All joking aside, I find this an interesting topic for discussion.
All my life I have been a heavier person, though there have been times I have been in very good shape. I try to watch what I eat most of the time, (I typically eat game meat, and vegetables I grow myself), and I exercise on a regular basis. Yet despite all this, I still carry the pounds. Though I am a large man, I would not consider myself 'out of shape', as I can most certainly out preform many more slender people in both the gym, and in aerobic activities.
For example...
I weigh 240 lbs., but I can still bench press my own weight, run 5 kms. (though I don't break any speed records), play lacrosse and rugby, can ride 50 kms. on my bicycle, etc. I also still workout on both a heavy bag and a speed bag for 20 minutes every day. (anyone who has ever done that knows how tiring it is).
I know one of the reasons that I have the problems losing weight is that my 'serving sizes' are not what one would consider moderate. The times that I have lost weight, (I've lost and gained hundreds of pounds in my life), I have literally had to starve myself, and put in at least 2+ hours of exercise every day, but as soon as I slow down, the weight comes right back on. At this point in my life I do not have the motivation to do that yet again.
Others might disagree, but I think that being 'in shape', and carrying extra weight are not necessarily mutually exclusive. I am fit, I am just not slim.