Dumb Question on Economics

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
If the US is trillions of dollars in debt, and owes money, where is this money from the government (financial stimulus package) coming from? Is this money they are borrowing from some place, or are they just printing it?
 
What a dumb question! Just kidding. Yes, the U.S. government is simply printing the money. That is why many people think the U.S. dollar will be seriously devalued not far down the road. No country has ever printed its way to prosperity.
 
You cannot, of course, simply print more money to solve this problem. If the fed prints more money it simple devaluates all the money that was previously printed causing inflation. This means you need more money to buy tomorrow what you bought today for less money. They borrow money from lenders which can be citizens or other countries. As the debt mounts so does the interest which makes future lenders quite leary of your ability to pay. The hope is the economy will pick up, along with taxes, to pay for this.

Another problem is make work projects which Obama is kean on. While such projects do create work it does not create a sound economy as business is leary to expand as it knows this goverment ponzi scheme cannot go on for ever. This will cause the recession to continue. In the great depression one theroy as to why it lasted so long is the government kept spending on make work projects. This is the exact reason the Japan recession has lasted so long. The goverment there has kept building their infastructure, as Obama plans, to such an extent they have highways and bridges that lead to nowhere and have done nothing but prolong the problem.

This is my take on it and I should know as I have a high school diploma, so dont fu*k with me, ok?
 
Literally and exactly they borrowed it from all those people who invest in US govt. bonds and t-bills.

One of the largest investors is China, but there are loads of Americans (and others) who hold these bonds in their retirement portfolios, pension funds, and so on, as well.
 
And then they spend the money, paying people to work and get the economy rolling, in theory. Then, once people are financially stable, the US starts taxing at highet rates to increase government income with which to pay those loans (maturing TBills, etc). It's the government's ability to tax that makes these lenders willing to buy the bonds. The US is still the richest country on earth.
 
JohnFK said:
The government doesn't have to print more money so long as it can borrow it.

Sometimes, many time, the U.S. Treasury repays the borrowed money by printing it. (Borrow US$100 from China and then print US$100 to repay the debt. Neat, eh?) Some lenders are wise to this trick so they lend the U.S. government in currency denominated in Euros or some other non-U.S. currency like Yens. The U.S. can legally only print USD's and not Euros or Yens.
 
There you go, sometimes one, sometimes the other, certainly both at one time or another.

Are we all happy now?
 
It is amazing how the value od the US dollar has not diminished due to the mass circulation of additional money into the system.

I'm sure Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe is pissed and envious. Their new currenct just dropped 8 zeros from the old. apparently 1 billion Zimbabwan dollars barely bought you a loaf of bread. There's a perfect example of what happens to a currency's value when all you do is print money to get yourself out of trouble.

Monetary policies have to combined with some Fiscal policies to create real solutions to this frightening economic situation. I must say I'm quite worried but optimistically hopeful.
 
oldjones said:
Are we all happy now?

Sometimes yes, sometimes no. Don't you hate it when your friend repays your loan with "money" that he just printed off the computer in his basement? In this case, your friend is the U.S. treasury and yes they do print money.
 
Actually Zimbabwe most recently dropped twelve zeros from their recently introduced trillion dollar notes, having somewhat less recently also dropped zeros from million dollar notes without at all slowing the pace of inflation. Or of their printing presses apparently.

What makes printing $US a money-maker (pun intended) as compared to printing $Z, is that rich people and countries still want to buy them. Only the poor schmucks needing to buy bread in Harare want the Zimbabwean ones.

Why that should be, after a year that saw US dollars sinking against all other developed currencies, after conclusive demonstrations that the country cannot manage either its spending or control its financial institutions and that their managers are either blind, blunderers or crooks, is a complete mystery and one of the reasons that the Dismal Science is no more a science than Intelligent Design.

Ya just gotta believe.
 
oldjones said:
What makes printing $US a money-maker (pun intended) as compared to printing $Z, is that rich people and countries still want to buy them.

One day (and it might be soon), the EURO will probably replace the USD as the world's reserve currency. (I wish I could print money and repay my bank loan with it.)
 
With business conditions so lousy everywhere in the world, mostly the only place people want to put their money is government debt. Unfortunately most of that is in short term treasuries....ie: they can at any time decide not to renew their loans to the US government. The banks in the US that have all of a sudden gotten afraid of lending, are putting their funds in Long Bonds and other government-guaranteed debt instead. So, the upshot is that, Right Now, the governments can borrow alot of money quite easily....but I doubt that's going to last forever.

Some governments in Europe (Italy, Greece, and the UK) had a few recent 'failed auctions' of government paper; they literally had no takers so they had to withdraw the offer and presumably will try again later by offering higher interest rates. That's what might happen to the US if they lose favour with the markets. Nobody can tell the future, so no one can really say if foreigners will become skittish about adding to their US debt, but I'm betting that they will and in the not too distant future.

One last thing is that the Fed governor has publicly committed to supporting the long term bond markets....he'll buy bonds if there are no takers (printing money). That's one of the factors that's keeping the long term bond market so high. But liquidity has to go somewhere...it will be spend in some capacity, be it on assets or real things like commodities and land or just on general rise in the price level; there's no free lunch.
 
FOOTSNIFFER said:
mostly the only place people want to put their money is government debt. Unfortunately most of that is in short term treasuries....ie: they can at any time decide not to renew their loans to the US government.

That is because most people know the U.S. government will repay their debts, even if they have to print the money.
 
The Houdini said:
It is amazing how the value od the US dollar has not diminished due to the mass circulation of additional money into the system.

That's because this is not a "typical recession" and the processes that are unfolding are not typical recession processes. What is unfolding are the "D" processes: deleveraging, disinvestment, and deflation. You might also note the last time that we saw those processes unfold we called it a "depression".

All that debt has to be unwound, and as the debts are closed out that withdraws money from the system, reducing the multiplier effect of debt on the money supply--in short, unwinding that debt withdraws money from the system about as fast as the government has been pumping it in.

Presumably all that cash that has been pumped into the economy has indeed has a massive inflationary effect, but all it has done is counteract the deflation that otherwise would have taken hold by now.

Here is another "D" word: Decades. In Japan, in the US, whenever the economy has unwound debt like this elsewhere in the world or in the past in the US, it has taken decades for the process to run its course. The crash in 1929 took until the 1940's to unwind; Japan's problems of the early 1980's were still plauging their economy by the late 1990's and arguably haven't run their course yet even today.