F-35 II Lightning

F-35 purchase

  • YES, I support the deal

    Votes: 53 64.6%
  • NO, the deal must be cancelled

    Votes: 29 35.4%

  • Total voters
    82
in the end, I think the total numbers of JSF built will be about 1/3 of the original projected total...which will drive the cost of this pink elephant up to about 145M/copy....FAR more then the F22...what a joke. The US needs to slash defence spending radically. Once there is some sign of economic growth in the US, defence spending will be attacked. The US navy now has more combat power then the next 13 largest navies combined......this is simply RETARDED.
 
There's no "I think we need new planes, but this deal is a bit excessive" option.

Because I think we need new equipment, but this deal does seem too expensive.
 
Part of the draw of the F35 for Canadian politicians is the fact that many parts are made in Canada and it was developed, in part, by Canadian designers and manufacturers. By purchasing this aircraft some jobs in Canada will be assured. Remember it's not just about the capability of the plane itself. Many other factors go into the purchase of a military weapon by governments.

In particular, the current purchase of several hundred Leopard 2A6 main battle tanks from Germany to replace the really old Leopard 1 that Canada has been using since the 60's. Part of this deal was a joint training regime in Alberta for the German military.

Also, remember the purchase of the CF101 VooDoo back in the 60's. Many people complained that the Canadian government should have purchased the F4 Phantom or continued the Arrow program. It was the CF18 Hornet that replaced the VooDoo. The main reason for the VooDoo purchase was cost.

The Leopards were bought in the late 70's not the 60"s
 
in the end, I think the total numbers of JSF built will be about 1/3 of the original projected total...which will drive the cost of this pink elephant up to about 145M/copy....FAR more then the F22...what a joke. The US needs to slash defence spending radically. Once there is some sign of economic growth in the US, defence spending will be attacked. The US navy now has more combat power then the next 13 largest navies combined......this is simply RETARDED.

The cost per unit will not change for us , the price per unit for the Americans could very well change id theyt cahnge the order size.

The F35 was intended to replace all the F15, F16, and F18 variants that are being used outside the US navy. That is a very big number of airframes.
The argument about the spin off work is interesting, any design , manufacturing work that canadian companies do for the basic airframe would be used for the entire production run, country specific stuff such as avionics or radio/radar equipment would probably go bto the purchasing country or its designated manufacturer.
 
The cost per unit will not change for us , the price per unit for the Americans could very well change id theyt cahnge the order size.

The F35 was intended to replace all the F15, F16, and F18 variants that are being used outside the US navy. That is a very big number of airframes.
The argument about the spin off work is interesting, any design , manufacturing work that canadian companies do for the basic airframe would be used for the entire production run, country specific stuff such as avionics or radio/radar equipment would probably go bto the purchasing country or its designated manufacturer.

HA HAAA AA HA ...the price per unit has almost doubled since the inception of the program. Unlike landscaping contracts, jet fighters are not fixed cost contracts.....current price amortizes development cost against a production estimate of 4000 planes. I doubt that many will be built..

http://www.flightglobal.com/articles/2010/03/19/339714/f-35-cost-estimate-grows-up-to-nearly-90.html
 
Darian, baby. [post #58] Your first contribution to this erudite society -- and what you've come up with is that the road to world peace is for Canada to have no arms!!

On the other hand, there is some truth that sovereignty isn't just about military strength and readiness. In fact, suppose the Danes and the Russians, and the others who have designs on the Arctic, were to develop amphibious (or even just land)vehicles that can roam around the Arctic? What use are squadrons of fighter aircraft against them? -- assuming we are not actually at war with the Danes, etc.

Sovereignty of the Arctic belongs to the nation that can populate the Arctic with large numbers of go-anywhere vehicles, with people in them.

The vehicles don't exist yet, even as designs. But it can't be too difficult technically, and Canada already has impressive technologies in that area. We could be first! Imagine that - whatever areas the Russians and Americans fly their fighter aircraft over, we are waving to them from our ground bases.
 
I have to admit, it's a nice looking and super maneuverable aircraft BUT is it just me or did that first "jump" take off look very shakey? I think Canada has better things to spend it's money on!
 
I have to admit, it's a nice looking and super maneuverable aircraft BUT is it just me or did that first "jump" take off look very shakey? I think Canada has better things to spend it's money on!

Canada isn't purchasing the jumpjet version. We are purchasing the F-35A version designed to replace the F-16, Tornado, and Eurofighter (none of which we operate.)

A big portion of our air defence is patrolling remote areas, generally over northern seas and/or ice. The idea behind the F/A-18 was that in the event of an engine failure, the aircraft could limp home on the other engine. This is a big reason why the F/A-18 is used by the US Navy, and not something smaller and cheaper like the single engine F-16. Single engine fighters aren't the best idea in trying conditions at sea. The F-35 is not a replacement for the F/A-18, and if we try to deploy it as a replacement for the F/A-18, we will almost certainly fail.

If the U.S. Navy isn't planning on replacing all the F/A-18 planes (which include specialized planes), with F-35s, why are we?
 
Canada isn't purchasing the jumpjet version. We are purchasing the F-35A version designed to replace the F-16, Tornado, and Eurofighter (none of which we operate.)

A big portion of our air defence is patrolling remote areas, generally over northern seas and/or ice. The idea behind the F/A-18 was that in the event of an engine failure, the aircraft could limp home on the other engine. This is a big reason why the F/A-18 is used by the US Navy, and not something smaller and cheaper like the single engine F-16. Single engine fighters aren't the best idea in trying conditions at sea. The F-35 is not a replacement for the F/A-18, and if we try to deploy it as a replacement for the F/A-18, we will almost certainly fail.

If the U.S. Navy isn't planning on replacing all the F/A-18 planes (which include specialized planes), with F-35s, why are we?

Because the US Navy has thousands of planes and we only have 80....???
 
The Americans are so far under water economically, I can't see the F22 program surviving frankly. There are already rumblings about moth-balling the entire program.

I agree that a single engine fighter is inferior.

Interestingly, I read that we just issued a contract to overhaul the remaining F-18's to keep them flying another 6 or 7 years.
 
Interestingly, I read that we just issued a contract to overhaul the remaining F-18's to keep them flying another 6 or 7 years.

The F-35's won't be delivered for many more years, and even if they are, we still need the F-18's.
 
The Americans are so far under water economically, I can't see the F22 program surviving frankly. There are already rumblings about moth-balling the entire program.

I agree that a single engine fighter is inferior.

Interestingly, I read that we just issued a contract to overhaul the remaining F-18's to keep them flying another 6 or 7 years.

F-22 already has an end in sight... production will stop at around 187 planes. The current ones will fly for quite a while yet I think.