Don't change the anthem

The Americans play with their anthem ALL the time.

Great voice on that girl.

I didn't get all wound up about it.

One of the most haunting versions of Oh Canada I ever heard was right after 911 when Natalie MacMaster played Oh Canada just on her fiddle. Brought tears to my eyes.

They do? They may sing it a little different because some of the parts (that "land of the FREE" is a tough one for some) but I have yet to hear a different "official" versions (by official I mean at some game, function, or government assembly).

Frankly I did NOT appreciate that version in the least. I mean, you don't change the cadence, notes, or rythym of a song or anthem. I've heard rap, rock and pop versions but it is all done with the correct cadence, just different vocal styles or harder edges such as with an electric guitar.
 
It was more that the anthem was changed from being inclusive where everyone one could sing along with pride to being exclusive where only the girl singing the anthem knew the melody to sing along. One comment in the Toronto Stare put it well "it changed the anthem from being paitriotic to being a lounge act." I know there are rendition changes to the anthem but if ever there was a time that perhaps all the Canadains in the stadium would like to have sung along to our anthem the opening cermonies was one of them. Like I said it was about making the anthem exclusive to one singer rather than keeping it inclusive so everyone could sing along to an anthem in a style they knew.

Yeah, THAT was it.....good way to describe it actually.

But hey, it's 2010, anything goes now. They changed the anthem for HNIC to that soda pop POS crap with bagpipes and brass...wtf is that? I cringe whenever I hear that too.....da dadaaaaa da DA duh DUHDUTdahhhh wht????
 
I had to laugh when I saw Sarah McLachlan listed as proudly being from Halifax.I dated a girl about 15 years ago who was best friends with her in their teens.She fucking HATES Halifax!!.....Hates it....When she left in her late teens she did not come back for 10 years and that was only on a tour stop.She considers Vancouver her home.She was picked on as a kid and could not wait to leave.
I'm sorry for her and I'm sorry for Nova Scotia. It's a shame when someone feels that way. Many of us have less than the world's best time in Secondary School/High School, but generally we don't totally cut ourselves off from our home town for the rest of our lives.
 
wrote to him and gave him a peice of my mind.

I mean you can play with certain things but what he did was paramount to changing our flag from a red maple leaf on a white background to a Blue oak leaf on a green background.

Some thing you don't mess with.....
 
As a musiacian for over 40 plus years and who has played our National Anthem in front of PM's Presidents and Royalty I was disgusted at the rebndition "sung" last night.
The girl has a GREAT voice BUT O'Canada is NOT a jazz or R&B number. I cringe when these "artists" sing any anthem US included like it's part of their repitoire. SING THE SONG THEWAY IT WAS WRITTEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Why didn't they get the opinion of the crowd during the rehersal? If they hated it, like we all seem to, they could have done Oh Canada properly during the opening ceremonies.
 
Last edited:
Why didn't they get the opinion of the crowd during the rehersal? If they hated, like we all seem to, they could have done Oh Canada properly during the opening ceremonies.
Hey Vanoc doesn't even have a direct email address posted on their Olympic site, so it is apparent they have no interest in hearing from the general Canadian public.