Furnace brand and type help

newtohobby

New member
Jul 22, 2006
445
0
0
I'm shopping for a new furnace and had 4 companies come over to give me quotes. They were all gas technicians and not sales men giving me the quotes. My current furnance is old and about 27 years old. the output btu is about 85000 btu. They all said to go with single stage high efficiancy furnace and in their experience, the 2 stage has way too many problems. I'm happy with my current single stage furnace and probably stick with another one. My house is about 2000 sq ft. All of them are 92-95 percent efficiant.


options are :

#1 rudd single stage 2899 plus tax
rudd variable speed 2 stage 3399 plus tax
75000 btu

#2 luxaire single stage 2450 plus tax
80000 btu

#3 rudd single stage 2200 plus tax
60000 btu
or 75000 btu 2450 plus tax

#4 rheem single stage 2250 plus tax
75000 btu
Aire flo single stage 1900 plus tax
80000 btu
keeprite single stage 2250 plus tax
80000 btu

I am leaning towards the rheem furnace, my worries are is 75000 btu big enough, one company was pushing just 60000 btu. I think the rheem uses direct spark ignition and not hot surface ignition. The keeprite uses a DC motor and the rheem uses a AC motor
 
I seem to recall Captain James T. Kirk saying that many brands are manufactured by the same company. Anyway, I like the comment about single stage versus 2 stage.
 
A few years ago I installed a Keeprite 2 stage with DC motor. my understanding is the dc motors can be adjusted for maximum efficiency (heat rise & cool) . BTU was drastically reduced as the old furnace was way over what the house needed, on the first stage it fires at 27,000 btu where the old furnace was about 70,000. The second stage only fires if you raise the t stat several degrees. say in the morning or occasionally on a very cold day the second stage kicks in if the furnace has run for ( i think ) 10 minutes to help boost temperature.
I was in the eco energy grant program and the 2 stage with DC motor had the best payback, the price was right on the furnace & the install was done by a friends nephew for a very reasonable cost. Had those options not been available, I may have looked at other furnaces.
New furnace, new windows, attic insulation upgrade, full basement insulation , converted to gas drier and the heating bills are less than half they were.
 
Get a Goodman furnace. Get a high efficiency. And drop the size down to 45-55 K btu's. Check out home stars for a good installer. But make sure u use an hvac Co that specializes in residential furnaces. The commercial guys will want to oversize u. And u font need that. To big will be to windy and noise in house.
airmakers.ca
 
Remember nothing runs like a Trane, 96.7 efficient... best in the business... a little more expensive but 10 year full warranty last time I checked...
 
Get a Goodman furnace. Get a high efficiency. And drop the size down to 45-55 K btu's. Check out home stars for a good installer. But make sure u use an hvac Co that specializes in residential furnaces. The commercial guys will want to oversize u. And u font need that. To big will be to windy and noise in house.
airmakers.ca

Yes your input needed will likely be less than your current. Ensure the Output BTU rating on the new furnace is not less than the Output on your old furnace. Check the label inside the service door of your current furnace.

In theory there should be no reason to upgrade a properly sized furnace with a higher OUTPUT BTU furnace unless the house had an addition. In most cases people will have improved there windows and insulation over the years, meaning a small furnace is better
 
Likewise on goodman as they make many of the furnaces for other companies. Why not buy from the main company.
 
Likewise on goodman as they make many of the furnaces for other companies. Why not buy from the main company.


Simpleton.

You think all the units they make are the same model with the same specs, components and warranties?

Just a different label and price tag stuck on?

Every company has their own designs, specifications for materials and components. In fact they have several grades within their product lines. Builder grade, Economy, Standard and up to their premium lines. They may use one of many contract assembly factories for certain assemblies like the heat exchanger. Even motors are widely variable in quality from cheap Mexican and Chinese units to Made in the USA units. And even then within the same electric motor company.

Back in your crate Mutley!
 
I'm shopping for a new furnace and had 4 companies come over to give me quotes. They were all gas technicians and not sales men giving me the quotes. My current furnance is old and about 27 years old. the output btu is about 85000 btu. They all said to go with single stage high efficiancy furnace and in their experience, the 2 stage has way too many problems. I'm happy with my current single stage furnace and probably stick with another one. My house is about 2000 sq ft. All of them are 92-95 percent efficiant.


options are :

#1 rudd single stage 2899 plus tax
rudd variable speed 2 stage 3399 plus tax
75000 btu

#2 luxaire single stage 2450 plus tax
80000 btu

#3 rudd single stage 2200 plus tax
60000 btu
or 75000 btu 2450 plus tax

#4 rheem single stage 2250 plus tax
75000 btu
Aire flo single stage 1900 plus tax
80000 btu
keeprite single stage 2250 plus tax
80000 btu

I am leaning towards the rheem furnace, my worries are is 75000 btu big enough, one company was pushing just 60000 btu. I think the rheem uses direct spark ignition and not hot surface ignition. The keeprite uses a DC motor and the rheem uses a AC motor


All the prices are within the realm of being reasonable. Go with whichever contractor is best recommended and in business longest
 
Simpleton.

You think all the units they make are the same model with the same specs, components and warranties?

Just a different label and price tag stuck on?

Every company has their own designs, specifications for materials and components. In fact they have several grades within their product lines. Builder grade, Economy, Standard and up to their premium lines. They may use one of many contract assembly factories for certain assemblies like the heat exchanger. Even motors are widely variable in quality from cheap Mexican and Chinese units to Made in the USA units. And even then within the same electric motor company.

Back in your crate Mutley!

Since that's not what I claimed, no. Just like beach foundry used to do with household appliances. Had two family members for them and they said quite often slapping different names on them was just what they did.

You're so fucking lazy now and firing blanks so much lately you're stealing others schtick, bad karma SC. WWC is Mutley.
 
At least have a conversation with an authorized rep from Carrier about their multi-stage furnaces with advanced thermostats.

Time has not stood still in furnace advancements in the 27 years since you purchased your last furnace.
 
Rheem and Rudd are exactly the same company, and likely the same unit unless one of them has different optional features. A variable-speed fan will save a lot of electricity if you keep the fan running all the time, but will not make much difference if you only run the fan during heating or cooling cycles.