German Army Snipers - can you find them?

Yes but air forces don't win wars as they say.

Armies do.

Bullshit. Team effort. You can have the largest, best equipped, most well trained land force in the world. If they're completely pinned down by non-stop bombing, they're useless. Same goes for artillery. If you've got amazing artillery, your enemies overwhelming numbers and equipment won't help.

Grunts are one piece of the puzzle. Yes, at the end of the day they need to walk up to the enemy commander, shove a gun and his face and order his surrender. But they can't get there alone. When I said "This is where the air force wins", I was talking about the game of "where's the sniper." The answer is that a rough estimate is good enough. If you're relying on a bullet, you've got to be pretty accurate. That's not the case with airborne de************ systems.
 
Keebler Elf said:
Air force alone does not win wars but if your enemy achieves aerial supremacy you're fucked.

Bullshit. Team effort. You can have the largest, best equipped, most well trained land force in the world. If they're completely pinned down by non-stop bombing, they're useless. Same goes for artillery. If you've got amazing artillery, your enemies overwhelming numbers and equipment won't help.

Grunts are one piece of the puzzle. Yes, at the end of the day they need to walk up to the enemy commander, shove a gun and his face and order his surrender. But they can't get there alone. When I said "This is where the air force wins", I was talking about the game of "where's the sniper." The answer is that a rough estimate is good enough. If you're relying on a bullet, you've got to be pretty accurate. That's not the case with airborne de************ systems.


The U.S. had air superiority in Viet Nam but they lost.

The Soviets had air superiority in Afghanistan but they lost.

Air superiority is a great thing to have, but less effective in a guerrilla war.
 
Bullshit. Team effort. You can have the largest, best equipped, most well trained land force in the world. If they're completely pinned down by non-stop bombing, they're useless. Same goes for artillery. If you've got amazing artillery, your enemies overwhelming numbers and equipment won't help.

Grunts are one piece of the puzzle. Yes, at the end of the day they need to walk up to the enemy commander, shove a gun and his face and order his surrender. But they can't get there alone. When I said "This is where the air force wins", I was talking about the game of "where's the sniper." The answer is that a rough estimate is good enough. If you're relying on a bullet, you've got to be pretty accurate. That's not the case with airborne de************ systems.

Enough of this line of argument. Like JOSHUA says, "The only winning move is not to play".

6/9 including the easy one. (and seeing them isn't the right word, more like figuring out where they could be.
 
Bullshit. Team effort. You can have the largest, best equipped, most well trained land force in the world. If they're completely pinned down by non-stop bombing, they're useless. Same goes for artillery. If you've got amazing artillery, your enemies overwhelming numbers and equipment won't help.

Grunts are one piece of the puzzle. Yes, at the end of the day they need to walk up to the enemy commander, shove a gun and his face and order his surrender. But they can't get there alone. When I said "This is where the air force wins", I was talking about the game of "where's the sniper." The answer is that a rough estimate is good enough. If you're relying on a bullet, you've got to be pretty accurate. That's not the case with airborne de************ systems.
Sniper & sniper-hunter tactics and methodology have evolved quite a bit over the past few decades, now most likely to result in CQC (which negates the flyboys pretending they're helping out from 15000 ft & 500mph).
 
imgres
257 Russians didn't see this dude:


CR_660963_vasili_zaitsev.jpg

Over 400 Germans didn't see this guy
 
Enough of this line of argument. Like JOSHUA says, "The only winning move is not to play".

6/9 including the easy one. (and seeing them isn't the right word, more like figuring out where they could be.

Not without those hints though.
 
The U.S. had air superiority in Viet Nam but they lost.

The Soviets had air superiority in Afghanistan but they lost.

Air superiority is a great thing to have, but less effective in a guerrilla war.

They also exercised a "limited air war". Hardly a fair comparison.
 
Sniper & sniper-hunter tactics and methodology have evolved quite a bit over the past few decades, now most likely to result in CQC (which negates the flyboys pretending they're helping out from 15000 ft & 500mph).

Sure, they've evolved. Doesn't mean it isn't easier and safer to just put bombs on them. Especially since, as this thread indicates, they can be difficult to pinpoint. And if you say fast-movers aren't helpful, I suggest you go talk to the guys back from overseas that routinely called in air support. I'd sure they'd like to hear how they should've done it themselves and the high flyers were just pretending to help.
 
400? What's with the '242 soldados nazis' in the caption about?

That was just his kills from the 5 week Stalingrad battle. He was over 400 by wars end...at least so says Wiki, but he did kill a quite a few. Who knows what really happened. Great story though. If it was propaganda it was EPIC!!!
 
That was just his kills from the 5 week Stalingrad battle. He was over 400 by wars end...at least so says Wiki, but he did kill a quite a few. Who knows what really happened. Great story though. If it was propaganda it was EPIC!!!

Great, thanks. Was this the subject of that movie with Jude Law?
 
They also exercised a "limited air war". Hardly a fair comparison.

Oh come now. They used LG bombs and carpet bombed enemy targets and the Ho Chi Min Trail. What else could they bomb? The entire jungle? You don`t mean nukes do you? :)

The point is, even with air superiority, they couldn't defeat the enemy.
 
Oh come now. They used LG bombs and carpet bombed enemy targets and the Ho Chi Min Trail. What else could they bomb? The entire jungle? You don`t mean nukes do you? :)

The point is, even with air superiority, they couldn't defeat the enemy.

You might want to grab a book on Vietnam War history. The language used in virtually all official documents was "limited". Even Rolling Thunder was limited in scope. The fear was that if they treated it the way they would've treated a "real war", they'd anger the Chinese and the Russians and ignite WWIII. At no point was USAF ever allowed to conduct air operation to the scope they wanted to. Not to mention there was little to no coordination. If you review WWII, you'll see that strategic bombing coincided with movements on the ground. Most of the Vietnam campaigns had nothing to do with what was going on in the south.

This is what's meant by a limited campaign. Think of the Battle of Ia Drang. When Hastings (not Moore as the movie suggested) decided to enact Broken Arrow. At that moment, 29 close support aircraft were called in and 5 B-52's. A total of 740 close support sorties and 96 heavy bombing sorties. On average, payload was delivered on LZ Xray and Albany every 15 minutes. That's an unlimited air war. That is what air support can do. A unit that was overrun and on the verge of breaking was pushed back from the brink because of CAS and heavy bombing runs. Helicopters alone delivered 33,108 105mm roungs and 7,356 2,75" rockets. That was 4 days. For 4 days, ordinance was delivered on a single valley every 15 minutes. The rest of the war didn't go that way. Most of the bombing, even during Rolling Thunder and Linebacker II, was against strategic targets in North Vietnam, not direct attacks in support of ground operations. And really, those are the only 2 major air operations of the war. Rolling Thunder lasted 3 years, but had as a primary purpose, to discourage North Vietnam from accepting assistance from China and other communist powers. It was heavily marred by civilian "oversight" (aka meddling) that overruled the desires and needs of the commanders. While it was "sustained air operations", it remained limited because of how targets were selected and ordinance dispersed. It also didn't help that the civilians had no concept of the affect the air-defences supplied by China would interfere with their concept of how to conduct an air war, which increased losses and limited the number of sorties that could actually meet their objectives.

The use of close air support was not as widespread in Vietnam as it could have or should have been given the era in which the war existed. They face the same problems with their artillery support was also hamstrung by civilian oversight.

In short, the Vietnam war was a mess. A clusterfuck of epic proportions. It's not an example of how anything be done in war.