Flying Ice on the Roads

Ref

Committee Member
Oct 29, 2002
5,143
1,077
113
web.archive.org
I was recently hit with sheet of ice from a vehicle in front of me. Smashed my windshield, (thank goodness it remained in tact, but major spider-webbed). I was able to get the plate number of the vehicle it came off of, and followed them to the next stop, where he basically said "too bad" and took off.

The cost of the windshield is much lower than my deductible (though I do have a small dent on my hood, which I can live with).

I contacted the local police and they told me to contact my insurance company. The insurance company told me that I can open up a claim, but chances are slim that I can prove the car in front of me had the ice.

For a couple of hundred bucks I would rather avoid the whole hassle of processing a claim and having my insurance inevitably go up...

My question is - Has anyone experienced this type of situation before?

I should consider myself lucky, as it could have been worse. Hopefully karma comes back and haunts the irresponsible asshole who took off...
 
This happened to me once on the 401.
Scared me silly as it hit my car like a sledge hammer, shattered and all the chunks covered the windshield. I could not see a thing for a moment or two while doing 90 kms/hr

The is ready bad behaviour
Many people are just lazy/cold/in-a-hurry to properly clear all the ice off their car.

However I also think that many are also too stupid to know what kind of hazard an ice sheet on their car represents to the drivers behind them.
 
Press the Legislature to make it illegal to not clear snow and ice off your vehicle before driving.

There are a number of jurisdictions here in North American where this is a criminal or motor vehicle offense.
 
Press the Legislature to make it illegal to not clear snow and ice off your vehicle before driving.

There are a number of jurisdictions here in North American where this is a criminal or motor vehicle offense.

Where I am it is a motor vehicle offense, but just a ticket(and mostly to stop people packing snow against their plate to obscure the #).

I was recently hit with sheet of ice from a vehicle in front of me. Smashed my windshield, (thank goodness it remained in tact, but major spider-webbed). I was able to get the plate number of the vehicle it came off of, and followed them to the next stop, where he basically said "too bad" and took off.

The cost of the windshield is much lower than my deductible (though I do have a small dent on my hood, which I can live with).

I contacted the local police and they told me to contact my insurance company. The insurance company told me that I can open up a claim, but chances are slim that I can prove the car in front of me had the ice.

For a couple of hundred bucks I would rather avoid the whole hassle of processing a claim and having my insurance inevitably go up...

My question is - Has anyone experienced this type of situation before?

I should consider myself lucky, as it could have been worse. Hopefully karma comes back and haunts the irresponsible asshole who took off...

Put on your big boy pants and pay out of pocket. It's the cheapest and easiest way to go.
 
To me this is more like an 'act of god' and only maybe 35% the fault of the driver in front of you.
I spent half an hour banging the ice off my car Sat. and Sun morning last week; but, some people don't have the time to deal with all that. A one inch thick sheet of ice on your roof is hard to get off and takes a lot of time.

Also, for the ice to fly through the air that far and not fall on the road you might have been following him too closely , too close for the ice to get low enough so it doesn't hit your windshield.

All I'm saying is that if every single member of this board had someone stop them in the parking lot at Shoppers Drug Mart last weekend and demand $350. bucks for a new windshield because a piece of ice allegedly came off their car, - a lot of people would tell the guy to take a hike and basically say something along the lines of 'act of god, so not my fault and fuck you I'm not giving you $350.'

That's just the way human beings are and you're being really naïve to expect anything more than that. In case you haven't noticed, life is not a sweet little Norman Rockwell painting; so, you need to get off the space shuttle and beam back down to planet earth with your expectations and stop being such a drama queen about every little thing that bugs you.
 
To me this is more like an 'act of god' and only maybe 35% the fault of the driver in front of you.
I spent half an hour banging the ice off my car Sat. and Sun morning last week; but, some people don't have the time to deal with all that. A one inch thick sheet of ice on your roof is hard to get off and takes a lot of time.

Also, for the ice to fly through the air that far and not fall on the road you might have been following him too closely , too close for the ice to get low enough so it doesn't hit your windshield.

All I'm saying is that if every single member of this board had someone stop them in the parking lot at Shoppers Drug Mart last weekend and demand $350. bucks for a new windshield because a piece of ice allegedly came off their car, - a lot of people would tell the guy to take a hike and basically say something along the lines of 'act of god, so not my fault and fuck you I'm not giving you $350.'

That's just the way human beings are and you're being really naïve to expect anything more than that. In case you haven't noticed, life is not a sweet little Norman Rockwell painting; so, you need to get off the space shuttle and beam back down to planet earth with your expectations and stop being such a drama queen about every little thing that bugs you.


As per following too close, in hind-sight it would have been safer to have in that position, as when a sheet like that peels off it goes way up in the air (picture, if you can, a sheet of plywood flying off the back of a moving truck - It's movement are sporadic).

As for being naive, I will admit I have never been in this situation before hence I was looking for feedback from others who may experienced this scenario before and perhaps share the opportunity to learn from them.

But thanks for your heartfelt advice, I have always respected your opinion, especially when you fully appreciate a situation and are able address it in such an eloquent manner.

Happy New Year Kilgore Trout!
 
To me this is more like an 'act of god' and only maybe 35% the fault of the driver in front of you.
I spent half an hour banging the ice off my car Sat. and Sun morning last week; but, some people don't have the time to deal with all that. A one inch thick sheet of ice on your roof is hard to get off and takes a lot of time.

I am sorry but that is a cop-out in my opinion. You know the car needs cleaning off, so plan for it. This too busy crap is just not flying with me. It is 100% the driver's fault. I have had NO ice, snow, etc on my car. Everyone is capable of it. Yes, it is hard, yes it takes time, but that is part of the responsibility of being a driver. Falling from buildings, etc is different.



