Free Michael Vick

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Please set Michael Vick free! Oh, he is freed. Now what? Will he return to the NFL? Will they let him play? Will this "sabbatical" actually prolong his career?
 
Rockslinger said:
Please set Michael Vick free! Oh, he is freed. Now what? Will he return to the NFL? Will they let him play? Will this "sabbatical" actually prolong his career?

Who'd take him? I'd say his career has gone to the dogs.

jwm
 
jwmorrice said:
Who'd take him? I'd say his career has gone to the dogs.

jwm

Belichick is enamoured with the wildcat offense and it wouldnt surprise me to see the Pats take a flyer on him. They could use him in the wildcat or in special Michael Vick packages - obvioiusly would not be the starting QB. San Francisco or St.Louis could also be other possible landing spots.

As a Falcons fan I have moved on. Michael Vick when he was in the league was easily the most electrifying player in the league but his passing skills wasnt that of an elite QB in my opinion. He may have had a howitzer for an arm , he could probably throw the ball 70 yards off his back foot with just a flick of the wrist but he was not accurate with his passes. Ball security was an issue for him too, when he would tuck the ball and run he would leave the ball exposed and defensive players could just swipe the ball out of his hand. Trust me I know. I saw this happen on a few occasions and I havent missed a Falcons game since my senior year of university of 2001.

Matty Ice - he is the real deal and in my opinion will take the Falcons where Vick didnt - to the promised land and a Superbowl Championship. Maybe not this year as the defense is not of championship calibre but the offense this year could easily be a top 5 offense in the NFL if not better. Trust me. Falcons will score 30 points in a lot of their games this year. Falcons do have quite the difficult schedule though paired up with the AFC East and NFC East but also they have 4 games against opponents coming off of byes.
 
Best athlete to ever play the QB position but arguably in the bottom 1% in league history as a decision maker to ever be a starter. Anyone who thinks they can win with him throwing the ball more then 5 times a game should be fired for suggesting it.

could he help as a backup RB? maybe (depends how good the prison weight room was) but why would you add the distraction of a legion of reporters asking every player on your team every week "How does it feel to be on the same team as a man worse then Hitler?" and all the inevitable dramas of guys putting their foot in their mouths trying to dodge it?

He's not that good. Never was, never will be.
 
gramage said:
Best athlete to ever play the QB position but arguably in the bottom 1% in league history as a decision maker to ever be a starter. Anyone who thinks they can win with him throwing the ball more then 5 times a game should be fired for suggesting it.

could he help as a backup RB? maybe (depends how good the prison weight room was) but why would you add the distraction of a legion of reporters asking every player on your team every week "How does it feel to be on the same team as a man worse then Hitler?" and all the inevitable dramas of guys putting their foot in their mouths trying to dodge it?

He's not that good. Never was, never will be.

I hope you didnt mean Vick wasnt good.

I wouldnt say he wasnt good. I'm a die hard Falcons fan and saw every single game he played in a Falcons uniform. He was good , even very good at times but not great. Are you forgetting what he did at Lambeau? handing GB their first home playoff loss? He ran circles around the GB defense in that game. How about the play in OT against the Vikings. Or when he led them to the NFC Championship game? Also, did he ever have a name receiver on his team? Peerless Price? I dont think so. And just to remind you during the Mora regime they were employing the Alex Gibbs zone-blocking scheme that Denver is famous for. That type of scheme requires smaller offensive lineman and that compromises pass-pro. The pass-protection wasnt great when Vick was there, the receivers werent great and the defense was very good only part of the time. The best weapon Vick had in the passing game was Crumpler. One of the biggest mistakes the Falcons did was getting rid of Dan Reeves because Reeves knew how to use Vick the best. He knew how to take advantage of his skill set. Sure Vick was never an elite passer but he made plays on 3rd downs , in the redzone and in the 2 minute drill when big plays needed to be made.

He was actually quite accurate out of the pocket just not in the pocket. In fact some DCs would try to keep him in the pocket instead of flushing him out b/c they knew that he was more accurate outside the pocket and dangerous on the run.

