Israeli historian Dr. Lee Mordechai painstakingly documents the pogrom in Gaza
For The Genocide Deniers
- Thread starter niniveh
- Start date
Ha'aretz published excerpts. No wonder the Cabinet is trying to silence the English Daily.
Israeli historian produces vast database of war crimes in Gaza
Lee Mordechai says his country is committing genocide, as his report documents a wide range of atrocities committed by Israeli forces
Lee Mordechai is an Israeli historian and the author of 'Bearing Witness to the Israel-Gaza War' (Supplied)
By Nadav Rapaport in Tel Aviv, Israel and Oscar Rickett in London
Published date: 6 December 2024 14:25 GMT | Last update: 1 day 4 hours ago
2.5kShares
An internationally recognised Israeli historian has concluded that his country is committing genocide in Gaza after compiling a vast, methodical report documenting a litany of war crimes committed since Israel’s invasion began last year following the Hamas-led attacks of 7 October.
Lee Mordechai, an associate professor at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, who has also held a fellowship at Princeton University in the US, has published a report titled “Bearing Witness to the Israel-Gaza War” which, in its English translation, is 124 pages long and contains over 1,400 footnotes.
Using eyewitness reports, video footage, articles, photographs, eyewitness evidence and over investigatory material, much of it recorded by Israeli soldiers, the historian has produced what Haaretz calls “the most methodical and detailed documentation in Hebrew (there is also an English translation) of the war crimes that Israel is perpetrating in Gaza”.
Some of the most shocking incidents documented by Mordechai include a Palestinian woman with a child being shot while waving a white flag, starving girls being crushed to death while queuing for bread, a handcuffed 62-year-old Palestinian man getting run over by an Israeli tank and an air strike targeting people trying to help a wounded boy.
The database includes thousands of videos, photos, testimonies, reports and investigations documenting the atrocities Israeli forces are committing in Gaza, where over 44,500 Palestinians have been killed during the war.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Mordechai also includes a section on "The media, propaganda and the war", noting that the current war has been "enabled and facilitated by massive media efforts to shape discourse in Israel as well as in the West – in countries such as the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Germany".
Corpses, killings and sunsets
Haaretz led its report on Mordechai’s document by drawing attention to footnote 379, which refers to a video clip showing a large dog eating the corpse of a Palestinian.
“Wai, wai, he took the terrorist, the terrorist is gone - gone in both senses,” says the Israeli soldier who filmed the dog eating the dead body. A few seconds later, the soldier pans away from the corpse to the scene around him. “But what a gorgeous view, a gorgeous sunset. A red sun is setting over the Gaza Strip,” he says.
Mordechai’s compendium details the killing of children by Israeli soldiers, the murder of entire families, the starvation and shooting of civilians, tanks running over prisoners and corpses, and much more.
Footnote 354 of the document shows footage of Palestinians being shot by Israeli forces while raising a white flag. The video footage, first published by Middle East Eye, shows many people waving white flags while apparently evacuating their homes. A woman with a small child is shot dead by an Israeli sniper, with the child managing to escape.
The historian first published the document in January and has been publishing updated versions of it ever since.
“I felt that I could not continue to live in my own bubble, that it was a matter of life and death, and what was happening was too big and contradicted the values I grew up with here,” he told Haaretz.
In his report, Mordechai confirms the veracity of the fatality figures published by Gaza’s Ministry of Health. According to the historian, claims that these numbers are exaggerated are groundless, and even the Israeli government treats the health ministry’s data as accurate.
Exclusive: Gaza grandmother shot and killed by Israeli sniper as child waved white flag
Read More »
Of the tens of thousands of people killed in the war, Mordechai includes in the document the death of four premature babies after Israeli forces decided to evacuate the hospital they were in. A nurse looking after five babies was forced to choose the strongest one, which was allowed to survive.
