furnace advice

pokergod

Member
Apr 15, 2007
614
0
16
I have a 23 year old home and its still the original owner. I just got a violation for a new water heater and need a chimney liner. They suggested I replace the furance and AC since it would be better with the new ones. They both work great and I don't know if I should get a new one or wait till they break down then get a new one.
 
I just got a violation for a new water heater and need a chimney liner. They suggested I replace the furance and AC since it would be better with the new ones.
If the new furnace is HE then you don't need a chimney, just a couple of holes in your wall.
 
If the furnace and AC are high efficency ones then leave it and buy a new water heater. Like 300 bucks. Not sure the liner pricing. Are you on gas? I added the latest for all models(replaced an oil furnace) F years ago and pay so little with the new stuff. If you can delay and its not needed or will significantly lower your bills then wait. Especially if you won't be selling soon. Better to have a newer system when you sell.
 
i would think you would probably get a better deal if you did it all at once.
 
If you have metal pipes coming off the top of your water heater & furnace, these appliance are "natural draft" and were approx 60% combustion efficient when they were new. You might possibly have a mid-efficiency furnace, which would be 80% efficient - open the top front panel & look for an exhaust motor to confirm 80% efficiency. Lets assume you don't have one so its a "natural draft", ie "conventional".
For every dollar of gas you put into that furnace, approx 60% stays in the home as usable heat and 40% goes straight up your chimney. A new furnace is from 92% - 96% combustion efficient. Do the math using the "consumption" amount on your gas bill. Also, your old furnace is a standard ac blower motor, probably drawing 4-7 amps depending on size. A new furnace with a dc motor is much more electrically efficient; you'll likely use 90% less electricity to run the new furnace. Again, do the math.
If you plan to stay in this house for more than 5-6 years, you are wasting alot of money on your old furnace.
Also, if your AC unit is 23 years old, those compressors probably draw 15-18 amps when running, wherreas a new AC with a scroll compressor uses maybe 5-7 amps. Same cooling effect for alot less money, & they`re much quieter. Downside is R410A units (the new refrigerant which replaced R22) are big...really big. Maybe 30% physically larger condensing unit than your old AC. Also R410A operates at higher pressures & seem more susceptible to leaks.
Replace your water heater to a power-vent model; efficiency is pretty much the same as the natural draft heaters but you`ll eliminate the need for the chimney & chimney liner. Or try a tankless, depending on water quality in your area. They`re upwards of 80% efficient & if properly sized, virtually unlimited hot water.
 
I was in the same situation last year. My old furnace was around 60 percent efficient. The new high efficiency furnaces are 94 percent so you'll be using less energy. Your gas bill will go down. This is the slow time of the year for HVAC guys,the lull before the summer AC frenzy. There are usually deals on furnaces because it's the end of the season.
 
the water heater is gas and the furnace and AC are not HE

Since the hot water heater is not HE it needs a liner in the chimney . The furnace is not HE then it also must be vented up a chimney with a liner . That chimney should already have a liner in it . If it doesn't the you should get one installed .

As for a new furnace , yea maybe . If the furnace is still running good the why spend big dollars on a new one . You will save a few dollars in the amount of gas used but it will take along time to recuperate that money back in savings .

Same goes for the AC . If the old one is still running OK then why get a new one . If your one of these people that lower your thermostat in the summer that your AC is running steady then maybe a new AC is a good idea . My AC doesn't run 24-7 . I don't need to freeze in the summer . Just need to be comfortable.

Like every one said . A new furnace will be HE and the exhaust and vent will go outside the wall of your house . Two ABS pipes . Same goes for a HE hot water tank . Two pipes outside the wall of your house . IF you keep your old Hot Water tank then it must be vented going up a chimney with a liner .

If you choose to replace your furnace then make sure that they install two pipes . One for exhaust and one for fresh air . I have two neighbours that only have one pipe for exhaust . The installers said that a fresh air pipe was not needed because the furnace is in a large room with lots of air . I call bullshit . Those guy's were too lazy to drill two holes and add two pipes .

I don't know if you rent your Hot Water tank but to buy the HE tank is over $1000 last time I looked . A old style hot water gas tank is around $400 .

Either way your going to spend some money . A bit now for a liner or big bucks now or down the road . Some people like to have a new furnace . The guy who installed mine ( I went from oil to gas ) takes the home owners old furnace out and will resell it , say for $1000 bucks . Not every one can afford a brand new furnace so they are happy getting a old furnace decent furnace at a much lower price .
 
One thing to note. Old mid-efficiency furnaces can last 600 years (just kidding, more like 30-40 years) but the new HE furnaces last only 15 years. So save your gas savings so you have money to buy a new HE in 15 years.
 
I replaces my 25 year old furnace. Put in a high efficiency and ac. Cut my gas bill from 400 per month to 150 per month. I wouldn't believe it if I hadn't seen it myself. Summer time hydro bill also lower by about 40 dollars. The house smells nicer too. And not as dusty These new high efficiency furnaces r incredible.
Again, I wouldn't believe my own post if I hadn't experienced it myself. Best damn money I ever spent.
BUT make sure u use a contractor who specializes in residential. And don't put oversized unit in your hose or I will be noisey and lots of blowing. Check out home stars. And get contractors. Cozy World is the best in my books. Lots of people I know have used them and love them.
 
I have two neighbours that only have one pipe for exhaust . The installers said that a fresh air pipe was not needed because the furnace is in a large room with lots of air .
Yes, two holes are much better than one. Also, speak to your neighbour first so he won't kill your dog because he is so angry that your exhaust vents into his porch or window or wall or walkway.
 
Yes, two holes are much better than one. Also, speak to your neighbour first so he won't kill your dog because he is so angry that your exhaust vents into his porch or window or wall or walkway.

That certainly can be a problem . The installers don't really care where the exhaust pipe goes so you have be certain to tell them where to put it .
 
how big is your house.?? My house is just over 2100 square ft and in the winter pay around 220 a month for gas. the total is about 1000 bucks a year. So my electricity bill is only around 900 for the year. How big is your house that you used to pay 400 a month

I replaces my 25 year old furnace. Put in a high efficiency and ac. Cut my gas bill from 400 per month to 150 per month. I wouldn't believe it if I hadn't seen it myself. Summer time hydro bill also lower by about 40 dollars. The house smells nicer too. And not as dusty These new high efficiency furnaces r incredible.
Again, I wouldn't believe my own post if I hadn't experienced it myself. Best damn money I ever spent.
BUT make sure u use a contractor who specializes in residential. And don't put oversized unit in your hose or I will be noisey and lots of blowing. Check out home stars. And get contractors. Cozy World is the best in my books. Lots of people I know have used them and love them.
 
how big is your house.?? My house is just over 2100 square ft and in the winter pay around 220 a month for gas. the total is about 1000 bucks a year. So my electricity bill is only around 900 for the year. How big is your house that you used to pay 400 a month

The question may be not how big the house but how well-insulated and air-tight is it?