Elliot Lake Inquiry

night ride

Active member
Jul 23, 2009
3,444
5
38
Anyone following the Elliot Lake Inquiry?? Seems like a sad circus. I think the main recommendations that are going to come out of it are already pretty plain to see, however the lawyers are going to be milking several hundred thousand more $$$$ from us in the following weeks.

On the plus side there oddly seems to be a large increase in SP's in the general area with all these out-of-town lawyers working four hour days floating around.:)
 
Everyone will point the finger at everyone else.

That's what will happen.

The government will blame the owner, the owner will blame the Engineer who designed the place, the Engineer who designed the place will blame the various engineering firms that were hired over the years to do structural inspections of the place. The various Engineers who did structural inspections of the place will blame the owner saying that the owner did not follow their recommendations, or that the owner did not agree to the structural engineer's complete inspection proposal, or that the owners did not follow the Engineer's recommendations, the owner will say that the Engineers who did the the inspections did not make it clear to the owners that the problem was dire, the owner will blame the contractors who either built the place, or maintained the place. The contractors will blame the government, and the circle starts anew.

Ultimately, it WILL come down to the Engineers who carried out structural inspections. IF (And it's a big if) they had a mandate to do a 100% inpsection of the building and they failed to carry out their work properly, they will be found at fault.

My guess is that the owner probably chewed through several consulting engineering firms until he found one to do the work cheap enough and who would tell him (the owner) what he wanted to hear, i.e. "no serious problems"

Of course, if the original design is deficient, all bets are off.

In reality, they will probably spread the blame around, even to guys who don't deserve to get blamed.
 
Everyone will point the finger at everyone else.

That's what will happen.

The government will blame the owner, the owner will blame the Engineer who designed the place, the Engineer who designed the place will blame the various engineering firms that were hired over the years to do structural inspections of the place. The various Engineers who did structural inspections of the place will blame the owner saying that the owner did not follow their recommendations, or that the owner did not agree to the structural engineer's complete inspection proposal, or that the owners did not follow the Engineer's recommendations, the owner will say that the Engineers who did the the inspections did not make it clear to the owners that the problem was dire, the owner will blame the contractors who either built the place, or maintained the place. The contractors will blame the government, and the circle starts anew.

Ultimately, it WILL come down to the Engineers who carried out structural inspections. IF (And it's a big if) they had a mandate to do a 100% inpsection of the building and they failed to carry out their work properly, they will be found at fault.

My guess is that the owner probably chewed through several consulting engineering firms until he found one to do the work cheap enough and who would tell him (the owner) what he wanted to hear, i.e. "no serious problems"

Of course, if the original design is deficient, all bets are off.

In reality, they will probably spread the blame around, even to guys who don't deserve to get blamed.

Pretty much. The word is the engineer that did the last inspection is finding it hard to get work in his field.
 
My guess is that the owner probably chewed through several consulting engineering firms until he found one to do the work cheap enough and who would tell him (the owner) what he wanted to hear, i.e. "no serious problems"

My impression is that the owner's spent a great deal of time on finding the minimum cost solution, and only implementing the minimum cost solution. Eventually, someone will give you the answer you want to hear (if only by reducing the scope of work.)

Another big issue for structural steel inspections is that there is often no way to do them properly. The steel can rust and crack in difficult to access place. This cannot be predicted by inspecting other stuff. Specifically, inspecting patches of accessible patches of steel is not a reliable predictor of failures elsewhere.

In bridges, it is particularly critical to be able to do a proper structural inspection. As a result, some of the new bridge designs are no longer as encased in concrete as the older bridge designs. Engineers need to be able to inspect the steel after many years in-service.

In the case of home inspections, it is routine for the home inspector to miss massive problems. If a house has serious hidden electrical and hidden structural defeciencies, I would be surprised if 1 in 10 home inspectors could find them. How many home inspectors have the equipment to measure beam deflections, foundation settling, moisture / heat loss / heat leakage, and IR scanners for electrical inspections?
 
Usually with bridges, there is a massive redundancy built into the design.

For example, the Gardiner Expressway is built like a brick shithouse. Sure, bits of concrete are falling, but that's a serviceability problem. Not a stuctural collapse in the making.

You could take a cutting torch to one of the steel beams on the Gardiner, cut it in half and the damn thing would just laugh at you. You could probably even get away with cutting 2 beams side by side in half and the Gardiner would not come down. (All bets are off on the third beam though.) The load simply bypasses the cut beam.

Not so with say the Leaside bridge which is a Deck Truss set up. There are only 2 trusses and you need both of them. Cut one and it's coming down.

If you want to see a horror show of a bridge in Toronto - a collapse just waiting to happen - go and check out the Dowling Avenue bridge over the GO Transit tracks by the CNE, or Dufferin Street over the GO Transit tracks just north of the Dufferin Gate. They make the Gardiner look like a prize winner. Not a question of if, but a question of when one or the other will catastrophically fail.

It will be interesting to read the report that comes out of this hearing as to exactly what caused the Elliot Lake mall to come down.

My guess is salt water from the cars corroded the connections of the steel.
 
The engineers who did the most thorough inspection gave the owner two options: fix it right, and el-cheapo (which they got grilled for making an "option".) As the mall was considered a vital element of attracting retirees to the City, it looks like the City itself never put much pressure on the owners to fix it - even though the place was full of drip buckets visible to anyone. Not one building standards inspection in 30 years. It seems the only one from the City who had the balls to complain and point out the danger, was a city librarian once the library moved into the mall. She was ignored.


At one point the original owner decided to dump the property "as is" and through a non-disclosure agreement somehow finagled the City into buying it through an arms-length retirement living corporation without knowing or caring to know about the inspections. Shame on them.

The building was designed one way, and then the owner insisted on some modifications which involved the roof-top parking, the cause of salt eating away at the beams all these years. Somehow the architect shrugged his shoulders and said 'sure go ahead, but I'm not responsible' yet the place got built. More shame.
 
My guess is salt water from the cars corroded the connections of the steel.



"According to the report, the collapse occurred when a weld between a support column and beam failed in two stages because of corrosion caused by years of water and road-salt penetration.
The collapse may have been unprecedented in the developed world.
"One is hard-pressed to find a similar example where a carbon-steel framed building in North America or Europe continued to corrode to the point of failure, when no extreme loading is present," the report states.
As the judicial inquiry into the collapse has already heard, leaking occurred because an "intrinsically flawed" waterproofing system installed in 1980 failed from the start, prompting years of complaints."


Read more: http://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/elliot...eadly-collapse-report-1.1202224#ixzz2PifYm7Bl

image.jpg
 
This inquiry is an exercise in civics. It's merely a way to determine who will pay what percentage and to also make recommendations.
True, and also there is a second part to the inquiry which will look at the so-called rescue attempt.
 
True, and also there is a second part to the inquiry which will look at the so-called rescue attempt.



You're right night ride, but once again it will not be to lay blame for any failures. Purely to make recommendations and to say they did their due diligence in addressing the issue.
 


"According to the report, the collapse occurred when a weld between a support column and beam failed in two stages because of corrosion caused by years of water and road-salt penetration.
The collapse may have been unprecedented in the developed world.
"One is hard-pressed to find a similar example where a carbon-steel framed building in North America or Europe continued to corrode to the point of failure, when no extreme loading is present," the report states.
As the judicial inquiry into the collapse has already heard, leaking occurred because an "intrinsically flawed" waterproofing system installed in 1980 failed from the start, prompting years of complaints."


Read more: http://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/elliot...eadly-collapse-report-1.1202224#ixzz2PifYm7Bl

image.jpg

wow

That is quite the photo