Fighting a $250 Parking Ticket

GameBoy27

Well-known member
Nov 23, 2004
13,042
3,099
113
I got a $250 parking ticket the other day while dropping my Dad off at the mall for a meeting at the bank. He's elderly, uses a walker and I have a disabled plate permit which allows me to park in those spots. The problem was all the designated spots were taken near the entrance and we even waited 10 minutes for one to become available but nobody vacated a spot. Parking in a regular spot wasn't an option as there's an incline towards the mall which would make it next to impossible for him to walk up.

So I pulled up to the curb out of the way while I helped him through the doors. When I got back to move the car less than a minute later, the parking guy was in the process of filling out the ticket. I explained what I was doing but he continued to fill out the ticket and said "too late" and put the ticket on my windshield.

What I should have done was pull up directly in front of the mall entrance blocking car and pedestrian traffic while I got his walker out of the trunk and helped him through the doors then go back and park the car. Probably still illegal but might not have gotten a ticket, but I hate blocking traffic.

Now I'm completely aware that I was illegally parked in a fire route which you aren't allowed to even with a disabled permit but I honestly didn't have any other choice.

I will fight it but what do you think my chances are of getting it thrown out? Maybe they'll lower the fine a bit?
 
Fight it.
Explain it as clearly and succinctly as you did for us.
Take pictures of the site... Especially of elderly disabled dad.
I'm sure you'll see leniency from the JP and prosecutor.
 
plead guilty , in court and it is highly likely to be greatly reduced . plead not guilty they will bury you - this has been my experience .

good luck
 
Fight it.
Explain it as clearly and succinctly as you did for us.
Take pictures of the site... Especially of elderly disabled dad.
I'm sure you'll see leniency from the JP and prosecutor.

Thanks Tiny... You know, I try to do the best for my elderly parents but then you get nailed like this!

Even though I'm allowed to park in a designated spot when escorting my folks around, I prefer to drop them off and park in a regular spot leaving those for driver's with disabilities. I can walk just fine.

plead guilty , in court and it is highly likely to be greatly reduced . plead not guilty they will bury you - this has been my experience .

good luck

Technically, I am guilty so that makes sense. The crown usually talks to everyone before court is in session. They will often give you advice at that time as well.
 
Fight it.
Explain it as clearly and succinctly as you did for us.
Take pictures of the site... Especially of elderly disabled dad.
I'm sure you'll see leniency from the JP and prosecutor.

if you go this route have 3 sets of pictures judge , prosecutor and for yourself
because i had 1 set of pictures the judge refused to look at them .
 
If you have any paperwork/receipts to indicate that your dad was there make sure to have it with you in court. Request a statement from the dickless meter maid. You may not get one, but that will be in your favor at court time. ( request it several times. ) Make specific request on what he saw and what he said.
 
Fight it, but quit saying you didn't have a choice. You always have a choice, i.e. waiting.

Easy for you to say just wait, but I had to get Dad to his meeting at the bank followed by an appointment with his doctor. After that I had to take him home then pick up my Mum and take her to an appointment. So no, I didn't have time to wait around for an hour for a spot. I don't think you know what it's like caring for two parents in their 90's.
 
If you do not fight it you will have to pay, at write an explanation to the prosecutor and include all paperwork.
 
I had a very similar situation once. Parked at the curb and ran inside. Took no more than 2 minutes. Came out and the parking guy was punching my plate into his machine. He finished it snd handed it to me. It was for parking in a fire route.

I decided to take it to court intent on arguing that I wasn't parked.

In court a guy came up before my case and pled not guilty with the same reason I was going to use. The judge said "you aren't in your car so you are parked". He got assessed the stated fine + court costs. I figured I was screwed !

When my case was called, I pled guilty with an explanation. My explanation was that I was only in the store for about 90 seconds when I came out and the parking officer printed off the ticket. The judge asked the parking guy if the ticket was finished before I arrived back at my car. The answer was "not completely, I finished it after he arrived". The judge said "Tie goes to the runner ... If he got back to his car before the ticket was finished then you can't give it to him". The whole fine was waived.
 
The real PITA is that you have to go to city hall in person to plead not guilty for a parking ticket. They make it so expensive to defend that you might as well pay it.
 
go to court... fight it but talk to the crown . take a picture and of dad and your plate and see what the crown will do. usually the crown will make you an offer...
 
Oh I think hes got a good chance of having the ticket dropped especially because of his father's condition. In fact if I were him I'd bring his father to court.
 
Bring your dad to court with you, if you can find a place to park that is...
 
there's an asshole parking cop in my neighbourhood he will try to physically block your car whilst he writes the ticket for parking past 2am on the street, even if he sees you coming he'll keep writing it. From what i've read if they haven't physically handed you the ticket/put it on your windshield you can just drive off, fuck them they can't do anything about that.

i feel that being a parking cop is the most hated job by the public. who gives off-duty parking cops parking tickets?

in your case, consult x copper?
 
you will be found guilty, you parked illegally..no magistrate wants to hear guilty with explanation...if you plead not guilty and the enforcement guy is there , your,e fucked...plead guilty and the fine will be cut in half, and the magistrate will even give you time to pay it, if you want that option..
 
without reading all the other post in this thread, 100% fight it, and check the little box that's says you want your trial to be held in French. You will never hear about it ever again....I promise. This is only if your ticket is from the city of Toronto. If it's from Vaughan, your fucked.

I don't care what anyone else says, trust me on this. I've done this about 20-25 times and have never gotten a letter with a trial date. It just gets lost in the system.
 
Last edited:
I had a very similar situation once. Parked at the curb and ran inside. Took no more than 2 minutes. Came out and the parking guy was punching my plate into his machine. He finished it snd handed it to me. It was for parking in a fire route.

I decided to take it to court intent on arguing that I wasn't parked.

In court a guy came up before my case and pled not guilty with the same reason I was going to use. The judge said "you aren't in your car so you are parked". He got assessed the stated fine + court costs. I figured I was screwed !

When my case was called, I pled guilty with an explanation. My explanation was that I was only in the store for about 90 seconds when I came out and the parking officer printed off the ticket. The judge asked the parking guy if the ticket was finished before I arrived back at my car. The answer was "not completely, I finished it after he arrived". The judge said "Tie goes to the runner ... If he got back to his car before the ticket was finished then you can't give it to him". The whole fine was waived.
This sounds promising! Good luck