Duck hunting crimes:

wet_suit_one

New member
Aug 6, 2005
2,059
0
0
Compare the U.S. and Canadian sentences (for two different crimes). Are these reasonable? Whaddya think hombres?

source: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saska...15/sk-american-hunter-pleads-guilty-1109.html

Duck-abusing American hunter pleads guilty

An American hunter who abused wounded birds in Western Canada and videotaped his antics is facing a $15,000 fine and a three-year hunting ban in Canada.

Jeffery Burdett Foiles, 54, of Pleasant Hill, Illinois, pleaded guilty in an Edmonton court Wednesday to causing unnecessary pain and suffering to a duck, contrary to the Criminal Code.

He also pleaded guilty to multiple violations of the Migratory Birds Convention Act, including killing more than his daily limit, hunting birds from a powerboat and failing to immediately kill a wounded duck he had retrieved.

The incidents happened near several communities around Alberta between 2004 and 2007.

Michelle Ferguson, the federal Crown prosecutor in the case, described some of the incidents recorded on Foiles's videos — later discovered by U.S. authorities — that resulted in the charges.

"Making the duck face the camera. Whacking the duck on the head. Placing an empty bullet box on the duck's head. Whacking that on his head. Plugging the nostrils of the duck and holding its beak shut," she said.

According to an agreed statement of facts between Crown and defence, most of the incidents that led to the changes happened in the Bentley area.

In one video recorded Oct. 17, 2007 near Westerose, Foiles held a wounded mallard up to the camera, then moved the head around so it was facing him, the statement said.

"Look at me when I'm talking to you," Foiles said. He wagged the duck's head back and forth, then opened and closed the bird's mouth with his fingers while making quacking sounds, the statement said. He then walked off camera and killed the duck.

Some of the incidents that led to the charges happened near Bentley and Pigeon Lake, Alta.

Foiles is a guide who runs a hunting club in Illinois and posts edited versions of his videos on YouTube in a series called "Fallin' Skies". The videos are shot in Alberta and Saskatchewan.

In Canada, under a joint submission from the Crown and defence, he'll likely receive a $15,000 fine and a three-year hunting ban, but a judge will have the final decision. He'll find out about the sentence next week.

Meanwhile, Foiles is also facing punishment in Illinois for violating hunting laws there.

Earlier this year, he pleaded guilty to one count of unlawful sale of wildlife and one count of unlawfully taking migratory game birds.

Under a deal between the defence and prosecution, Foiles has agreed to serve 13 months in prison and pay a $100,000 fine, with sentencing set for Sept. 21."



Is it just me, or is the U.S. like crazy punitive? 13 months and a $100K fine for unlawful sale of wildlife and unlawfully taking migratory game birds. Really? Not saying poaching is ok or anything, just seems like fairly strong sauce for a relatively minor crime. Or am I smoking bad duck feathers?
 
Sorry as a hunter who has always tried to follow the rules. . . . Smoking bad duck feathers.

If the guy had violated some minor rule (not leaving a feathered wing on transported birds) that is one thing but major violations. Come on!
 
So should he have been summarily shot?

I'm not questioning whether it should be a crime, I'm asking were the penalties fair? Which was fair? The U.S.'s or Canada? Was one too harsh, not harsh enough or just right?

Do tell.
 
Canada not harsh enough. The guy is sick, it truly amazes me he is not completely banned from entering Canada. If that was a Canadian violating US law he would never be allowed back.
 
Friggin' duck hunters. Oughta be banned I tell ya :p
 
Canada not harsh enough. The guy is sick, it truly amazes me he is not completely banned from entering Canada. If that was a Canadian violating US law he would never be allowed back.

Yeah. Isn't torturing animals, one of the classic signs of a psychopath?
 
Yeah. Isn't torturing animals, one of the classic signs of a psychopath?


That's what I was thinking. If the goals of a sentence are punishment, deterrence, and prevention, then punishment and prevention should be the priorities in this case. He's made a habit of acting like this and he's sure to do it again.

If he's a guide, he's supposed to know better.
 
forget about the fine and jail time. Let nature hand out justice and throw the demented moron bastard in an ocean (baited with blood) full of great white sharks during a feeding frenzy for a day or two.