Other footage compiled by the historian – and again often filmed by Israeli forces themselves – shows a soldier forcing bound and blindfolded prisoners to send regards to his family and to say they want to be his slaves.
Israeli soldiers are photographed holding stacks of money they plundered from Palestinian homes in Gaza and an Israeli army bulldozer is seen destroying a large pile of food packages from a humanitarian aid agency.
In another clip, an Israeli soldier sings, “Next year we’ll burn the school,” while a Gazan school is engulfed in flames in the background. Numerous video clips documented by Mordechai show Israeli soldiers modelling women’s underwear they have looted.
Genocide
The links included in “Bearing Witness to the Israel-Gaza War” also lead to graphic footage of bodies strewn about the haunted streets of the Palestinian enclave, of people crushed under the rubble and of puddles of blood everywhere.
In some footage we hear the cries of people who have lost their entire families in a single instant. There is also documentary evidence attesting to the killing of disabled people, sexual assault and humiliation, the burning of homes, random shooting, forced starvation, looting and more.
War on Gaza: The Palestinian doctors found dead in the ruins of al-Shifa hospital
Read More »
Mordechai argues that Israel’s war reached a brutal peak during the second incursion into al-Shifa Hospital in March, when the Gaza City medical complex became the site of mass killings.
The Israeli army argued that Hamas was using the hospital as a base, but did not provide sufficient evidence to back up this claim.
Another brutal peak has been Israel’s complete siege and assault on northern Gaza since early October, which has been widely described as ethnic cleansing.
In an appendix to his report, Mordechai explains why he thinks Israel’s actions in Gaza constitute genocide.
“We need to disconnect the way we think of genocide as Israelis - gas chambers, death camps and World War II - from the model that appears in the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (1948),” he writes.
“There don't have to be death camps for it to be considered genocide. It all boils down to the commission of acts and the intent, and the existence of both has to be established.
"In regard to committing acts, it's killing, but not only – [there is] also wounding people, abduction of children and even just attempts to prevent births among a particular group of people. What all these acts have in common is the deliberate destruction of a group.”
Recommended
Israeli soldier was ordered to kill Palestinian holding white flag, says reservist
How Amnesty concluded that Israel has genocidal intent in Gaza
Amnesty chief calls on Starmer and Lammy to revise Gaza genocide stance after major report
Read more
Israel's war on Gaza
Revealed: Israel's own footage of Gaza air strikes documents 'devastating' civilian harm
Israel's war on Gaza
Footage appears to show Israeli strike on donkey cart pulling civilians
Israel's war on Gaza
Footage shows Israeli drone killing four Palestinian civilians
Haaretz - back to home page
Hi, habeeb
SUBSCRIBE NOWSUBSCRIBE NOW
Reading List
accessibility
A Massive Database of Evidence, Compiled by a Historian, Documents Israel's War Crimes in Gaza
A woman with a child is shot while waving a white flag ■ Starving girls are crushed to death in line for bread ■ A cuffed 62-year-old man is run over, evidently by a tank ■ An aerial strike targets people trying to help a wounded boy ■ A database of thousands of videos, photos, testimonies, reports and investigations documents the horrors committed by Israel in Gaza
Share in Twitter
Share in WhatsApp
Gift this article
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Go to comments
Print article
SaveSave article to reading list
Zen Read
Nir Hasson
Get email notification for articles from Nir HassonFollow
Dec 5, 2024
Footnote No. 379 of the carefully researched, wide-ranging document that historian Lee Mordechai has drawn up contains a link to a video clip. The footage shows a large dog gnawing something amid bushes. "Wai, wai, he took the terrorist, the terrorist is gone – gone in both senses," says the soldier who filmed the dog eating a corpse. After a few seconds the soldier raises the camera and adds, "But what a gorgeous view, a gorgeous sunset. A red sun is setting over the Gaza Strip." Definitely a beautiful sunset.
Netanyahu wants to shut us down. Read Haaretz now.
SUBSCRIBE
This is a subscriber-only article.
