Exchange rates-VISA vs cash

Worf

Well-known member
Sep 26, 2001
1,890
28
48
In a house somewhere
A question regarding exchange rate conversions. I will be going to Europe later this month, and spending upwards of 2000 euro. Which is more efficient - spending this money using a Canadian VISA card and letting VISA convert it using their rates, or buying euros here at the best bank rate, and carrying it there to spend. I know the rates change daily, but if you were to assume that all transactions could occur in one day, which would be better?
 
Credit cards can put 2 to 2.5% premium on the spot rate for transactions. if you can front the cash, best to get the best rate you can here.
 
eyeofthedragon said:
consider using a debit card



I'll credit you with that suggestion, bank on it.


Where is the farkin ratty furred bear these days.????
 
Debit cards is a very good way to gout if you need some cash from it always check the fees before you use any given machine . Sometimes the fee can be excessive. A friend use to prepay his VISA card giving him a credit balance so he could grab cash without paying interest and he felt this gave him the best rates with lowest fees .

Boo
 
So, I have 2 suggestions.
1. Debit - what premium do they charge for using the debit card? Is the rate the same as cash on the day you use it overseas?
2. Pay cash to VISA - isn't there still a 2-2.5% charge for using it? I don't plan to pay interest, so if there is no extra charge if you have a credit balance, I could go this route.

Thanks for the info.
 
Worf said:
So, I have 2 suggestions.
1. Debit - what premium do they charge for using the debit card? Is the rate the same as cash on the day you use it overseas?
2. Pay cash to VISA - isn't there still a 2-2.5% charge for using it? I don't plan to pay interest, so if there is no extra charge if you have a credit balance, I could go this route.

Thanks for the info.

I'll go in Europe as well and I got information from my Scotia office, that I still have to double check just in case... And they confirm what's been said before:

1) If you use a credit card, the interests apply directly. So it's not a good solution for me (and for most credit cards so I understood).

2) The debit card seems an excellent mean as you can withdraw cash from any cash machine with, apparently, only $1.5 or $2 as inter-bank charge. The exchange rate seems to be the official one. Problem is that you cannot pay with it in Europe from what I understood.

3) Buy cash before leaving - and have it delivered at your home (extra cost). Problem is that you'll have to carry it with you... but the exchange rate is here again excellent.
 
Traveller's checks from AmEx as an alternative to cash if you don't want to carry?

Personally I use a bank card to withdrawl cash from ATM machines overseas and most of the time get excellent rates. This is done in US, Canada, Europe and Asia so I've seen all the different rates. My bank used to waive all the fees too (couple of dollars per transaction) but they are getting stingy lately.
 
osanowo said:
2) The debit card...Problem is that you cannot pay with it in Europe from what I understood.
Debit card payment is only popular in N.America.

Careful withdrawing from ATM, especially smaller banks, fees can vary. Smaller bank ATM may not display english & if it eats your card you're screw.

I prefer credit card for purchase & fraud protection. Have a bit of Euro for tips.

In my travels, traveller cheques are only accepted at large stores. Banks/hotels may charge fee for cashing.

Bon Vonage.
 
In Europe, you can use the ATMS and get decent exchange rates but you get zapped $4 for each withdrawl. Try and plan your spending to limit your withdrawls without being stupid & carrying large amounts of cash.
 
I was in Europe for 3 weeks in 2001. I don't know if things are still the same, but I found out the hard way that if you plan on using a bank card at ATM's make sure that it is connected to a checking account and not a savings account. I had left $ in a savings account and had planned on hitting atm's as I needed it. Tried 1 bank machine and it didn't work. Wasn't sure why. Tried another and it ate my card. This was on a Saturday. I had some cash on me, so was ok until Monday. When I went to the bank, I was advised that I could only access funds that were in a checking account not a savings account. I had to spend the 3 weeks living off of cash advances on my credit card. If I remember correctly I paid quite a bit in fees.
 
rcw said:
I was in Europe for 3 weeks in 2001. I don't know if things are still the same, but I found out the hard way that if you plan on using a bank card at ATM's make sure that it is connected to a checking account and not a savings account. I had left $ in a savings account and had planned on hitting atm's as I needed it. Tried 1 bank machine and it didn't work. Wasn't sure why. Tried another and it ate my card. This was on a Saturday. I had some cash on me, so was ok until Monday. When I went to the bank, I was advised that I could only access funds that were in a checking account not a savings account. I had to spend the 3 weeks living off of cash advances on my credit card. If I remember correctly I paid quite a bit in fees.

Yes because in Europe you cannot pay with what is on your savings account. The money must firstly be transfered to the checking account...
 
smiley27 said:
I normally use CCs for payments, but be aware that they are not that widely accepted as in North America (in restaurants, stores).
We must of hit different areas as they had handheld CC machines did the receipt right at our table in restaurants. Stores had no problem with Visas & MC. True Amex less popular.