Election in Spain

Re: Re: Re: No

onthebottom said:
Some great? suggestions for the US:

hold terrorists responsible through international police work

Pull out of US military bases, beginning with Saudi Arabia; such bases don’t protect us from enemies, they create enemies. (I guess someone read that, I think Germany and North Korea should be next)

Turn over Middle East peace process to neutral parties (such as a commission of recent Nobel Peace prize winners). (that's really funny)

End the economic sanctions against Iraq. (now you can see why we had the war, no more sanctions though)

cancel the third world debt ( that should go over well)

Stop the war on drugs abroad

OTB
Funnier yet, I also agree with most of these suggestions.
You know what's even funnier? Something I don't agree with. Having a superpower force everyone to conform to western imperialistic ways by holding a gun to their heads. No I take it back, that's not funny at all.
 
Re: Re: Re: No

onthebottom said:
Didn't realize that we had used WMD against Canada in 1953 - anyone up there elaborate?

OTB
The city of Winnipeg was saturated with toxic zinc cadmium sulfide by US spray planes. The US government lied to the mayor of Winnipeg by telling him that the test was non-toxic and defense necessary. The actual purpose of the CIA test was to find the safe watered down level of the weapon before it starts to induce cancer. The US measured the effectiveness of the test by counting the number of people going to medical clinics with sore throats and bronchial problems.
 
Re: Re: Re: No

onthebottom said:
This, from your artical, makes my point:

"But by asking why, and by trying to truly understand, we must remember that acts of terrorism like the ones we’ve just experienced can never be justified. I repeat: nothing we’ve ever done, none of our policies, no matter how questionable, can ever justify terrorism."

Enough said.

OTB
Yes I also agree that terrorism must stop. But doesn't it seem odd that the whole article is devoted to how US foreign policy causes grievances which in turn causes terrorism? Nick it in the butt. Stop the imperialist fundamentialist vs Islamic fundamentalist cycle and the grievances and terrorism will go away.
 
Re: No

onthebottom said:
I don't think you can blame US foreign policy for their experiences. Unless of course you are an appeasement monkey, looking to bow to international terrorists so you're not a target. There's a word for that, I'm trying to think what it is......

OTB

Where, exactly, does blacking out 28 pages of text that points to a specific country as supporting and funding terrorism because America wants cheap oil fall in your definition of "appeasement"? Where, exactly, does giving a country that sells nuclear secrets to the highest bidder a free pass fall in your definition of "appeasement"? Where, exactly, does allowing a terrorist back into our economic good graces for giving up his nuclear weapons program fall in your definition of "appeasement"? Where, exactly, does giving North Korea a pass on it's human rights abuses because it might have nuclear weapons fall in your definition of "appeasement"? Appeasement my ass.
 
Re: Re: Re: No

onthebottom said:
This, from your artical, makes my point:

"But by asking why, and by trying to truly understand, we must remember that acts of terrorism like the ones we’ve just experienced can never be justified. I repeat: nothing we’ve ever done, none of our policies, no matter how questionable, can ever justify terrorism."

Enough said.

OTB

Yet another case of conservatives twisting a liberal position into something it's not, just so they can say liberals are wrong. Nobody is saying terrorism is justified. Except, of course, that ghost liberal that you and ocean keep paraphrasing.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: No

Ickabod said:
Yet another case of conservatives twisting a liberal position into something it's not, just so they can say liberals are wrong. Nobody is saying terrorism is justified. Except, of course, that ghost liberal that you and ocean keep paraphrasing.




Now that we agree that terrorism is wrong. Can we agree that if someone broke into your home and killed your family; you might see fit to terminate them with extreme predjudice?
 
Re: And back to the point

onthebottom said:
The Spanish are still retreating appeasement monkeys.

OTB

So riddle me this, Batman. If Spain isn't supposed to allow their vote to be dictated by a fear of terrorism, then why should the fear of terrorism dictate that Americans should vote for Bush?

Or maybe you're just an appeaser.
 
Re: Re: And back to the point

Ickabod said:
So riddle me this, Batman. If Spain isn't supposed to allow their vote to be dictated by a fear of terrorism, then why should the fear of terrorism dictate that Americans should vote for Bush?

Or maybe you're just an appeaser.

It is the fear of paying tribute to terrorists that people should vote for Bush, for.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: No

papasmerf said:
Now that we agree that terrorism is wrong. Can we agree that if someone broke into your home and killed your family; you might see fit to terminate them with extreme predjudice?

Sure. And can we then agree that if you were dumb enough to leave the door open at night while you knew that a mass murderer was floating around the neighborhood, that some blame would fall on your shoulders for allowing the murder of your family to happen?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: No

Ickabod said:
Sure. And can we then agree that if you were dumb enough to leave the door open at night while you knew that a mass murderer was floating around the neighborhood, that some blame would fall on your shoulders for allowing the murder of your family to happen?

And here was my Question: Originally posted by papasmerf
Now that we agree that terrorism is wrong. Can we agree that if someone broke into your home and killed your family; you might see fit to terminate them with extreme predjudice?

Now where did I say I left the door open???

