Eglinton Stabbing

Actually Bazokajoe. I kind of suspected/knew that early on. I just didn’t want to come out “guns blazing”….

there are ways we can vet SPs before pulling the trigger…and ways we can test them too. Just have to know how to read people, and at times “give them rope”…

It’s all good.

Highly suspect you didn't know.
 
Um no.
legally we are allowed to use as much force as is necessary to remove the threat. Killing someone slapping you is hardly self defence.

You can shoot someone that breaks into your house. The implied threat of coming into your home…….warrants more force. But if dead body is at the bottom of the stairs and you are upstairs. Hope you have $1,000,000 to fight the charges. And no how the crime scene looks. In almost all cases you have the book thrown at you…years later charges dropped or acquitted. But your still broke.

As much force as is necessary to remove the the threat.

Right/wrong I have no bone. But that is how police read it, and crowns prosecute it.

This has nothing to do with someone breaking into your home. This was an argument that escalated first to fists being thrown and then a stabbing followed by chasing the original aggressor with a prohibited weapon and stabbing some more. He went over and above in force used and is looking at jail time. Just my opinion.
 
This has nothing to do with someone breaking into your home. This was an argument that escalated first to fists being thrown and then a stabbing followed by chasing the original aggressor with a prohibited weapon and stabbing some more. He went over and above in force used and is looking at jail time. Just my opinion.

I don’t disagree.
but as always topics have trunks and branches. And various people started talking about what is, what isn’t “self defense”…I think it started before page 2 if I recall :)
 
I don’t disagree.
but as always topics have trunks and branches. And various people started talking about what is, what isn’t “self defense”…I think it started before page 2 if I recall :)

I do believe it is the same thing in your home. If you have an unregistered gun or a registered gun not stored properly and use it in a self defense situation during a home invasion/burglary you would still face charges. Sure a jury may give some leniency because of the gut felt hatred towards home invaders, I know I would if I were on a jury but the cops would still charge.
 
I do believe it is the same thing in your home. If you have an unregistered gun or a registered gun not stored properly and use it in a self defense situation during a home invasion/burglary you would still face charges. Sure a jury may give some leniency because of the gut felt hatred towards home invaders, I know I would if I were on a jury but the cops would still charge.

unsafe safe storage, unlawful discharge are just the beginning and pretty much a given. This is but one travesty of Justice in Canada and really illustrates the “anti gun” culture in Canada, by police and more. I forget all details now, remember efforts to try and raise money for him. Etc and so on…


“self defence”
Something Canadians have always been able to do. Whether in the home with a gun or baseball bat. On the streets or TTC…Just for some reason ( see above) many think we can’t.
 
unsafe safe storage, unlawful discharge are just the beginning and pretty much a given. This is but one travesty of Justice in Canada and really illustrates the “anti gun” culture in Canada, by police and more. I forget all details now, remember efforts to try and raise money for him. Etc and so on…


“self defence”
Something Canadians have always been able to do. Whether in the home with a gun or baseball bat. On the streets or TTC…Just for some reason ( see above) many think we can’t.


Happy ending to that story, although it took one year...

 
People won't like this answer but...... in the scenario you mention, yes I pull the trigger. You trespass on my property be prepared to pay the consequences.
I hate when people start making excuses. Oh he was high on drugs, he has a mental illness. I don't give a fuck. You are responsible for you.

So you won't be making excuses for shooting them and will go to jail happily, then?
 
I understand what you are saying. I am of a similar opinion. But you don't want to be overtly jumpy either. Verify the guy is an actual threat and then if you shoot it would be justified. Or atleast it should be. But if you just wake up and start spraying bullets, that would be irresponsible, to put it lightly. And if you would do that, then you probably don't want to own a gun either.

Note: Even in cases where it is justified to shoot, may be a warning shot should be tried unless of course the intruder is actively going after someone in your home.

But that's a very different scenario from the one Bazookajoe appeared to be describing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kautilya
unsafe safe storage, unlawful discharge are just the beginning and pretty much a given. This is but one travesty of Justice in Canada and really illustrates the “anti gun” culture in Canada, by police and more. I forget all details now, remember efforts to try and raise money for him. Etc and so on…


“self defence”
Something Canadians have always been able to do. Whether in the home with a gun or baseball bat. On the streets or TTC…Just for some reason ( see above) many think we can’t.

Good gun laws are what the USA lacks!!! I wouldn't complain if they completely eliminated all firearms within all city limits and brought in heavier jail time for anyone caught carrying a firearm.
 
Last edited:
  • Sad
Reactions: bazokajoe
Good gun laws are what the USA lacks!!! I wouldn't complain if they completely eliminated all firearms within all city limits and brought in heavier jail time for anyone caught carrying a firearm.

I took some fire in the “other” thread for saying “the US is ill/ sick”

It is. To me that’s very obvious. Even if they get their heads out of the sand long enough to bring in some basic controls ( capacity/storage) but first they would need to make it Federally regulated as we are. Presently they are a hodgepodge across states.

wont even begin to address the underlying disease (s) to which the insane gun violence is but a symptom.

Spent a week hunting with two guys ( grown, mature, family men). Great guys, salt of the earth types. They were from Maine (shall issue state) Of coarse discussions about our different approaches to GC came up. Both of them talked about the fear of car jacking. Neither of them….allowed….their wives to go out without packing…

that’s not freedom. It’s a prison, just of a different kind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RZG
I took some fire in the “other” thread for saying “the US is ill/ sick”

It is. To me that’s very obvious. Even if they get their heads out of the sand long enough to bring in some basic controls ( capacity/storage) but first they would need to make it Federally regulated as we are. Presently they are a hodgepodge across states.

wont even begin to address the underlying disease (s) to which the insane gun violence is but a symptom.

Spent a week hunting with two guys ( grown, mature, family men). Great guys, salt of the earth types. They were from Maine (shall issue state) Of coarse discussions about our different approaches to GC came up. Both of them talked about the fear of car jacking. Neither of them….allowed….their wives to go out without packing…

that’s not freedom. It’s a prison, just of a different kind.
I wouldn't have thought that Maine was a state which had a high urban crime rate. It's rural. I can see it being a high domestic violence and suicide rate state. But car-jacking is an urban crime.

Can you relate why your friends were so concerned?

Criminal law in Canada is federal jurisdiction and therefore carrying without proper authorization is a federal offence here. In the US, most criminal law is enacted at the state level.
 
:(
any bets right now if the shooters are
A bangers
B out on bail
C repeat offenders
D all of the above

but we’ve only been screaming to go after the actual problem for 20+ years.
Highly likely to be gang-affiliated because who else carries and uses on the streets in Toronto.

"Out on bail"?..... Not necessarily, but they could be. Ditto repeat offenders. They could be rookies trying to show their mettle to move up in the gang structure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer