I've inserted vibrating butt plugs into many a GF's rear, then my cock in her pussy.
Even those who protest anal (but don't completely rule it out) are amazed at how good it feels. When you're inside her, you can definitely feel the vibrator as well.
I highly recommend. If you really want to get kinky (and who doesn't) I recommend a butt plug in your own ass at the same time (non vibrating) and it will completely blow your mind.
Ditto if you are adventurous, have her insert anal beads into your ass gently as she is sucking your cock and just at the moment you climax, she pulls them out. You will swear your intestines are coming right out of the end of your cock.