But in any event you agree you are likely to terminate with extreme predjudice. Well now multiply that by 9-11.
 
papasmerf,

While I can't really argue your example that you have the right to terminate somebody that broke into your house and killed your family, I can argue that you don't have the right to use that as an excuse to terminate somebody that isn't responsible for that (i.e. Iraq) . Also, what your analogy fails to consider is the extensive collateral damage of human life that will inevitably result in exercising that right and the cycle of violence that will perpetuate itself over and over again b/c of the revenge factor. You have to ask yourself when does the bloodshed end and with whom? I guess it doesn't matter as long as you think you have the right to strike back, huh? Very short-sighted in perspective.
 
The_Jaded_One said:
papasmerf,

While I can't really argue your example that you have the right to terminate somebody that broke into your house and killed your family, I can argue that you don't have the right to use that as an excuse to terminate somebody that isn't responsible for that (i.e. Iraq) . Also, what your analogy fails to consider is the extensive collateral damage of human life that will inevitably result in exercising that right and the cycle of violence that will perpetuate itself over and over again b/c of the revenge factor. You have to ask yourself when does the bloodshed end and with whom? I guess it doesn't matter as long as you think you have the right to strike back, huh? Very short-sighted in perspective.

Now for one second did I say that was the reason for Iraq??????
 
papasmerf said:
Now for one second did I say that was the reason for Iraq??????

I thought this thread had to do with Spains involvement and support of America in Iraq and Al-Qaida's attack in Madrid because of it??!!
 
papasmerf

papasmerf said:
Can we agree that if someone broke into your home and killed your family; you might see fit to terminate them with extreme prejudice?
I not only might; I most certainly would, but only as an emotional and irrational reaction. I'm fairly sure and would hope that I, like any thinking man, would gain perspective and foresee that vengeance changes nothing which has been done and only perpetuates the cycle of misery. I don't think "an eye for an eye" really fills that desire for revenge. It's only a band aid that covers up the real fear of helplessness, intrusion and loss imposed upon us.

You may see this as bleeding heart empathetic sentimentality. In fact, I see it as a far more rational line of thinking and stepping outside of emotions.

You may argue that it in the case of terrorism, that retribution will render them less capable or likely to strike again, but I see it as fuelling the breeding ground for terrorism and hatred for many generations to come.
 
pool said:
papasmerf

I not only might; I most certainly would, but only as an emotional and irrational reaction. I'm fairly sure and would hope that I, like any thinking man, would gain perspective and foresee that vengeance changes nothing which has been done and only perpetuates the cycle of misery. I don't think "an eye for an eye" really fills that desire for revenge. It's only a band aid that covers up the real fear of helplessness, intrusion and loss imposed upon us.

You may see this as bleeding heart empathetic sentimentality. In fact, I see it as a far more rational line of thinking and stepping outside of emotions.

So you would rely on the courts for justice??? You would consider a plea bargin just????
 
I think we've done that

pool said:
papasmerf

I not only might; I most certainly would, but only as an emotional and irrational reaction. I'm fairly sure and would hope that I, like any thinking man, would gain perspective and foresee that vengeance changes nothing which has been done and only perpetuates the cycle of misery. I don't think "an eye for an eye" really fills that desire for revenge. It's only a band aid that covers up the real fear of helplessness, intrusion and loss imposed upon us.

You may see this as bleeding heart empathetic sentimentality. In fact, I see it as a far more rational line of thinking and stepping outside of emotions.

You have not seen the guys in Cuba lined up and shot have you? Now to continue your metaphor, if you are looking for the guy who killed your family, corner him and he shoots at you what do you do. I'd suggest a daisy cutter, but that's me.

OTB
 
And I thought

n_v said:
I thought this thread had to do with Spains involvement and support of America in Iraq and Al-Qaida's attack in Madrid because of it??!!

It had to do with Spain surrendering to terrorism because it was attacked.

Do you blame the terrorists or the Americans for the bombing, if you blame the Americans you should seek help.

OTB
 
Re: I think we've done that

onthebottom said:
You have not seen the guys in Cuba lined up and shot have you? Now to continue your metaphor, if you are looking for the guy who killed your family, corner him and he shoots at you what do you do. I'd suggest a daisy cutter, but that's me.

OTB

I would much prefer to die trying them to allow it to happen to anothers family
 
Re: Re: No

Ickabod said:
Where, exactly, does blacking out 28 pages of text that points to a specific country as supporting and funding terrorism because America wants cheap oil fall in your definition of "appeasement"?

Oil is actually very expensive these days?

Ickabod said:

Where, exactly, does giving a country that sells nuclear secrets to the highest bidder a free pass fall in your definition of "appeasement"?

You over simplyfy but hey, you're a liberal. The question here is did a government do it or a group of individuals. If the government did it then we should punish them, if it was a group of individuals then that's a different story. Neither you or I know the answer to that question.


Ickabod said:
Where, exactly, does allowing a terrorist back into our economic good graces for giving up his nuclear weapons program fall in your definition of "appeasement"?"?

That's not appeasement, that's a reward for good behavior, the carrot of the carrot-stick combination. How would it be appeasing a country to reward them for doing what we want?


Ickabod said:
Where, exactly, does giving North Korea a pass on it's human rights abuses because it might have nuclear weapons fall in your definition of "appeasement"? Appeasement my ass.

I think the US has not pushed for sanctions on North Korea becasue the Chinease would veto them and becase we, as a group, are trying to change North Korea behavior by engagement. We still ship them food, regardless of their governments behavior. If you think we are affraid to sanctioin North Korea becase of their nukes you would be mistaken.

And yes, you have an appeasing ass.

OTB