If you have metal pipes coming off the top of your water heater & furnace, these appliance are "natural draft" and were approx 60% combustion efficient when they were new. You might possibly have a mid-efficiency furnace, which would be 80% efficient - open the top front panel & look for an exhaust motor to confirm 80% efficiency. Lets assume you don't have one so its a "natural draft", ie "conventional".
For every dollar of gas you put into that furnace, approx 60% stays in the home as usable heat and 40% goes straight up your chimney. A new furnace is from 92% - 96% combustion efficient. Do the math using the "consumption" amount on your gas bill. Also, your old furnace is a standard ac blower motor, probably drawing 4-7 amps depending on size. A new furnace with a dc motor is much more electrically efficient; you'll likely use 90% less electricity to run the new furnace. Again, do the math.
If you plan to stay in this house for more than 5-6 years, you are wasting alot of money on your old furnace.
Also, if your AC unit is 23 years old, those compressors probably draw 15-18 amps when running, wherreas a new AC with a scroll compressor uses maybe 5-7 amps. Same cooling effect for alot less money, & they`re much quieter. Downside is R410A units (the new refrigerant which replaced R22) are big...really big. Maybe 30% physically larger condensing unit than your old AC. Also R410A operates at higher pressures & seem more susceptible to leaks.
Replace your water heater to a power-vent model; efficiency is pretty much the same as the natural draft heaters but you`ll eliminate the need for the chimney & chimney liner. Or try a tankless, depending on water quality in your area. They`re upwards of 80% efficient & if properly sized, virtually unlimited hot water.