DVD-ntsc vd HD-DVD

xix

Time Zone Traveller
Jul 27, 2002
5,993
2,668
113
La la land
Maybe someone here might know the answer and not guess or speculate to what it may be.

The DVD of now that are being sold, I know they can be played on HD_DVD/Blue-ray systems. Also that it can be viewed on HDTV.
But if they are played on HD-players( for arguements sake) I am sure they are viewed like NSTC/old standard tv lines on HDTV. Most likely the lowest resolution or lines.

So is it worth buying a few series of some tv shows and be able to view them in the future with no problems?
Otherwise it won't be obselete.

Will the entertainment industry release some of the tv shows again but on HDTV/player format in the future? ( once the war is over of course)
( I am sure they probably will for popular $erie$)
 
you'll have the choice to watch the show at 480i or 480p using component or upscale to 720p or 1080i or 1080p but only passed through via HDMI connection.

Also considering a real decent upscaling DVD player is already about $250 and a decent standalone Audio CD Player costs (starting from) $400 - $800 range, getting an HD-DVD player right now is a no brainer (I needed both for my HT and it's cheaper for me to buy an HD-DVD player than two decent separate units)
 
How common is upscaling.... a friend has been recommending that as a feature to seek out since I am in the market for a 1080p wide screen HDTV.

Actually I am planning to have him order one through this online company that will mod the machines to be region free.
 
Given that the (modern) original shows were filmed for 525i (okay, 480i), they aren't likely to be released in a better quality format at any future time, at least not without high quality digial resampling. Already you see comments online that many older movies are being reissued well beyond their original quality, and warts of the original performance are becoming visible which were never originally visible (e.g. some actors who were drunk at the time of filming, but didn't appear so in the original release).

Let's suggest it this way: if you bought an LP, and enjoyed it, then saw the same LP offered at "CD quality" (44kHz samples) on a CD, would you buy it again? Then, if you saw the same LP offered again at a higher quality (say, 128kHz samples), would you buy it yet again?

The players tend to play each of the new formats, plus DVD and CD formats, even though the latter two use different lasers: the cost difference is relatively trivial for the manufacturers.

Blu-Ray and HD-DVD discs offer a higher capacity (around 25 Gig) than do DVDs (at around 4.7Gig), and than do CDs (at around 800Meg or less). It's not the storage format, nor the disc capacity which makes the big difference: it's the quality of what is put onto the disc. It the difference is worth it to you, buy it. If not, then wait.
 
frankcastle said:
How common is upscaling.... a friend has been recommending that as a feature to seek out since I am in the market for a 1080p wide screen HDTV.

Actually I am planning to have him order one through this online company that will mod the machines to be region free.

I've tried literally tens of these upscaling machine for the past 2 years. From the completely ineffective ones to the crazy $2,000 ones. The effectiveness of upscaling is display dependent and it is the most difficult to see the effect of upscaling on a CRT projector. Finally I tested the Toshiba HD-A1 HD-DVD player and it beats literally any upscaling DVD player I've ever tested by far.

So for that feature alone the HD-A1 is already worth the money. The CD playback capability (via digital output, player is only used as CD transport) is also astounding. Playing back identical CD (played in sync so all I need to do is switch the digital input) I can easily hear the sudden expansion of dimensionality and the 3D-like sonic space (dang, now I sound like an audio crackpot :p )

Between the two improvements, I will save quite a lot of money in the future because now standard DVD have become bearable to watch and CD more enjoyable to listen to. If only 5% of my CD and DVD collection no longer need to be re-purchased in higher-definition, that's already approx $3,000 in savings.

Okay, enough with my going-all-over-the-place.

PS: no HD-DVD or Blu-ray players are region hackable at this point. Also, region coding is only valid for standard DVD and Bluray. HD-DVD as a format does not have region coding whatsoever.
 
frankcastle said:
How common is upscaling.... a friend has been recommending that as a feature to seek out since I am in the market for a 1080p wide screen HDTV.
All fixed pixel HDTV’s like plasma and LCD upconvert a lower resolution image to match its native resolution. That’s why I thing the upconverting DVD players are a money making scam to talk advantage of the HDTV boom. If people only knew that their TV was doing the exact same thing. The difference in picture quality will depend on which one upconverts better, the TV or DVD player. Salesmen push these by saying they will upconvert a DVD to HD. DVD’s are 480i and you cannot squeeze any more resolution out of them. I would save my money and put it towards a HD or BD player instead.
 
Tyler1, I've seen upscaled DVD that looks literally as good as HD broadcast. Mind you, the the upscaler costs CAD$12,000 and will not be available to the public until February 2007.