doubled since 1988.

In addition to these sad statistics, many New York City children read and do math below grade level. An estimated 38.9% of the city's school children will graduate high school, compared to 68.8% for all American students.

How the USA Stacks Up

Among the 21 most affluent nations, the United States has the highest percentage of poor children. In fact, our rate is twice that of the country next in line.

http://www.heartsandminds.org/articles/childpov.htm
 
DonQuixote said:
When a foreign power invades a sovereign country and topples
its government, that foreign power becomes primarily responsible
for the security of the country and its people. When the US
invaded Iraq the US became primarily responsible for all
security in the country.

The crimes you refer to are occuring under the auspices of
the US. Fact is, it may very well be the case that the US
occupation of Iraq has been the direct cause of these
crimes. We opened the pandora box and now we have
to deal with the moral and legal breakdown in Iraq.
Let me get this straight here DQ. You are stating that the DIRECT CAUSE of the intentional targeting and gruesome murder and slaughter of between 17,000 and 20,000 innocent Iraqi men, women and children in markets, on streets, in Mosques, in playgrounds, or those who are just trying to go about their daily lives since May 1/03, by insurgents, terrorists and criminal elements employing tactics such as suicide bombings, suicide car bombings, beheadings, mass executions, IEDs, mortar and RPG fire, and small arms fire is in reality the US occupation and not those who are personally responsible for the atrocities.

This seems like carte blanche, a green light of legal and moral acquiescense to go out and massacre civilians at will since the DIRECT CAUSE is not with those who are actually doing the slaughter but with those who are actually trying to prevent it.

Doesn't make any sense.