Gay Pride??

If "Cute Bald" was still around, he would argue for equality, rights and status for short bald people. Hee, hee, hee. Please, I don't want to be exposed to pics of short bald naked people. No I am not shortbaldphobic. Some of my friends are short and bald.

P.S. Some of you folks take this thread way too seriously.

It's a fun way to spend an afternoon.. Having a mildly intellectual conversation with other gentlemen. In my opinion, what's the point of arguing if you're not going to take it seriously.
 
The issue with a few Terbites is public displays of nudity or highly-suggestive sexual content which are not suitable for viewing by mainstream families.

I wandered by PRIDE and I saw whole families attending. Apparently those families do not agree!
 
Now on the other hand, if it IS political, then politicians certainly shouldn't feel compelled to attend demonstrations and the like. So if it WAS a political march, then Rob Ford was no more required to attend than he was required to march with the Tamils on the Gardiner expressway.

So either way you lose Fuji.

Whether it's political or not is irrelevant.

Fact is, the Gay Pride Parade is a big event approved by the City of Toronto, and normal protocol is for the Mayor to make an appearance.

The Tamil March on the Gardiner or protests are not endorsed or approved by the City of Toronto.

Furthermore, even if the Gay Pride Parade is political, it's about a protest against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation which is prohibited by the Charter of Rights & Freedoms. Therefore, no politician in a democratic society can denounce that.
 
I wandered by PRIDE and I saw whole families attending. Apparently those families do not agree!

I didn't say that mainstream families wouldn't attend (they may have gay sons marching) but that the Terbites who take issue with lewdness object that it's not appropriate for mainstream audiences or families with children. I should have said mainstream families with children. I will edit.
 
Last edited:
Your last point is well taken. I'm still sure more people show up simply because it's plain old fun. But you're quite right. A "Lesbian, Gay, Transexual, Bisexual (and I forget the new one) Parade" wouldn't be very effective if it was devoid of any sexuality.

There are plenty of ways to express your sexuality without exposing genitalia.

And your argument is foolish. Does a pro-porn event have to have people carrying graphic porn? Does a pro seal hunting event have to have people kill seals at it? Does a pro abortion event...
 
There are plenty of ways to express your sexuality without exposing genitalia.

Many of the objections here were to the simulated sex, the flamboyance, etc., none of which inherently involves exposing genitalia. That said Canada appears to have lots of precedent for exposing genitalia at events like PRIDE, and the community appears not only to tolerate it, but by and large to support it. Nobody clamoured for the arrest of the body painted women at the Stanley Cup street party either--and they were actually featured on CBC Television. So... I think it's safe to say that a guy dressed in fetish wear that exposes his genitalia while marching in PRIDE is not clad in a way that offends public decency or order.
 
I didn't say that mainstream families wouldn't attend (they may have gay sons attending) but that the Terbites who take issue with lewdness object that it's not appropriate for mainstream audiences or families with children. I should have said mainstream families with children. I will edit.

I saw families with children in tow attending pride, for clarity. Those families appear not to have any issue. I would bet that's because those families have intelligent conversations with their children, and do not leave their sex education to the mall cop.
 
I saw families with children in tow attending pride, for clarity. Those families appear not to have any issue. I would bet that's because those families have intelligent conversations with their children, and do not leave their sex education to the mall cop.

I'm sure you did, but that doesn't necessarily represent the mainstream nor does it mean that families that don't wish to expose their children to two naked men with cock/ball straps are bad parents.
 
actually what it does is degrade the reputation of gays in general. most straights already see them as somewhat flamboyant and silly when they flaunt their lifestyle choices. elton john is a good example of a decent gay guy. he appears normal. talks normal. but swings different. nobody cares. but if he started showing his weiner on tv, it would be very different. this fetish approach to public life is what is offensive. not the actual mano-a-mano business behind closed doors.
 
I'm sure you did, but that doesn't necessarily represent the mainstream nor does it mean that families that don't wish to expose their children to two naked men with cock/ball straps are bad parents.

No, but parents who are unable to have an intelligent conversation with their children educating them on these issues would be bad parents.
 
actually what it does is degrade the reputation of gays in general.

Before things like PRIDE and its over-the-top celebration of gay sexuality many straight people felt entitled to criticize gays for kissing or holding hands in public. PRIDE has done a *lot* to confront and overturn those views. Yes, it pushes the limits, but in so pushing it has done a world of good for the equality of gays at a social level in our society.

If you think PRIDE and associated efforts weren't directly responsible for that change in public attitudes you have been living under a rock...

