Final questions regarding Bell vs. Rogers wireless (WARNING: Extremely length post..)

Hi everyone!

I am the type of person who will analyze the hell out of each option I have for everything...am I neurotic? Lol...perhaps but I like to think I`m a smart consumer. With that said, I apologize for starting another thread with this topic but I really need educated or experienced answers and comments as I wish to purchase the phone and service as late as Saturday.

I want to use the TREO 600, but I need to know the pro`s and cons` for Rogers and Bell.

I currently use Rogers for internet and cable, so adding a cellular/ data package will give me the choice of a bundle, thus reducing my monthly bill altogether.

I currently use Bell for a landline (which is absolutely pointless as I`m never home and when I am, friends/ family ALWAYS call my cellphone, so it`s basically a waste of money and when I get this additional cellphone, I will be cancelling my bell landline).

The Plans:

BELL- DATA RATES/ PLANS

1X Data $75 http://www.bell.ca/media/en/all_regions/images/icons/icon_digital.gif Price: $75.00 /month For use with 1X-ready devices on the 1X network*.

MB Included: 40, Additional MB: $5/MB

Benefits
  • The 1X network is packet-based, this means you are billed on the volume of data sent and received, not for the time you are connected to the network.
  • Speeds of up to 86kbps††
  • No roaming charges in Canada
  • No contract required
  • Packet-based billing†

    Detailed billing 1 megabyte (MB) is approximately equivalent to:
  • 250 e-mails (of 200 words)
  • 20 e-mails with attachments
  • 20 pages of excel spreadsheets
  • 10 Web pages
1X Data $50 http://www.bell.ca/media/en/all_regions/images/icons/icon_digital.gif Price: $50.00 /month For use with 1X-ready devices on the 1X network*.

MB Included: 10, Additional MB: $6/MB

Benefits
  • The 1X network is packet-based, this means you are billed on the volume of data sent and received, not for the time you are connected to the network.
  • Speeds of up to 86kbps††
  • No roaming charges in Canada
  • No contract required
  • Packet-based billing†

    Detailed billing 1 megabyte (MB) is approximately equivalent to:
  • 250 e-mails (of 200 words)
  • 20 e-mails with attachments
  • 20 pages of excel spreadsheets
  • 10 Web pages
Bell TALK TIME RATES/ PLANS (which would be additional to the data package)

Minutes Included:
350 weekday minutes
Unlimited weeknights
Unlimited weekends
Additional Minutes: 25 ¢/min
Price: $45.00 /month [url="http://www.bell.ca/media/en/all_regions/images/buttons/button_select.gif"]http://www.bell.ca/media/en/all_regions/images/buttons/button_select.gif[/url]
Long distance charges are 30¢/minute. Canada to Canada and/or Canada to USA. Roaming charges are extra. Included features:
  • Call Waiting
  • Call Forwarding
  • Conference Calling
  • Detailed Billing
  • Touch Base Service
Limited time offer also includes:
3 months free Picture*/Video Messaging** and Mobile Browser (camera and camcorder phones)
Up to 3 months of unlimited local talking1
All-in-one Nights & Weekends includes basic features, fees and valuable options such as free incoming Text Messaging. You`ll know what services you`re entitled to and how much you pay. Also, detailed billing lets you monitor costs by showing exactly how much airtime you use.
  • Talk all you want Monday to Friday from 8 p.m. to 7 a.m. and weekends from 8 p.m. Friday to 7 a.m. Monday.
  • 350 weekday minutes
  • Get 20 unlimited local calls/month to one number ($6 value)
  • Free incoming Text Messages
  • No connection charges ($35 value)
  • No hidden monthly fees ($7.45 value)
  • Know exactly where your dollars are being spent with detailed billing ($12 value)
  • Benefit from all the basic features (Call Waiting, Call Forwarding and Conference Calling)
I`m having a hard time trying to find the Rogers data plans...can anyone help me out? Also, why don`t either companies offer a voice AND date package together as opposed to pricing them separately? I`m so confused! HELP!
smile.gif
 
Test drove the rogers one had no luck with it.Some laptops present a problem with range,my Toshiba is one of them.Went to bell,checked it out,figured they would be the best deal cause they offer more service compatability outside of the city,where I would use it the most.Bottom line,this service is just to expensive and not reliable enough as of right now,plus,or I mean minus,it is way to much money.Better off going to an internet cafe,motel with free high speed.
 
Uh....I'm sorry...you were saying something about Bell vs Rogers.....?

**how can a man concentrate looking at that fine ass.....just not possible.....sheesh....
 
You probably won't need much in terms of data. At work I keep my guys (about 100 of them) on 10MB plans. I'm one of the heaviest data users because I'm always testing new stuff out. Out of all our users, I've got a grand total of 3 (I'm one of them) who routinely go over 10MB per month. The overage is generally about 2 - 3 MB so it's really not worth our while to upgrade to the next highest plan for data. If you need a benchmark, I get about 100 - 120 emails per day at work and the 10MB per month would pretty much cover that usage.

I will note that none of my guys use the data side to open attachments. That's why they have laptops after all. This may make a difference in your case. The only way you'll really start using a lot of data would be if you plug your phone into your computer and start using the phone as a wireless modem for everything. This is only really useful as a stop-gap measure when there's no real phone line / high speed access handy. Cellular modem performance is a lot better than it used to be, but it's still not really there in North America.

While there's little technical reason to keep voice & data separate, that's just the way it is until North America goes 3G.

In terms of voice minutes, you have to determine that yourself. How chatty are you? Only you really know. Similarly only you really know where your calls go to and where you use your phone. At work I keep my guys on a plan that includes all calls within North America. Some of my friends only use their cellphones within the GTA. YMMV so get whatever plan is right for you.

Rogers data plans are in their business section. Try this link:

http://www.shoprogers.com/business/...siness_plans.asp?plan=dataservice&cat=2&typ=2
 
I can't believe no one has mentioned your GREAT ASS :cool: !
 
xarir said:
...This is only really useful as a stop-gap measure when there's no real phone line / high speed access handy. Cellular modem performance is a lot better than it used to be, but it's still not really there in North America....

We recently did some 1X testing on Bell and the performance was very poor. About 7-11kbps which is less than 10% of what it's suppose to be (83 kbps). This is using both 1X phones and Sierra Wireless cards along the QEW and 427 corridors.
 
Wow, thanks to everyone for the ass comments- y'all sure know how to make a gal feel bootylicious. LOL.

On a more important and serious note, I really appreciate the feedback and insight about the topic I was inquiring about...

Basically, I'll be using this phone for business (THIS business). I am rarely home to use my computer to acess emails and pm's and I certainly can't check these things from my friends or families homes and who wants to go to a webcafe all the time? I want the TREO to assist me with handling my business in an effective manner...and honestly, the money really isn't a factor for me. If the unit is going to help me stay organized and up-to-date with my emails and client relations, it will be better for my business and my sanity...

So...BELL OR ROGERS?! Lol.

V.
 
I don't know if this will effect your decision but the Rogers' version of the Treo is a world phone (quad band) and the Bell isn't.
 
If you are in a high rise, Bell is not suitable, sometimes you can't use the buzz code. If you bundle Rogers, you automatically receive a 15 % discount.
 
If money isn't a factor, why not get both. Try them out for a couple of months and see which one you prefer.

And then bend over and take some more pictures of that sweet ass of yours...
 
Goober Mcfly said:
If money isn't a factor, why not get both. Try them out for a couple of months and see which one you prefer.

And then bend over and take some more pictures of that sweet ass of yours...
That would be two timing though!