RB? I dont think so. I think maybe as a return-man he could be effective but as a RB hes not the type that would be able to run between the tackles he would be more of a Reggie Bush type that would bounce it outside all the time. Also, we dont know how good he would be as a receiver out of the backfield and something tells me that Vick would get mauled in pass-pro. I also saw Vick run with the football quite a bit and if he were to be a RB he would have to improve his ball-security. He was a little careless with the football and would leave it exposed for defenders to knock it loose.

Bush has not lived up to the hype for sure but I will say that last year he showed that he can be very effective as a specialty back. You get him out in space, throw him some passes out of the backfield, use him in the return game and he can be very productive and do some very good things on a football field. But Bush is not the type that can run downhill and run between the tackles.

Vick was a very good QB. We gotta remember he never had a true stud receiver. He had Roddy White but that was before Roddy had some seasoning and became the emerging star that he is today. In fairness to Vick though the offense in the Mora regime was too one dimensional. The DVD backfield of Dunn, Vick and Duckett, it was great the Falcons were killing people on the ground for 3 consecutive years but we had no assemblance of a passing game b/c Vick was inaccurate but he also had no receivers other than Crumpler and the pass-protection wasnt good.

I am not defending anything Vick did off the field. The dog fighting is atrocious. And as a Falcons fan I have moved on. Matty Ice is the future of the franchise and he in my opinion will be a better QB than Vick was - even though he may not be as electrifying as Vick.
 
Good or not, Vick was an exciting player. On the subject of QB's, what is this sexual assault charge against Ben Rotheberger (sorry I butchered his name) all about? Is this going to be another Kobe Bryant type circus?
 
After learning of his conditional reinstatement to the NFL Monday, free agent Michael Vick issued a statement expressing "gratitude" and "appreciation" for the commissioner's decision.

Vick admitted his "terrible mistakes" and said he understands playing football "is a privilege, not a right, and I am fully thankful." "Finally, I want to sincerely thank Coach (Tony) Dungy for being in my corner," Vick added. "And I look forward to him being a mentor for me." ESPN's John Clayton reports that Vick's phone is "already ringing." Time will tell if anything is serious.

NFL Network's Steve Wyche reports that free agent Michael Vick will only work out for teams on an individual basis and won't hold a public "Pro Day."

Vick's speed, conditioning, and weight will be huge question marks as teams begin trying him out after two years in prison. It remains to be seen at which position most clubs will view him, but we'd bet he'll be signed as a QB.


The next few weeks will be very interesting.
 
Let him play. He served his time. There are a lot worse offenders in the NFL IMHO than him.
 
lawyerman said:
After learning of his conditional reinstatement to the NFL Monday, free agent Michael Vick issued a statement expressing "gratitude" and "appreciation" for the commissioner's decision.

Vick admitted his "terrible mistakes" and said he understands playing football "is a privilege, not a right, and I am fully thankful." "Finally, I want to sincerely thank Coach (Tony) Dungy for being in my corner," Vick added. "And I look forward to him being a mentor for me." ESPN's John Clayton reports that Vick's phone is "already ringing." Time will tell if anything is serious.

NFL Network's Steve Wyche reports that free agent Michael Vick will only work out for teams on an individual basis and won't hold a public "Pro Day."

Vick's speed, conditioning, and weight will be huge question marks as teams begin trying him out after two years in prison. It remains to be seen at which position most clubs will view him, but we'd bet he'll be signed as a QB.


The next few weeks will be very interesting.

I dont know if a team will take him on as the starting pivot, as it would just be too much of a circus atmosphere and PR nightmare. I can foresee him being a starting QB again in the NFL but not immediately. I think he could be useful in the wildcat packages though. I know Belichick seems to be enamoured with the wildcat especially after Sporano burned him with it last season. Plus even though NE has made some shrewd moves in the offseason to acquire Fred Taylor and Joey Galloway, I think one area of concern could be backup QB. We dont know how Brady will respond once he is back in real game action and if he somehow reaggravates the injury then at least Vick could step in take over under centre. Or perhaps he could be used similar to how Percy Harvin will be used in Minnesota (i.e not like a RB or a WR but sort of an inbetween guy). Miami could have been a destination that would have made some sense until they drafted Pat White. I expect Pat White to be used a lot in some of their wildcat formations. So Vick would likely not be a candidate to join the Fish.

