Mrbig1949 said:Your arrogance is only compounded by you immaturity someone. You argue like a second year Economics student with no life experience.
Again you make no reference. Which one your many detractors are you targeting your comments at.
Mrbig1949 said:Your arrogance is only compounded by you immaturity someone. You argue like a second year Economics student with no life experience.
Mrbig1949 said:They are internally democratic, they are organized on a majority principal, what do you want, the right to not contribute and reap the benefits at the same time? Not going to happen, they are a lot more internally democratic than oh I don't know, a share holders meeting of a major corporation.
Mrbig1949 said:BTW one would expect a Red Smear from the McCarthy types, if you think unions are a good thing you are a Commie? Get real we are talking about free trade unions, the ones who raised the common man/woman out of poverty, the ones supported by ML King, Nelson Mandela, Ghandi etc
Mrbig1949 said:They all supported unions my friend. Unions have this thing called a strike vote with a secret ballot. Most unions would not take the members out below 70% support.
Any contract is the 'fault' of the two parties signing it. If banked sickdays are a problem then management shares the fault. Nice that city managers are trying to correct that 'fault', but let's not pretend they weren't part of it. No one sends innocent babes to negociate and sign contracts. If they weren't competent, they're hosing us taxpayers for their pay.JohnLarue said:/
WTF
You agree that the bank sick days is stupid idea, but you still manage to make this the fault of past city mangers?????
That is strange logic, however lets not focus on fault as its clear you will never find your union pals in the wrong, no matter how outrageous their demands.
Lets focus on what is right & fair and what the outcome should be
1. Sick days are for when you get sick
23 sick days / year is an allotment far above any other group of employees that I am aware of, however, Trash collectors work outside in the winter & work around trash, so it is likely they might catch more colds & possibly even infections, than the average office employee. So lets not begrudge them this overly generous benefit and make sure their health is not an issue
2. But if you do not use them, you lose them.
If you have 10 left over in December, then call in sick for a couple weeks & go to Florida.
If this becomes a staffing problem (all the trash guys call in sick in Dec), fine offset half of the employees sick day calender year by two months, 4 months , 6 months whatever it takes.
3. Banking 20 days year after year is just too expensive
This amounts to a couple extra years pay at retirement
In twenty years time you could have more collectors on a 14 month sick day vacation, than you have collectors out collecting.
This sounds similar to the GM situation & we all know how that turned out
4. This is clearly a situation that requires correction & the current city mangers are trying to make that correction.
Only a self serving person would not agree that banking 20 sick days is not an abuse
5. " it has nothing to do with self-serving stuff like I'm a taxpayer and they're hosing me. "
I have every right to be concerned with how my tax dollars are being wasted.
It drives me absolutely crazy that unions feel they have a right to abuse the taxpayer and any ridiculous demand can be met with a tax increase
How dare you!
Thunderballs said:Let's face it, you can train a chimp to pick up garbage.
oldjones said:And geez, it's just a bit of trash. I'm still filling my first bag. There's a lot worse hardships.
oldjones said:It's quite clear unions drive you crazy, and I too am a taxpayer resentful of rising demands, but this is a bargaining process, and unions are a part of it.
QUOTE]
Why do unions have to be a part of it?
Clearly they are out of touch with reality
The world is about change & perhaps it is best they adapt or become extinct
Just as smoking & drinking & driving is no longer socially acceptable, perhaps it time that unions who extort the public become socially & legally unacceptable.
The status quo will not be satisfactory in a globally competitive marketplace
You need to wake up & smell the winds of change
Smoking cigarettes in no longer acceptable. I have NEVER been told to extinguish my pipe.JohnLarue said:Just as smoking & drinking & driving is no longer socially acceptable, perhaps it time that unions who extort the public become socially & legally unacceptable.
a 1 player said:I have NEVER been told to extinguish my pipe.
JohnLarue said:/oldjones said:It's quite clear unions drive you crazy, and I too am a taxpayer resentful of rising demands, but this is a bargaining process, and unions are a part of it.
QUOTE]
Why do unions have to be a part of it?
Clearly they are out of touch with reality
The world is about change & perhaps it is best they adapt or become extinct
Just as smoking & drinking & driving is no longer socially acceptable, perhaps it time that unions who extort the public become socially & legally unacceptable.
The status quo will not be satisfactory in a globally competitive marketplace
You need to wake up & smell the winds of change
Well put.
Don't get rid of unions. They should stay around and help us remember how bad things can be; just like keeping the evil king alive in the dungeon and trotted out every time someone begins to whine about the good old days- like they are doing in Russia right now saying that Stalin was just misunderstood and not that bad. They'd have to look for his remains in the deepest chambers in hell with Pol Pot, Caligula, and Ivan the Terrible.
How soon some people forget and need a reminder. Keep the unions around.
I'm quite aware you say bullshit, no need to shout.blackrock13 said:I say, BULLSHIT!!!!!!! Unless of course you live alone, eat out a lot and crash on a lot of couches at other peoples places.
Toronto's garbage service DID collect 14 tons of garbage every day or 12.5 million tons a year (Toronto star). That's not 'a bit of trash'. I know you might challenge that figure, but The Star probably have an irrefutable source that I don't have at my fingertips. It's probably listed in some tome of an annual report at city hall.
I'm going to guess that your PJs are NDP colours. I know that's cruel, but it's clear you see the world through very different eyes than the majority of people on this BB and across the country. That's why the NDP is stuck around 16% annually.
Because freedom of association is a basic human right guranteed by the Charter. Unions are just guys facing the same situation choosing to negociate as one.JohnLarue said:oldjones said:It's quite clear unions drive you crazy, and I too am a taxpayer resentful of rising demands, but this is a bargaining process, and unions are a part of it.
Why do unions have to be a part of it?
Clearly they are out of touch with reality
The world is about change & perhaps it is best they adapt or become extinct
Just as smoking & drinking & driving is no longer socially acceptable, perhaps it time that unions who extort the public become socially & legally unacceptable.
The status quo will not be satisfactory in a globally competitive marketplace
You need to wake up & smell the winds of change
You mean you've been going on all this time and only now are you bothering to find out the most basic fact of all? With that sort of wise citizenship contributing to the debate no wonder it's off the rails.blackrock13 said:Somebody tell me, is the contract still in force. If not, it's time to put out tenders. Let's see what kind of work can be offered for how much. then we can talk about worth.
Remember those numbers from way back, which MB had no clue of, only 3 out of 444 municipalities in Ontario have contracted out the garbage service. Something's not working right. Let's fix it.