Garrett Anderson - Baseball HOF Question

maurice93

Well-known member
Mar 29, 2006
6,363
1,357
113
As the HOF question came up in the Pujols thread, I thought of a stat I just saw the other day.

Remember a few years ago when there was the discussion whether Harold Baines would be a HOF'er if he got 3000 hits.

The new more modern test case could be Garrett Anderson. I was surprised to see the other day he had over 2500 hits. He is 37 years old - but 3000 still becomes a possibility. His last year was somewhat mediocore, but he may turn it around a bit, and hang around until he gets 3000.

Anderson has been aided alot by being a free swinger at the plate - lots of singles, few wals, relatively low OBP and OPS.... and he has never reallly had more then gap power except for a few seasons.

If he has four more average seasons, and gets 3000 hits, is Garrett Anderson a Hall of Famer?
 
As the HOF question came up in the Pujols thread, I thought of a stat I just saw the other day.

Remember a few years ago when there was the discussion whether Harold Baines would be a HOF'er if he got 3000 hits.

The new more modern test case could be Garrett Anderson. I was surprised to see the other day he had over 2500 hits. He is 37 years old - but 3000 still becomes a possibility. His last year was somewhat mediocore, but he may turn it around a bit, and hang around until he gets 3000.

Anderson has been aided alot by being a free swinger at the plate - lots of singles, few wals, relatively low OBP and OPS.... and he has never reallly had more then gap power except for a few seasons.

If he has four more average seasons, and gets 3000 hits, is Garrett Anderson a Hall of Famer?

I think not?
Gawd I hope not!
 
Garrett Anderson would be baseball's version of Dino Cicarelli, putting up consistently solid yet unspectacular seasons (with the exceotion of a few years of elevated performance) in an era where scoring is much higher then it ever was.

Interestingly, Dino is one of the few cases where the Hockey Hall has put there foot down despite "milestone" statistics.
 
No. Not all 3,000 hit hitters are equal. Derek Jeter will soon get 3,000 hits but he would be a shoo in HOF even if he quits right now.

But only Biggio, Palmeiro, and of course Rose have 3000 hits and aren't in. None of them are eligible (yet).
 
As someone who plays fantasy baseball I have great appreciation for Garret Anderson. He was always overlooked and I'd snag him later in drafts than he should have gone. Consistency was his forte. Plus he'd never get hurt.

He has great career numbers. A .295 BA, 39th all time in doubles, 79th in RBI, 90th in hits. Individually he was runner up AL R.O.Y. in 1995, he was a 3 time all star, including MVP in 2003. He won the Silver Slugger Award twice, he led the AL in doubles twice and finished 4th in MVP voting in 2002. He has 1 world series championship ring.

But what I think holds him back from being a HOF'er is his low career OBP and his mediocre defense. Even if he gets to 3,000 hits (I don't think he will) he shouldn't make the HOF.
 
Here's another one for you. Johnny Damon.

http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/d/damonjo01.shtml?redir

Turning 36 in November and has 2425 hits. Three more solid years of 150 hits per season and he's there. If he resigns with NY he will get the amount of at bats needed and he's another player who doesn't get hurt much.
 
Anderson, no. Was never a dominant enough player. I'd even argue that outside of one or two seasons, he was never the best player on his own team.

With that said, I doubt the Biggio should be in either. Sure he has 3,000+ hitm but was he ever a dominant 2B? He's the equivalent of Tony Fernandez over a longer period of time. Both good players (who I would want on my team), loved in the cities they played, but did not have that 'ever-lasting' touch. That said, if Biggio gets in for being 'good' for a long time, then Anderson's chances go up, and there will be louder cries for Don Mattingly.
 
I think you'll see less attention paid to the magic numbers for Hall induction going forward. There's been more offense with small parks, PEDs and better conditioning in general. Consider, for example, how many players have joined the 500 home run club in the last ten of fifteen years. It's just not the standout accomplishment it once was. Besides, the voters are becoming more knowledgeable about advanced stats. As we get a new generation of BBWAA voters numbers like OPS+ and VORP will become more important than counting stats.

So no, 3000 hits would not put Garrett Anderson into the Hall. He won't get there anyway. He'd likely need four more seasons of sustained production - his age 38, 39, 30 and 41 years. With a .300 OBP at age 37 I just don't see that happening.
 
Next on the discussion list of borderline candidates - Omar Vizquel.

Pretty much the same career as Ozzie Smith, without the mass appeal and indentity and "FAME" during his playing days.... should "FAME" and appeal during your playing days, be a deciding factor over productivity?
 
Anderson, no. Was never a dominant enough player. I'd even argue that outside of one or two seasons, he was never the best player on his own team.

With that said, I doubt the Biggio should be in either. Sure he has 3,000+ hitm but was he ever a dominant 2B? He's the equivalent of Tony Fernandez over a longer period of time. Both good players (who I would want on my team), loved in the cities they played, but did not have that 'ever-lasting' touch. That said, if Biggio gets in for being 'good' for a long time, then Anderson's chances go up, and there will be louder cries for Don Mattingly.

Anderson certainly no - I think most of us agree.

As for caseyx points that its not likely he gets to 3000.. I wouldn't totally discount it although yes it less then 50%.... - 37 years olds are in better shape, and sometimes bounce back somewhat--- its not a constant decline.

I totally disagree on your assessment of Biggio ... comparing him to Fernandez?? That's selling him way short IMO. I think he is basically comparable to Roberto Alomar which most people think is in the HOF. Biggio was a hell of a defensive player as well.... not quite in Robbie's class, but still 4 gold gloves. Fernandez was not at All-Star Level from the age of 27 onwards.

OPS
Alomar 814
Biggio 796
Fernandez 746

BTW, I smell something wrong with the OPS+ on baseball reference which has Alomar at 116 vs Biggio at 111.... Biggio spent over half his career at the Astrodome which is a pitcher's park... then got the benefit of Enron.

Biggio was much more dominant relative to his positional peers then Garrett Anderson, so I think he is in a different category when he reaches a career milestone. I think both Biggio and Alomar should be in the hall as there generation's 2b representatives.