All I'm saying is that if every single member of this board had someone stop them in the parking lot at Shoppers Drug Mart last weekend and demand $350. bucks for a new windshield because a piece of ice allegedly came off their car, - a lot of people would tell the guy to take a hike and basically say something along the lines of 'act of god, so not my fault and fuck you I'm not giving you $350.'

That's just the way human beings are and you're being really naïve to expect anything more than that. In case you haven't noticed, life is not a sweet little Norman Rockwell painting; so, you need to get off the space shuttle and beam back down to planet earth with your expectations and stop being such a drama queen about every little thing that bugs you.

Not all people are as selfish, and irresponsible as you suggest. Many are I agree, but not all. It was 100% the drivers fault and he was dick for not taking accountability for it. Ref will pay the price and move on. That is reality of this situation but to shut up about it and take it up the tail pipe is not going to help the situation either. I think Aardvark154 idea is best. Time to get something on the books and gets assholes like this to pay a fine if they are too lazy to clear off some ice and snow.
 
Ice flying off other cars and hitting you likely means you are following too
Close at an unsafe distance. Auto ice is only a very small percentage of the issue considering the ice that flies off transports and other larger commercial vehicles, which would be impossible to get on top of. it's Canada , it's winter. Keep safe by driving accordingly. Anticipate the worst and don't blame others
 
I've had a massive sheet of ice come off a semi right in front of me. It broke up and I managed to dodge the significant pieces. Thankfully I had room on either side of me to maneuver.

Makes me cringe when I see people driving on the freeway doing 120 km/h+ with a sheet of ice on their roof. I totally disagree with whitewaterguy above. Everyone has a responsibility to ensure their vehicle is safe to be on the roads and not a danger to fellow drivers. And when traveling at high speeds, that sheet of ice can stay airborne for some time, so it doesn't automatically mean the victim is following too closely.
 
I've had a massive sheet of ice come off a semi right in front of me. It broke up and I managed to dodge the significant pieces. Thankfully I had room on either side of me to maneuver.

Makes me cringe when I see people driving on the freeway doing 120 km/h+ with a sheet of ice on their roof. I totally disagree with whitewaterguy above. Everyone has a responsibility to ensure their vehicle is safe to be on the roads and not a danger to fellow drivers. And when traveling at high speeds, that sheet of ice can stay airborne for some time, so it doesn't automatically mean the victim is following too closely.
. Problem is there are way too many irresponsible drivers on the road, so the only person capable of keeping you safe on the road is you
 
To me this is more like an 'act of god' and only maybe 35% the fault of the driver in front of you.
I spent half an hour banging the ice off my car Sat. and Sun morning last week; but, some people don't have the time to deal with all that. A one inch thick sheet of ice on your roof is hard to get off and takes a lot of time.

Also, for the ice to fly through the air that far and not fall on the road you might have been following him too closely , too close for the ice to get low enough so it doesn't hit your windshield.

All I'm saying is that if every single member of this board had someone stop them in the parking lot at Shoppers Drug Mart last weekend and demand $350. bucks for a new windshield because a piece of ice allegedly came off their car, - a lot of people would tell the guy to take a hike and basically say something along the lines of 'act of god, so not my fault and fuck you I'm not giving you $350.'

That's just the way human beings are and you're being really naïve to expect anything more than that. In case you haven't noticed, life is not a sweet little Norman Rockwell painting; so, you need to get off the space shuttle and beam back down to planet earth with your expectations and stop being such a drama queen about every little thing that bugs you.

And if your ice sheet causes an accident where someone is hurt will you still call that an act of God?
Or will you realize your full schedule /laziness/ arrogance / ignorance is the cause ?

Every driver has the responsibility to ensure their vehicle is safe to drive for themselves and others on the road
Leaving a sheet of ice on your car is no different than driving with faulty brakes, YOUR CAR IS NOT SAFE
 
Considering the charges that drivers at my employer have had for ice coming off their trucks (and enough of it happening for the company to put a drive thru ice/snow removal device at a few of our Toronto locations), I would say yes you can be charged already. However, law enforcement generally has to see it first hand.
 
Sorry to hear about that Ref. I'm surprised it hasn't happened more often to others. One of the first things I did on Sunday (after I tried to shovel my driveway) was to warm up my vehicle and take it to the nearby Car Wash. It took only $5 coins, and got rid of all of the ice. I may not always keep the inside as tidy as I could, but removing an ice layer of this thickness, was totally the driver's responsibility and NOT an Act of GOD....
 
Mr Ref, the guy was a dingbat. Report the accident then file a lawsuit against his insurance company. Let's see how his "too bad" resonates when his premium goes up over 80%. I have two lawsuits pending from a rear end collision from last February. This is a question of due diligence so get consultation.

Here's an interesting side note and a story of invasive species in reverse. A group of botanists have been working throughout the GTA, identifying which trees sustained the most damage. No.1 on the list are Eurasian Maples, our Canadian variant bends but does not break.

Happy New Year to all, Ref get some help.
 
Mr Ref, the guy was a dingbat. Report the accident then file a lawsuit against his insurance company. Let's see how his "too bad" resonates when his premium goes up over 80%. I have two lawsuits pending from a rear end collision from last February. This is a question of due diligence so get consultation.

"too bad" will resonate quite well when the judge throws it out because it's a 'he said she said' situation.
 
. Problem is there are way too many irresponsible drivers on the road, so the only person capable of keeping you safe on the road is you

That's something I subscribe to. I would have been in deep shit on several occasions if I didn't.

But I think irresponsible drivers should be held responsible when damage or harm results from their idiocy. So I sure as hell will blame them when something goes wrong.