Election in Spain

Re: Re: Credible News Source

Ickabod said:
You give what is nothing more than an opinion of one writer.

OK, here's another one:

"Saddam was a grave threat
By Robert J. Lieber
We now hear the argument that since weapons of mass destruction (WMD) have not — so far — been found in Iraq, there has been a massive intelligence failure, and we never should have gone to war. But failure to find stockpiles does not mean the ultimate peril did not exist. Far more important were Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein's history, capability and intent, and the serious and long-term threat he posed to a vital region, to America's allies and to our national security."

........

http://www.usatoday.com/news/opinion/editorials/2004-03-17-oppose_x.htm




OTB
 
Stop making stuff up!!

ocean976124 said:
Even Hans Blix has said he does not believe Bush was lying about WMD, he was mistaken but not lying.

Republicans just pull stuff out of their asses w/o having a shred of proof it seems. First it was OTB now it is you. Do you have any references to back up what you just claimed above?? That's what I thought. Anyways, that is NOT what Hans Blix said.

Check out this report : http://www.indybay.org/news/2004/03/1672821.php

Highlights:


What Mr Blix still cannot understand is why his doubts and those of his professional teams of trained inspectors failed to make an impression on Mr Blair and President George Bush, who continued to mislead the public with categorical assertions about the existence of WMD with the fervency of religious crusaders. He accuses the British and US governments of "distorting" the reports of the weapons inspectors, who had said that amounts of chemical and biological weapons remained unaccounted for. This became an accusation that Iraq "retained" chemical and biological weapons.

and...

Worse, he says, the Bush administration actively sought to undermine the inspectors, accusing them of playing down the threat from Saddam's WMD, particularly after Mr Blix refused to brand the discovery of an Iraqi drone as a "smoking gun".

and the DAMNING statements against DICK CHENEY

His account is particularly damaging for Dick Cheney, the Vice-President who continued to insist that Iraq had "nuclear weapons" long after the evidence proved the contrary


Originally posted by ocean976124
Bush did exaggerate the evidence greatly but anyone who was paying attention all along knew that. Thats what politicians do. The left does it as well as the right.

No!! Bush flat out lied. I already provided proof in this very thread which shows beyond a shadow of doubt that Bush fabricated a story about an IAEA "WMD" report. Making stuff up is lying NOT exaggerating. I know that you are a very partisan Republican incapable of logic or objectiveness but try to get a grip on reality please. Saying Bush didn't lie is like denying that the sky is blue.
 
Re: Stop making stuff up!!

seven said:
Republicans just pull stuff out of their asses w/o having a shred of proof it seems. First it was OTB now it is you. Do you have any references to back up what you just claimed above?? That's what I thought. Anyways, that is NOT what Hans Blix said.


I can back up that statement, on NPR YEASTERDAY Hans Blix said that they were wrong, had bad intelligence but were not lieing. If you want to listen to the interview:

http://freshair.npr.org/day_fa.jhtml?display=day&todayDate=03/17/2004

Again, try some reliable and balanced news sources. Even though NPR (like the NY Times) is a propaganda machine for the left they have quality reporting of the left side of an argument.

OTB
 
Re: Stop making stuff up!!

seven said:
Republicans just pull stuff out of their asses w/o having a shred of proof it seems. First it was OTB now it is you. Do you have any references to back up what you just claimed above?? That's what I thought. Anyways, that is NOT what Hans Blix said.

Check out this report : http://www.indybay.org/news/2004/03/1672821.php

Highlights:


What Mr Blix still cannot understand is why his doubts and those of his professional teams of trained inspectors failed to make an impression on Mr Blair and President George Bush, who continued to mislead the public with categorical assertions about the existence of WMD with the fervency of religious crusaders. He accuses the British and US governments of "distorting" the reports of the weapons inspectors, who had said that amounts of chemical and biological weapons remained unaccounted for. This became an accusation that Iraq "retained" chemical and biological weapons.

and...

Worse, he says, the Bush administration actively sought to undermine the inspectors, accusing them of playing down the threat from Saddam's WMD, particularly after Mr Blix refused to brand the discovery of an Iraqi drone as a "smoking gun".

and the DAMNING statements against DICK CHENEY

His account is particularly damaging for Dick Cheney, the Vice-President who continued to insist that Iraq had "nuclear weapons" long after the evidence proved the contrary




No!! Bush flat out lied. I already provided proof in this very thread which shows beyond a shadow of doubt that Bush fabricated a story about an IAEA "WMD" report. Making stuff up is lying NOT exaggerating. I know that you are a very partisan Republican incapable of logic or objectiveness but try to get a grip on reality please. Saying Bush didn't lie is like denying that the sky is blue.

