Ebay feedback question (from buyer)

Gentle Ben

Senior Member
Jan 5, 2002
7,213
0
36
I dabble on ebay, know my way around not to badly. recently bought an item for about $5, not a huge purchase. Item came in damaged in shipping, it was very poorly packed from Hong Kong. Notified the seller of the damage and they responded with "Please send us pictures so we can confirm the shipping" I messaged back saying that my camera is not working, and not to worry about it .
I provided neutral feedback stating that item was poorly pakaged, damage was inevitabel , they wanted photos of the damage to compensate me.

I have over 50 positives as a buyer over the last 8 or 9 years with no neutral or negative.
Next day seller messages me that it's not that they don't believe me, but they need this photo for their records and shipping dept. if I could please provide the photo they will refund me fully, and then I can revise my feedback.also claim that they don't get much in the way of damages, but it can and does happen since they ship hundreds of items per day.
first off, how do I revise the feedback,and secondly, I left honest feedback ( I think) ,and I no longer have the item to take a picture.
How would you proceed?
 
I would leave the feedback neutral. I'm also an ebayer and have items shipped from Hong Kong. At the end of the end of the day, it should have been packed properly.
 
just mention in your feedback (assuming you can change it) that you were unable to provide photos, but that the seller was willing to refund you if you did. That way at least other potential buyers know they have some sort of recourse.
 
In this case I believe the seller. For a $5 dollar item, the feedback must be worth more to the seller than that particular transaction, although the bit about the picture for such a small amount is questionable but then some places have a fanatical attachment to standard procedures....
 
You cannot actually change your feedback rating or your feedback comment once they have been left but you can add a "follow-up" comment to your original comment. Also, you can respond to a comment made by the other party. Check out the "Feedback Tools" section at the right-hand side of the following page:

http://pages.ebay.com/services/forum/feedback.html.

Although buyers can leave positive, neutral or negative feedback for sellers the converse is not true, although it used to be. These days sellers can only leave positive feedback for buyers (the only other choice is to not leave any feedback at all). This policy seems stupid to me but that's the way it is these days. Some sellers get round this restriction in the case of an unsatisfactory transaction by leaving a positive rating for the buyer but inserting the words "NEGATIVE TRANSACTION" somewhere in the comment!

By the way, it's standard procedure in the case of a damaged or broken item for the seller to request photographic proof that the item was indeed damaged or broken. How else can the seller know for sure that it was actually damaged or broken? Whether it's a $5,000 item or a $5 item the onus lies with the buyer to prove that damage or breakage actually took place. Long gone, regrettably, are the days when a Gentleman's word was his bond .......
 
I certainely understand the reason fro asking for photo, I was prepared to write off the transaction, and left what I felt was appropriate feedback, they get dozens of feedback per day and pretty much all are positive.very occasional negative, and a the odd neutral. I felt the neutral was accurate info based on the fact the item was very poorly packaged,and the sole reason why item was damaged. The seller chooses to poorly ship the item, and in a certain percentage of cases, the items get damaged. ( they even admit to occasional damage in shipping due to packaging)
My last message to them was, I see 3 choices, either is fine by me... replace the item, do nothing, refund the money. They aer choosing to refund the money if I agree to adjust the feedback.
The seller is oviously very concerened about their feedback.
Thansk for the info everyone
 
Understand also from the sellers point of view. If an item is shipped from HK and its damaged, they have to send proof to their supplier that it was damaged, or they cant get $$$ to refund you.