There are still 3 camps where there are QB battles going on :
1. TB
2. CLE
3. SF

I dont see TB going after Vick b/c Freeman is probably the future in Tampa though it will likely be Leftwich that will get the starters job. As a Falcons fan I am hoping Leftwich plays as badly in Tampa as he did in Atlanta. He did play well in Pittsburgh though - thanks a lot Byron!

Brady Quinn is probably the future in Cleveland even though the starting job is probably still up for grabs in CLE so I dont see Vick going to CLE either.

I could see SF maybe taking a flyer on Vick though. What is up with Alex Smith's accuracy. Its gonna be a battle between Hill and Smith but I could see SF taking a flyer on Vick.

St. Louis, Oakland I think are other possibilities too.

Who knows, i guess time will tell.

Steve Whyche knows what he is talking about and I take his word as gospel especially since he is based down in the ATL. I absolutely love his work on NFL Network.

The funny thing is Vick is thanking Tony Dungy (and he should) but Dan Reeves who was almost like a father to Vick when Vick came into the league tried to contact Vick numerous times too during his incarceration but Reeves never heard back from Vick. I found that a little odd. Especially b/c Reeves was always a supporter of Vick's.

Vick's paid his debt to society, I hope he can make a huge comeback and it really would not surprise me to see him play well upon his comeback. As a diehard Falcons fan I still remember the SNF game on ESPN against Carolina @ the Georgia Dome (still have that game on tape actually) his first game back from the fibula injury in 2003. The GA Dome was packed for a 2-10 team b/c Vick was back and boy did he ever play well in that game. LIke he hadnt even missed a snap. Obviously this is a much different situation though coming off of a jail sentence as opposed to an injury but hopefully he can be a different guy now.

That being said, Im happy with Matt Ryan and the Falcons made the right move releasing Vick. Ryan is the future of the franchise and to me has Peyton Manning potential. Vick was arguably the most electrifying player in the league when he played but Ryan is and will be the better QB I have no doubt in my mind about that.
 
Let the dog killer play. They have murderers playing so why not?

Besides, football doesn't have a "bring your dog to the ballpark" promotion like baseball so there should be no worries ......:p
 
He COULD end up in the CFL!!!!!!!!!! We have a history of attracting some bad boys from the US Manley Bell etc.
 
CNN says that Vick has $16million in assets and $20million in debts (and no, he does not own any Beatles songs that he can sell).
 
spankingman said:
He COULD end up in the CFL!!!!!!!!!! We have a history of attracting some bad boys from the US Manley Bell etc.

I dont think he wants to come to the CFL. I think he would rather go to the UFL and play under Jim Haslett in Orlando - at least this is what I heard on NFL Network a couple nights ago. He would probably be paid more in the UFL as well. Plus you have the issue of him being a convicted felon and we dont even know how smoothly he would be able to just come and work in Canada based on his criminal history with the dog fighting.
 
Rockslinger said:
Is the UFL the same as "arena football"?

Nope, not same as arena football. It will be played in outdoor stadiums to the best of my knowledge and the rules from what I have heard will be similar or the same as the NFL rules.
 
I was watching NFL Total Access earlier and Jason La Canfora was saying that Vick could be an option in Minnesota now that Favre has said he is gonna stay retired. I tell you what, a backfield that features Vick, "All Day" and Chester Taylor would be pretty scary. Throw in Percy Harvin and you have got some crazy athleticism and electricity on that team. Granted they may not have a stud receiver but I dont think they would need one. They have Bernard Berrian who can stretch the field vertically and they have Visanthe Shianco who is a decent TE, not a star, but a decent one.
 
lawyerman said:
It remains to be seen at which position most clubs will view him


Probably not tight end anymore
 
I just read an article about Vick and how it looks likely that he will go to Jacksonville. This makes sense because Jacksonville needs some QB depth.

I really hope he is sorry for what he has done. I am an animal lover and it sickens me that he did this. It's sounds like he does regret his actions but that will come in time.