To some extent what's happened is that by being so outrageous on pride day and at the public event the far less outrageous "normal" behavior has become acceptable, where it used not to be. By switching the debate to being about whether a guy can walk down the street in fetish gear the issue of holding hands was neutralized into being a non-issue.

PRIDE has been *very* effective.
 
Many of the objections here were to the simulated sex, the flamboyance, etc., none of which inherently involves exposing genitalia. That said Canada appears to have lots of precedent for exposing genitalia at events like PRIDE, and the community appears not only to tolerate it, but by and large to support it. Nobody clamoured for the arrest of the body painted women at the Stanley Cup street party either--and they were actually featured on CBC Television. So... I think it's safe to say that a guy dressed in fetish wear that exposes his genitalia while marching in PRIDE is not clad in a way that offends public decency or order.

Other than your generalizations there is not much suggesting that the community supports exposed genitialia.
 
Other than your generalizations there is not much suggesting that the community supports exposed genitialia.

You're right. Nothing but about a million people attending, including major public figures, many former mayors, a large fraction of the current city council, provincial and federal political leaders, all coming and marching in an event that they all know is going to include some nudity. Other than that enormous showing of support there is nothing much suggesting that the community tolerates it.

Oh and choose your words carefully please: Tolerance is the key, not support. You can say that by marching they don't necessarily support the nudity they are marching with, but they plainly demonstrate their tolerance of it by being there.

Given the presence of community and political leaders not to mention such a large fraction of the community itself attending in support I find it implausible that anyone could win an argument in court that it is not tolerated by the community...
 
Maybe you better re-read the act and look at how "nudity" is defined, it is different than being naked. Again, the gay community would love nothing better than to fight a charge that public political expression of gay sexuality offends public decency.

As usual, the Supremes disagree with you:

http://www.canlii.org/eliisa/highli...scc/doc/1978/1978canlii208/1978canlii208.html

.
But where there is complete nudity without lawful excuse in a public place, proof by the accused that the nudity was compatible with public decency or order is not a defence in my opinion just as proof that the nudity offended against public decency or order is not required from the prosecution. On the other hand, lawful excuse is a full defence even if it is proved that the nudity did offend against public decency or order.

You really need to stay away from legal issues. You get them consistently wrong.
 
You're right. Nothing but about a million people attending, including major public figures, many former mayors, a large fraction of the current city council, provincial and federal political leaders, all coming and marching in an event that they all know is going to include some nudity. Other than that enormous showing of support there is nothing much suggesting that the community tolerates it.

Oh and choose your words carefully please: Tolerance is the key, not support. You can say that by marching they don't necessarily support the nudity they are marching with, but they plainly demonstrate their tolerance of it by being there.

Given the presence of community and political leaders not to mention such a large fraction of the community itself attending in support I find it implausible that anyone could win an argument in court that it is not tolerated by the community...

Well if it was neccessary to argue that...I might care to disagree. But since it is not an element of the offense...who cares?

Sorry law prof...you have blown it yet again.
 
No, but parents who are unable to have an intelligent conversation with their children educating them on these issues would be bad parents.

Which of course entirely depends upon the age of the children their maturity level etc. . . what is an approriate discussion with a 14 or fifteen year-old is almost certainly not an appropriate conversation with a five or six year-old.
 
A hobbyist can still support family values or respect someone's wish to be with their family.

The issue with a few Terbites is public displays of nudity or highly-suggestive sexual content which are not suitable for viewing by mainstream families with children.
Entirely so.
 
Rld your decision does not apply to someone partially clad, such as in fetish wear. Try again.

I am referring to the two chaps in the much posted picture with clearly exposed genitilia. And it is not "my" decision it is the SCC's. And most importantly it proves this statement made by you is completely incorrect:

Originally Posted by fuji
I agree, but I think those who are claiming there is anything illegal about marching that way in PRIDE are just plain wrong. There seems to be a tradition in Canada of tolerating nudity at major public events and particularly for political expression.

I know that you will again refuse to admit you are incorrect, even in the face of the leading SCC case on the subject, but others might learn something both from the case, and your folly.
 
Exposed genitalia is not the same as nude. Your decision defines that to be competely bare. The act makes no special mention of genitalia, instead the test of whether a non-naked person counts as nude is whether they are dressed in a way that offends public decency.

As I've tried to educate you a few times the gay community would love nothing better than an opportunity to fight a charge that political expression of gay sexuality offends public decency. Given the way community standards tests for public decency works, and the presence of so much of the community, and so many community and political leaders in attendance, clearly tolerating their behavior--they'd win.