Taxman's second bite proves crime doesn't pay
Court seizes RRSP, then Ottawa taxes its withdrawal
Arthur Drache, Financial Post
Published: Tuesday, April 18, 2006
There has always been an interesting interrelationship between the proceeds of criminal activity and the income tax system. From early days, the courts have taken a consistent position that revenue from criminal activity is subject to tax as income from other sources. The individuals receiving the income can claim "legitimate" expenses against that income ... if the expenditure can be proven. Past cases show that proving, for example, the payment of bribes can be difficult, as receipts are hard to come by.
But a recent case shows a new danger to those caught in the criminal law net. As most readers are aware, changes to the law a few years ago allow seizure of ill-gotten gains under special provisions of the Criminal Code.
A case which came before Judge Cam McArthur shows just how tough the rules can turn out to be. Joseph Toth pleaded guilty to criminal charges involving an escort business that he had operated. The attorney general of Quebec then obtained a court order which seized Toth's assets including his RRSP. This money all went to the Crown.
The CRA then came after Toth claiming he owed taxes on his RRSP on the basis that there was a payment out of the plan which was taxable. Subsection 146(8) of the Income Tax Act requires the benefits of the RRSP to be received by the taxpayer and the CRA argued that the RRSP forfeiture to the government as ordered, resulted in a "constructive receipt."
Toth, of course, argued that since he did not receive any benefit from the RRSP funds, he shouldn't pay tax on the amount received by the Crown. The test, according to McArthur after a review of the prior cases, was two-fold to make the payments taxable.
(a) Toth would need to have authorized or in any event acquiesced in the payment; or
(b) Even if he had not authorized or acquiesced ... he would have had to be under a legal obligation to make the repayment so that the payment ... had the effect of relieving him of that obligation.
In this case, McArthur found that the forfeiture order was a legal obligation on the taxpayer, and that the taxpayer constructively received the benefit on May 29, 2003, when the court order of forfeiture was handed down.
In the event, the appeal was dismissed and Mr. Toth found himself owing money to the government with respect to money which the government has seized. Truly, when it comes to the tax system, crime does pay ... and the penalty may be higher than what the court has imposed.
© National Post 2006
Court seizes RRSP, then Ottawa taxes its withdrawal
Arthur Drache, Financial Post
Published: Tuesday, April 18, 2006
There has always been an interesting interrelationship between the proceeds of criminal activity and the income tax system. From early days, the courts have taken a consistent position that revenue from criminal activity is subject to tax as income from other sources. The individuals receiving the income can claim "legitimate" expenses against that income ... if the expenditure can be proven. Past cases show that proving, for example, the payment of bribes can be difficult, as receipts are hard to come by.
But a recent case shows a new danger to those caught in the criminal law net. As most readers are aware, changes to the law a few years ago allow seizure of ill-gotten gains under special provisions of the Criminal Code.
A case which came before Judge Cam McArthur shows just how tough the rules can turn out to be. Joseph Toth pleaded guilty to criminal charges involving an escort business that he had operated. The attorney general of Quebec then obtained a court order which seized Toth's assets including his RRSP. This money all went to the Crown.
The CRA then came after Toth claiming he owed taxes on his RRSP on the basis that there was a payment out of the plan which was taxable. Subsection 146(8) of the Income Tax Act requires the benefits of the RRSP to be received by the taxpayer and the CRA argued that the RRSP forfeiture to the government as ordered, resulted in a "constructive receipt."
Toth, of course, argued that since he did not receive any benefit from the RRSP funds, he shouldn't pay tax on the amount received by the Crown. The test, according to McArthur after a review of the prior cases, was two-fold to make the payments taxable.
(a) Toth would need to have authorized or in any event acquiesced in the payment; or
(b) Even if he had not authorized or acquiesced ... he would have had to be under a legal obligation to make the repayment so that the payment ... had the effect of relieving him of that obligation.
In this case, McArthur found that the forfeiture order was a legal obligation on the taxpayer, and that the taxpayer constructively received the benefit on May 29, 2003, when the court order of forfeiture was handed down.
In the event, the appeal was dismissed and Mr. Toth found himself owing money to the government with respect to money which the government has seized. Truly, when it comes to the tax system, crime does pay ... and the penalty may be higher than what the court has imposed.
© National Post 2006