The sky is brown in LA LOL

or:

"Hussein has ... chosen to spend his money on building weapons of mass destruction and palaces for his cronies."
- Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999

"There is no doubt that ... Saddam Hussein has invigorated his
weapons programs. Reports indicate that biological, chemical and
nuclear programs continue apace and may be back to pre-Gulf War status. In addition, Saddam continues to redefine delivery systems and is doubtless using the cover of an ilicit missile program to develop longer-range missiles that will threaten the United States and our allies."
- Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL,) and
others, December 5, 2001

"We know that he has stored secret supplies of biological and
chemical weapons throughout his country."
- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

"The last UN weapons inspectors left Iraq in October of 1998. We
are confident that Saddam Hussein retains some stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, and that he has since embarked on a crash course to build up his chemical and biological warfare capabilities. Intelligence reports indicate that he is seeking nuclear weapons..."
- Sen. Robert Byrd (D, WV), Oct. 3, 2002

But my favorite is:
"I will be voting to give the President of the United States the
authority to use force-- if necessary-- to disarm Saddam Hussein because I believe that a deadly arsenal of weapons of mass destruction in his hands is a real and grave threat to our security."
- Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002

The lying bastard!

Were they all lying or are you too partisan to think it through?

OTB
 
Re: Re: Stop making stuff up!!

onthebottom said:


- Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999

- Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL,) and
others, December 5, 2001

- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

- Sen. Robert Byrd (D, WV), Oct. 3, 2002

- Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002


It seems that you continually miss the point. First off, it was asserted by ocean976124 that even Hans Blix said the president was just given misinformation and wasn't lying. I provided proof to the contrary re:Hans Blix. The quotes that you have provided aren't from Hans Blix, they aren't even from scientists/weapons inspectors, and they are outdated (as far back as 1999?? come on!!). I thought you were the one talking about having reliable sources of information.

PS - Do you have a transcript of the Hans Blix interview? I can't seem to dl the audio right now, and I quoted an interview from him (regarding the same book) that states that Bush "distorted" and "mislead" (i.e lied to) the American public. Do you honestly think Blix was misquoted by Anne Penketh of the Independent?
 
ocean976124 said:
Even Hans Blix has said he does not believe Bush was lying about WMD, he was mistaken but not lying.
Here's something Blix also said last Monday, promoting his new book, to NY University students, "They wanted to come to the conclusion that there were weapons(referring to the Bush administration). Like the former days of the witch hunt, they are convinced that they exist, and if you see a black cat, well, that's evidence of the witch."
He also said, "The world isn't safer now that Saddam Hussein is out of power".
 
One has to wonder if Blix is so effective why he was prevented from implimenting inspections for so many years.

BTW he was never a canidate in Spains election.
 
Core issues

papasmerf said:
One has to wonder if Blix is so effective why he was prevented from implimenting inspections for so many years.

BTW he was never a canidate in Spains election.

We can argue all day over various details. What has been done has been done. More interesting is what comes next and to that end, motivation must be understood.

Ocean, OTB, Papasmerf;

What was the reason for the war in Iraq? Knowing what we know now and if we could go back in time, should the US invade Iraq anyway and why?
 
Re: Re: Stop making stuff up!!

onthebottom said:
I can back up that statement, on NPR YEASTERDAY Hans Blix said that they were wrong, had bad intelligence but were not lieing. If you want to listen to the interview:

http://freshair.npr.org/day_fa.jhtml?display=day&todayDate=03/17/2004

Again, try some reliable and balanced news sources. Even though NPR (like the NY Times) is a propaganda machine for the left they have quality reporting of the left side of an argument.

OTB
In the radio interview, Blix did say, and I'm paraphrasing, "The US did not say that the uncertainty about WMD is unbearable and so we must go to war. No, they said that there is WMD and that was just not the case".
There was uncertainty of WMD. And uncertainty was not what the US was preaching to the world. Sounds like deception to me.

But lets look at another US lie/deception/whatever you want to call it. Before the war, C Powell gave evidence to the UN of an Iraq/al Qaida connection involving Abu al-Zarqawi(the 53rd wild card in the deck of Iraqi villains) and his al Qaida terrorist camp in Iraq. Powell had said, "Iraq today harbors a deadly terrorist network headed by ... Zarqawi, an associate and collaborator of Osama bin Laden." The evidence and the danger looked convincing. Powell however, left out one detail. The camp was outside of Saddam's control, near Kirma in the northern Kurdish area of Iraq. In fact the area was in the US enforced no-fly zone, a zone that the US had already bombed on a near daily bases leading up to the war.
So with a preemptive policy on terrorism, why didn't the US take out this camp and al-Zarqawi as well? It was out of Saddam's control. NBC news had a good answer for this, "...but the (Bush)administration feared destroying the terrorist camp in Iraq could undercut its case for war against Saddam." Sounds again like US deception to me.
www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4431601
www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2004/03/15/007.html
 
Re: A missile up the ass!!!

EnergizerBunny said:
You're a fucking bleeding heart liberal Jaded one. The only language that these fuckers understand is a missile up the ass! And they better give us their fucking oil and at prices we agree to and in US$. Who do they think that they are? We don't give a fuck about their culture, their religion, their standard of living, etc.

Spoken like a true American JACK ASS.
 
Re: Core issues

tompeepin said:
We can argue all day over various details. What has been done has been done. More interesting is what comes next and to that end, motivation must be understood.

Ocean, OTB, Papasmerf;

What was the reason for the war in Iraq? Knowing what we know now and if we could go back in time, should the US invade Iraq anyway and why?

Knowing what we know now
we may have done well to prevent his comming to power all together. I suspect that 20/20 hindsight is often clearer then our powers of seeing the future.
 
Re: Re: Core issues

papasmerf said:
Knowing what we know now
we may have done well to prevent his comming to power all together. I suspect that 20/20 hindsight is often clearer then our powers of seeing the future.

Again:

1- What was the reason for the war in Iraq?

2- Knowing what we know now should the US have invaded Iraq anyway and why?
 
Re: Re: A missile up the ass!!!

incognito said:
Spoken like a true American JACK ASS.

ROTFLMAO! I think that it was a lame attempt at satire. :D
 
Re: Re: Re: Core issues

tompeepin said:
Again:

1- What was the reason for the war in Iraq?

2- Knowing what we know now should the US have invaded Iraq anyway and why?

A fair question.

The reason sold to the British and American people was that Saddam was a risk because of WMD. That was wrong, because he didn't have WMD. He was a risk (arguable) but not because he had WMD.

Had Saddam opened up and allowed the UN to verify he didn't have WMD the UN would have had to end the sanctions.

An alternative to an invasion would have been extending sanctions beyond the point where Saddam gave up his WMD. I don't think would have been politically possible but the US could have tried to win this in the UNSC.

Another option would have been to impose a very strickt set of ongoing inspections and lift sanctions. Saddam would not have allowed (saving face) such an invasive regime (see Iran for current example) but again the US could have tried.

I think if the US administration would have know that Saddam didn't have WMD they would have tried one of the above and then, when they failed, would have invaded to keep from letting Saddam out of his box. This may have allowed a broader alliance, or it could have resulted in more UNSC infighting that could have made things worse than they are now.

Sadly, we can't go back in time, so one question is, would you rather the US have not invaded Iraq? If yes, and there will be many Yeses on this board, what would you have suggested in the REAL world.

OTB
 
Re: Re: Re: Stop making stuff up!!

*d* said:
The camp was outside of Saddam's control, near Kirma in the northern Kurdish area of Iraq. In fact the area was in the US enforced no-fly zone, a zone that the US had already bombed on a near daily bases leading up to the war.

Wolfowitz actually takes the cake on this one. On the same Meet The Press interview in the days leading up to the war, he touched on your points to make 2 points of his own for the war that totally contradicted each other. First, to indicate that war was necessary, he mentioned this camp in Northern Iraq. Then, to indicate war would lead to good things, he stated that there was proof that democracy could flourish in Iraq based on the Kurdish controlled north having their own form of democracy since they were given control of the north. All within 10 minutes.
 
Re: Re: Re: Credible News Source

onthebottom said:
OK, here's another one:

"Saddam was a grave threat
By Robert J. Lieber
OTB

I hope you didn't spend too much time tracking that down. My point wasn't that only 1 person believed it, although it may have come across that way. My point was that the article is written in such a way so as to present the writer's personal interpretation of the facts. And you're trying to present the interpretation as indisputable fact. I'm sure i could just as easily find articles using the same facts to indicate it meant Saddam was a paper tiger.
 
ocean976124 said:
Its only dumb if you think terrorism can be justified.

It's dumb if you think i'm saying terrorism is justified. In fact, you're dumb if you think i'm saying terrorism is justified. Rationale and justification are not the same thing. Learn that, will you please?

Well I certainly wouldn't "blame" you. But in your analogy me locking the door from now on will prevent, to a certain extent, future break-ins. Giving in to terrorists does not end terrorism, it spreads it...

My analogy wasn't perfect, and yeah, you exploited that. But you failed to address it's actual point. Add in that we know there's a mass murderer in the neighborhood, and my insistence on leaving the door open is only that much dumber. And i don't buy your "i wouldn't blame you" line. You'd have it in for me sure as shoot. And your last statement can just as much be considered your "justifying" terrorism as my supposed suggestion that killing innocent Iraqi's in war justifies terrorism. If, of course, you still hold to the ridiculous notion that "rationale" is the same as "justification".
 
ocean976124 said:
And you've fallen for what Saddam wanted you to fall for. He used human shields when he could so that any attempt on him would be seen as killing innocent people. OBL does the same thing. They make sure to hide with the innocent. But you don't seem to be questioning the morality of that decision.

I haven't fallen for anything. I'm saying that bombing Iraq and killing innocent Iraqis, even if it is as 100% justifiable as you say it is, does 2 things. Gets rid of Saddam, and throws gasoline on the fire of terrorism. Throwing gasoline on the fire of terrorism is an unfortunate consequence of the positives of getting rid of Saddam. That assumes the whole thing is as justified as you say it is. If it's not even close to being as justified as you say it is, which is my position, then it throws gasoline on the fire of terrorism with no beneficial consequence. But either way, it throws gasoline on the fire of terrorism.