Garbage Strike - Give Me a Break

Mrbig1949 said:
the left has as many economists as the right who can clearly demonstrate the cost-Benefit analysis of taxation

NOBODY disputes the value of taxation or the usefulness of having the government provision services. I am a big supporter of public health-care for example among many other things. I am hardly right wing.

What you CAN'T demonstrate, and what no economist is going to demonstrate, is that there is any value in OVERPAYING for public services and getting too little benefit for the money spent.

You also won't find any economists claiming that you can create a middle class by over-paying low skilled workers. That does not create wealth and benefit everyone. It makes almost everybody worse off. It is not the same AT ALL as having high quality jobs that bring in good pay--that DOES benefit the whole community, unlike paying garbage men more than they are worth.

If you OVERPAY you get less benefits, fewer schools, worse services.
 
It is not overpaying

fuji said:
NOBODY disputes the value of taxation or the usefulness of having the government provision services. I am a big supporter of public health-care for example among many other things. I am hardly right wing.

What you CAN'T demonstrate, and what no economist is going to demonstrate, is that there is any value in OVERPAYING for public services and getting too little benefit for the money spent.

You also won't find any economists claiming that you can create a middle class by over-paying low skilled workers. That does not create wealth and benefit everyone. It makes almost everybody worse off. It is not the same AT ALL as having high quality jobs that bring in good pay--that DOES benefit the whole community, unlike paying garbage men more than they are worth.

If you OVERPAY you get less benefits, fewer schools, worse services.

It is paying what the job is worth. The private sector underpays labour. That is where this thng called profit comes from.
 
Mrbig1949 said:
It is paying what the job is worth. The private sector underpays labour. That is where this thng called profit comes from.

Dude, picking up trash is not worth $50-60k/year. It's just not. You could hire people to do the job at HALF that rate, and they would happily.

Give your head a shake.
 
Let's make this a little more real so you can understand it, since you are so thick:

Joe, Fred, and Moe are all (un)skilled enough to collect trash. Joe is willing to do the work for $20k, Fred won't do it for less than $30, and Moe wouldn't take the job unless it paid $40k. In other words wages depend on supply and demand. In the city the supply of labour depends on the rate. You have to offer at least $20k before anyone (Joe) will apply. At $30k two people will apply. At $40k three will apply.

The question now is on the demand side. How many collectors does the city demand? It can get three at $40k/ea, two at $30k/ea, or one at $20k. The more labour the city wants, the more expensive it will get.

Let's say the city has collected $60k in taxes, to be spent on garbage collection. If it overpayed at $60k/yr to hire one garbage collector and hire any of the three, leaving the other two unemployed. With one collector residents get garbage pick-up once a week.

OR the city could pay $30k/year, Joe would be ecstatic to get the job for that amount, and Fred would take it too. Now the taxpayers get twice weekly garbage collection and there is only one person unemployed.

Which is better? Paying $60k to one person, or $30k to two?
 
Let's make this a little more real so you can understand it, since you are so thick:

Joe, Fred, and Moe are all (un)skilled enough to collect trash. Joe is willing to do the work for $20k, Fred won't do it for less than $30, and Moe wouldn't take the job unless it paid $40k. In other words wages depend on supply and demand. In the city the supply of labour depends on the rate. You have to offer at least $20k before anyone (Joe) will apply. At $30k two people will apply. At $40k three will apply.

The question now is on the demand side. How many collectors does the city demand? It can get three at $40k/ea, two at $30k/ea, or one at $20k. The more labour the city wants, the more expensive it will get.

Let's say the city has collected $60k in taxes, to be spent on garbage collection. If it overpayed at $60k/yr to hire one garbage collector and hire any of the three, leaving the other two unemployed. With one collector residents get garbage pick-up once a week.

OR the city could pay $30k/year, Joe would be ecstatic to get the job for that amount, and Fred would take it too. Now the taxpayers get twice weekly garbage collection and there is only one person unemployed.

Which is better? Paying $60k to one person, or $30k/ea for two?
 
Trying to debate logically with some members who have been brainwashed by "Big Labour" makes pissing into the wind seem like fun.
 
train said:
Trying to debate logically with some members who have been brainwashed by "Big Labour" makes pissing into the wind seem like fun.
I used to think Fuji’s debates with the 9/11 conspiracy theorists were one sided! I have to say that I respect his patience in being willing to spend hours debating both 9/11 conspiracy theorists and people here who think real wealth can be created out of nothing. I would never have the patience.

One thing I will say that the Scandinavians do right is contracting out garbage collection. As a link I posted in another thread points out, Denmark contracts out 80% of garbage collection.
 
someone said:
One thing I will say that the Scandinavians do right is contracting out garbage collection. As a link I posted in another thread points out, Denmark contracts out 80% of garbage collection.

I am sure all of Scandinavia will be rejoicing in your endorsement of their
policies. Are you trolling for the Nobel prize?:)
 
danmand said:
I am sure all of Scandinavia will be rejoicing in your endorsement of their
policies. Are you trolling for the Nobel prize?:)
My only hope would be the peace prize. They seem to have made some questionable awards lately so perhaps the standards are even low enough even for me! (Just kidding).
 
Like debating with people who have been brainwashed...

train said:
Trying to debate logically with some members who have been brainwashed by "Big Labour" makes pissing into the wind seem like fun.

Like talking to people who have been brainwashed by "Big Capital".

We have a totally unbalanced view of the capital/labour relationship here due to our proximity to the USA. Europe has a much more balanced view. As does the rest of the free world where they regularly elect Labour/Socialist/Social Democrat Parties to government.
 
Mrbig1949 said:
The Scadinavians pay among the highest in the world

They also have the highest suicide and alcoholism rates. Being enslaved by working for the government from Jan 1 to Jun 30 before getting your real first penny (50%+ tax rate) for yourself will do that to people.

Please do look at this chart, the highest places in the world are from around that area:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate



Mrbig1949 said:
there is no tax revolt because they believe the get value for money.

wrong. there is a HUGE verifiable revolt.

http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,4310212,00.html


Mrbig1949 said:
Higher public sector wages equals a higher standard of living for the community

Higher standard of living for individuals = Higher standard of living for the "community"

After all a community is just a bunch on individuals. The "communities" with the lowest standard of living are the ones with most nationalized services for the community. (Cuba, North Korea etc.)




Mrbig1949 said:
When the economy was booming these were the insecure dopes who chose gov't work over getting rich.

Except people in the public sector are not slaves who will work without a PROFIT, and DO care about being rich. Look at this strike, its about money. There would be no monopoly if this was a private service, you could just move on to another competitor.



Mrbig1949 said:
There is a lot of jealousy going around right now about the public sector.


nah, public sector employees always have the guilt that they are getting their salaries through force, not through voluntary transactions. How many people would voluntarily pay a bureaucrat what they make? Not to mention they are judged by EVERYONE, its everyone's business, everyone has a right to intrude, measure and make comments on how to improve their performance. After all they pay taxes.


Mrbig1949 said:
capitalism misallocates resources by creating too many poor people.

(!!!!!!!!!!!!!) Wrong, Capitalism increases equality and raises the living standards of all.

Rich countries contains several times as many billionaires as any other poorer country. If the theory of the rich get rich on the expense of the poor or that a fat man got fat on the expense of a skinny man was true, then ordinary people of those rich countries would be the most poverty stricken people in the world if the wealth of the wealthy derives from the poverty of the poor. They would be even worse condition than those in 3rd world countries.

Conversely, billionaires are much rarer in exactly in those places that are most absolutely poverty stricken.

Most residual hard cases of poverty are a result again of a failure of GOVERNMENT. Welfare dependency is one example.




Mrbig1949 said:
You just assume the private rates are correct because they are set by this invisible hand of the market bull shit that nobody believes any more.

On the contrary, about 80,000 people are being lifted out of poverty EVERYDAY thanks to governments around the world increasing freedom for their people.

Excellent book:

http://www.amazon.com/Three-Billion-New-Capitalists-Wealth/dp/0465062822/

Mrbig1949 said:
We have a totally unbalanced view of the capital/labour relationship here due to our proximity to the USA. Europe has a much more balanced view. As does the rest of the free world where they regularly elect Labour/Socialist/Social Democrat Parties to government.

Mrbig1949 said:
top 5% of who we could EASILY do without.


WHAAAAA??? :eek: What do you suppose they do with the money, keep in under their pillow? Nope they/banks keep investing it and creating jobs for the ordinary person.

What do you suppose the productivity/wage rate of workers of this country would be if the total amount of capital of this country was what it was 100 years ago?

Where do you think the increase in living standard and productivity come from except from the investment by people of their savings?

THANK GOODNESS FOR RICH PEOPLE!! The invisible hand is not really that invisible.



Mrbig1949 said:
You simply cannot escape the FACT that people who think llike you caused THE RECESSION .

Nope. Its amazing how many people still think that. All major downturns in an economy are caused by government interference.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123414310280561945.html
http://news-info.wustl.edu/tips/page/normal/10831.html
http://newsblaze.com/story/20081105145113tsop.nb/topstory.html
http://www.africanexecutive.com/modules/magazine/articles.php?article=3586


Mrbig1949 said:
You don't know shit from shinola, you haven't proven a thing since the start of the debate. Your biggest problem is that you take you assertions and beliefs for facts, they are not FACTS asshole.

Dude you're getting owned LOL

Kudos to fuji and JohnLarue!
 
Mrbig1949 said:
Like talking to people who have been brainwashed by "Big Capital".

We have a totally unbalanced view of the capital/labour relationship here due to our proximity to the USA. Europe has a much more balanced view. As does the rest of the free world where they regularly elect Labour/Socialist/Social Democrat Parties to government.

In the final analysis, it is unquestionable that for a corporation to prosper,
it must have a dedicated and cooperative workforce. Can that be achieved
with unions?: Yes. Can it be achieved without unions? : Yes.
 
Mrbig1949 said:
Like talking to people who have been brainwashed by "Big Capital".

We have a totally unbalanced view of the capital/labour relationship here due to our proximity to the USA. Europe has a much more balanced view. As does the rest of the free world where they regularly elect Labour/Socialist/Social Democrat Parties to government.

I have spent a significant amount of time working in Europe, and I never ran into anybody there who thought that you could create wealth just by raising wages. Sorry.

Europeans certainly do believe in having a strong social safety net and in having government provision some important services--but they also believe in getting value for their money, and in the importance of labour productivity.

In my experience Europeans are much more numbers oriented than Americans are, much more hard nosed about costs versus benefits, much more likely to throw a business case into a spreadsheet and then cancel a project or program or shut down a business if it isn't going to pay for itself.

Americans are much more likely to approve or cancel a project based on how good the story sounds, and pay less attention to to the financial numbers, preferring to back what they see as a good idea rather than getting bogged down in calculating costs and benefits.

If I had to guess I'd say the average European mayor (or at least someone working for the city) could tell you how much economic benefit their city figures it derives from garbage pickup, versus what they pay for it; and similarly I would bet you that neither Miller nor any other North American mayor has tried to work that out.
 
binderman said:
They also have the highest suicide and alcoholism rates. Being enslaved by working for the government from Jan 1 to Jun 30 before getting your real first penny (50%+ tax rate) for yourself will do that to people.
Please do look at this chart, the highest places in the world are from around that area:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate
wrong. there is a HUGE verifiable revolt.
http://www.dw-world.de/dw/article/0,,4310212,00.html
Higher standard of living for individuals = Higher standard of living for the "community"
After all a community is just a bunch on individuals. The "communities" with the lowest standard of living are the ones with most nationalized services for the community. (Cuba, North Korea etc.)
except people in the public sector are not slaves who will work without a PROFIT, and DO care about being rich. Look at this strike, its about money. There would be no monopoly if this was a private service, you could just move on to another competitor.
nah, public sector employees always have the guilt that they are getting their salaries through force, not through voluntary transactions. How many people would voluntarily pay a bureaucrat what they make? Not to mention they are judged by EVERYONE, its everyone's business, everyone has a right to intrude, measure and make comments on how to improve their performance. After all they pay taxes.
(!!!!!!!!!!!!!) Wrong, Capitalism increases equality and raises the living standards of all.
Rich countries contains several times as many billionaires as any other poorer country. If the theory of the rich get rich on the expense of the poor or that a fat man got fat on the expense of a skinny man was true, then ordinary people of those rich countries would be the most poverty stricken people in the world if the wealth of the wealthy derives from the poverty of the poor. They would be even worse condition than those in 3rd world countries.
Conversely, billionaires are much rarer in exactly in those places that are most absolutely poverty stricken.
Most residual hard cases of poverty are a result again of a failure of GOVERNMENT. Welfare dependency is one example.
On the contrary, about 80,000 people are being lifted out of poverty EVERYDAY thanks to governments around the world increasing freedom for their people.
Excellent book:
http://www.amazon.com/Three-Billion-New-Capitalists-Wealth/dp/0465062822/
WHAAAAA??? :eek: What do you suppose they do with the money, keep in under their pillow? Nope they/banks keep investing it and creating jobs for the ordinary person.
What do you suppose the productivity/wage rate of workers of this country would be if the total amount of capital of this country was what it was 100 years ago?
Where do you think the increase in living standard and productivity come from except from the investment by people of their savings?
THANK GOODNESS FOR RICH PEOPLE!! The invisible hand is not really that invisible.
Nope. Its amazing how many people still think that. All major downturns in an economy are caused by government interference.
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123414310280561945.html
http://news-info.wustl.edu/tips/page/normal/10831.html
http://newsblaze.com/story/20081105145113tsop.nb/topstory.html
http://www.africanexecutive.com/modules/magazine/articles.php?article=3586
Dude you're getting owned LOL
Kudos to fuji and JohnLarue!