Hi, habeeb
SUBSCRIBE NOWSUBSCRIBE NOW
Reading List
accessibility
A Massive Database of Evidence, Compiled by a Historian, Documents Israel's War Crimes in Gaza
A woman with a child is shot while waving a white flag ■ Starving girls are crushed to death in line for bread ■ A cuffed 62-year-old man is run over, evidently by a tank ■ An aerial strike targets people trying to help a wounded boy ■ A database of thousands of videos, photos, testimonies, reports and investigations documents the horrors committed by Israel in Gaza
Share in Twitter
Share in WhatsApp
Gift this article
Send in e-mailSend in e-mail
Go to comments
Print article
SaveSave article to reading list
Zen Read
Nir Hasson
Get email notification for articles from Nir HassonFollow
Dec 5, 2024
Footnote No. 379 of the carefully researched, wide-ranging document that historian Lee Mordechai has drawn up contains a link to a video clip. The footage shows a large dog gnawing something amid bushes. "Wai, wai, he took the terrorist, the terrorist is gone – gone in both senses," says the soldier who filmed the dog eating a corpse. After a few seconds the soldier raises the camera and adds, "But what a gorgeous view, a gorgeous sunset. A red sun is setting over the Gaza Strip." Definitely a beautiful sunset.
Netanyahu wants to shut us down. Read Haaretz now.
SUBSCRIBE
This is a subscriber-only article.
For it to be considered a genocide more than 60% of the population would need to be annihilated. Right now the casualties are estimated to be 45,000 of which I'd say conservatively a quarter of them would be Hamas militants. That leaves 32,500 civilians dead out of a population of 1.9 million. 1.7% of the population. Not even remotely close to being a genocide by definition.
I call it a war with civilian casualties. Its unfortunate that this many civilians have to perish but the close proximity between Hamas targets and civilian populations makes it that much more challenging.
That is absolutely false and untrue.
Genocide is defined by the UN genocide convention.
For it to be a genocide, intent needs to be proven.
The numbers have nothing to do with it.
At the same time, Amnesty in Israel, the people who are actually there to get data reject the genocide finding.
www.theguardian.com
www.timesofisrael.com
They say there are likely war crimes, possibly including ethnic cleansing, that need to be investigated but they reject the claim.
As Amnesty Israel says, there is an actual definition is international law. It's not just a word to use because you're upset.
Amnesty International’s Israel branch distances itself from ‘genocide’ claim
But local branch of rights group says ‘serious crimes’ were potentially taking place that needed investigation
www.theguardian.com
‘Predetermined conclusions’: Amnesty Israel workers slam parent group’s ‘genocide’ charge
Local branch rejects report's conclusion, but says Israeli actions 'may amount to crimes against humanity and ethnic cleansing'; US also rejects genocide conclusion
www.timesofisrael.com
They say there are likely war crimes, possibly including ethnic cleansing, that need to be investigated but they reject the claim.
As Amnesty Israel says, there is an actual definition is international law. It's not just a word to use because you're upset.
And many others do support the claim.At the same time, Amnesty in Israel, the people who are actually there to get data reject the genocide finding.
Amnesty International’s Israel branch distances itself from ‘genocide’ claim
But local branch of rights group says ‘serious crimes’ were potentially taking place that needed investigation
They say there are likely war crimes that need to be investigated but they reject the claim.
Okay then it really isn't a genocide then is it...If Israel wanted to they would annihilate the entire population.
Intent is what matters and needs to be proven.
The reports that call Israeli actions genocide, attempt to do just that.
Not entirely.
They've researched this and found that the ICJ tends to be politically biased towards the west and against the 3rd world.
Which I suppose is good for Israel when it comes to this genocide case.
''Since 1990, this term has been redefined to make it more correct politically. Initially, the term “third world” meant that a nation is “under-developed”. However, today it is replaced by the term “developing".
Sorry couldn't resist.
Last edited:
