someone said:
BTW, given that garbage collection would likely be contracted out to dozens of private firms (if the intention is to get around unions, there is no reason for the city to simply make one large firm with a lot of government business a target to a union, when there are no real economies of scale in garbage collection anyway) the money would very likely be spent on local firms anyway. Not to mention the extra money taxpayers would have to spend money locally (or save it in foreign bonds, if they so wish). However, it is not really relevant anyway.
Yes, you're arguing with a person who is generally pro union, not 'the union forever or bust'. On the issue of garbage collection private can work, and be (possibly) cheaper (if handled right). It's like I said before, IF they did go down that road, the city should lease the trucks and / or retain the capacity to to cover any one collection firm. And there are probably about a dozen other bits of policy and contract law that could come into play. That requires a continuity from the political class, regardless of how you do it. Even if solve the private sector 'hold up' problem in the short term, that's a shoddy guarantor of the future. As I've also said before the biggest conduit for waste tends to be where public meets private (contracts, consultants, and contractors.) There's a union 'hold up' problem there as well, which "Agree or swelter in the sun with the garbage." Oddly enough, the preferred method of solving a 'hold up' is via merger.
We can both wank on macro economics. (Christ, I even have a shiny piece of paper that says I can, though I'm not 'in field'.) It was not meant as misdirection. You're an advocate for the 'Chicago School',
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_school_(economics) , and that's fine in so far as it goes. But they've fallen out of ascendancy for *good reasons*-- Not the least of which is that they've had 30 years and things haven't worked out as advertised. (I'm pathologically trying to avoid a series 25 paragraph debate on contemporary econ, less than I'm trying to misdirect. Mostly because I just don't have the time.)
I'm a social democrat (loony left), and I'm keen on Union 2.0-- That makes me a poor advocate of traditional unions in some ways. I've uttered more times than I can count that there is comprehensive reform needed to basically save traditional unions from themselves. Once again, unions shouldn't be able to shelter the incompetent and unproductive, shouldn't be able to fight technology, and should have regularly evaluated quotas that exist within 'one standard deviation' of the sustained output of a representative set of workers. In exchange the difference between part time and full time employees should be made cost neutral (politician hate that, but if you've ever had 2 or 3 part time gigs you damn well know why that's important.), there needs to be absolute clarity on 'essential services' (and maybe accelerated arbitration for garbage and TTC type services), 'what is a contractor?' should be sorted, and there are several right to organize and scab provisions that should be looked at. The biggest problem is that all policy happens on the fringes, so comprehensive reform is 'hard'. (And I hate to say it, I wouldn't really trust the party I tend to vote for to do it any more than the Conservatives, or whatever wing of the Liberal party is in power at the time.) I really don't want to wave the banner for traditional unions, though organized labour if structured right has a constructive role to play.
Basically unions should be about collective rights not defending individuals who don't particularly warrant it.
As far as 'Chicago School' driven policy goes, it's no coincidence that the current crises has hit the adherents of that school by proportion of how closely it followed it's dictates. The lesson that the Americans, Icelandic, and British should have learnt is that not all growth is equal. While 'globalism' shouldn't be 'rolled back' there is a justifiable counter movement on the go. Policy wise, 'supply side' and 'trickle down' have produced accelerating inequity, races to the bottom, and increasing political and economic volatility. There is no reason why the Scandinavian model wouldn't work quite well in Canada. We share density / temperate / resource availability similarities that we share with no other nations. We also share a border with the USA and overlapping demographics. Frankly, I have no illusions about which model produces better results for REAL LIVING HUMAN BEINGS while maintaining decent growth. Or basically 'society' and 'people' based policy, not rigid ideological policy on the left or right.
TL;DR version: Races to the bottom benefit nobody, not even those who profit from them if the short term. Neither does gross inefficiency for that matter. Rigid models that fixate on any one thing (Needs of Capital, or Organized Labour) that aren't holistic and people driven produce worse societies, and that leads to volatility which will often undermine the model.
THE REAL BONEHEAD IS THAT THE CITY KEEPS SIGNING CONTRACTS WITH AN EXPIRY DATE IN THE SUMMER. Sweet Jesus, they should hold out for dates that are spring or fall so the cold can keep the smell down, and the city isn't heaping with steaming garbage in the tourist season. Even if they cave on everything else, they should offset the date...
edit: and in so far this is a punt, well it is... My time is finite as well.