It takes a certain amount of arrogance, and maybe lack of knowledge, to
postulate that the way things are done in North America is the only reasonable way.

The fact is that both the USA, Canada and northern Europe are democracies, and
therefore the way things are organized is supported by the majority of the people.

In Scandinavia, people put a high value on free health care, free education,
high unemployment benefits and generally a high level of welfare. people are
willing to pay high taxes to support that.

In the USA, the opposite is the case. The majority of people do not want to pay for
universal health care, free education and other welfare programs. Taxes are lower.

Canada is somewhere in the middle between USA and Scandinavia.

The moral of this story is: In all 3 places it is organized the way people want it.
You cannot claim that the Scandinavian countries are not successful, and that
the living standard there is lower than in North America.
 
Well damnmand I would be the last person to make some sweeping claim that the American system is better or worse than some other and I agree with you that each country is organized the way people see fit.

You can however make claims about which system is more efficient, which leads to a higher level of productivity, or to a higher level of wealth.

Americans are significantly richer than either Swedes or Danes in terms of their net purchasing power, although Norway has a slight edge of the US, and Canada and Denmark or Sweden rank similarly, so it's hard to draw a conclusion.
 
Purchasing power on average but highly maldistributed across the USA.

Bidderman raises the old canard about the Swedish suicide rate first raised by Eisenhower to fend off Adlai Stevenson. The quick responce from Swedish Embassy came the next day. Sweden has the highest suicide rate to a statistically insignificant number vis a vis other northern European countries. Southern European countries and the catholic world significantly underreport suicide because it is a sin and may cause problems for the soul.

Quality of life data shows northern Europe has significant advantages over the USA, longevity, birth data, health etc.

Most of these social welfare costs do not cost much because they yield significant savings down the road like the Fram oil filter, "you can pay me now or pay me later" Later usually costs much more.

If everybody thought like you guys we would have a tax revolt in Canada but I do a lot of work for a fairly famous polling company. Taxes makes hardly a wave in Canadian priorities for government action as much as the National Post tries to pump it up it just does not register compared to health, education, the environment, the economy and on and on. It is usually about priority #10.
 
I don't think Canadian taxes are particularly high. You keep confusing me for someone who is far right apparently for no reason other than I think the city overpays so you make some wrong assumptions.

I simply insist on getting value for money spent.
 
The melon heads in the media keep pointing to contracting out, but they either do not realize, or do not care that the private waste companies are unionized too.
 
wantoplay said:
The melon heads in the media keep pointing to contracting out, but they either do not realize, or do not care that the private waste companies are unionized too.

If that's the case, it just points out that the reason for going after the strikers is not anti union, it's against the stance and demands that this union has.

I don't think out taxes are too high and it's clear I'm not alone. Thanks MB for proving it. I just don't like spending it badly and the local union strike is just that.

Sorry, time to give the shovel back to MB
 
wantoplay said:
The melon heads in the media keep pointing to contracting out, but they either do not realize, or do not care that the private waste companies are unionized too.

Good point so, using MrBig's convoluted yet strangely simplistic logic, the unionized employees of private waste companies must be being paid a fair wage. This leads to the obvious conclusion that the extra 20% that the City workers are being paid is grossly unfair.