Sorry DQ, if "we're" going to start a war on body counts, then 'documented deaths and documented causes of deaths' I believe trumps "estimates" no matter how scientifically based they purport to be. BTW, there are many knowledgable dissenting opinions towards the Lancet "estimate".DonQuixote said:You're opinion doesn't match up to what's been reported on the 100,000 deaths
estimate.
The report is by Johns Hopkins University and printed in the British medical
journal Lancet. The report was based on legitimate statistical analysis
done by a team that included Iraqi medical doctors. They randomly selected
33 locations around the country and then surveyed households about deaths
in their immediate families or neighborhoods. The survey model and the
numbers have been reviewed for scientific legitimacy by pier reviews.
The numbers are morally challenging and no reasonable person would tolerate
his government being so destructive and inhumane.
As for the suicide bombers we must once again look at the initial invasion and
events during the first six months of occupation. The US military is legally
responsible for the security of the country. Even to this day. The lack of
planning and lack of security that should have been put in place during that
crucial 6 month period has resulted in the lawlessness in Iraq today.
Cheney and Rumsfeld are primarily responsible for this disaster.
Bush was never in the circle. He's a puppet in this endeavor.
Don
Any objective analysis would lead any reasonable person to conclude that since major military operations ceased on May 1, 2003, that it has been the insurgents, terrorists and criminal elements who have been directly responsible for more than 95% of civilian deaths.
"Responsibility" to safeguard civilians during "warfare" and "transition" phases towards stability certainly is valid, but if you are aware of strategies and tactics that can have an immediate or short-term effect in stopping lunatics from strapping on suicide belts and driving suicide vehicles into markets, Mosques, hospitals, crowds of children playing, then please share this with American commanders and Israeli, Jordanian, Indonesian, Russian etc security forces.
Rummy flush with delusions of "war on the cheap", and "victory using surrogates" in Afghanistan did not properly prepare the military "as it was best abled to" for post-May 1/03 Iraq.
Last edited:

