Don't change the anthem

my2cents

Just Horny
Aug 22, 2001
805
0
16
between the sheets
Watching the opening cermonies and hearing our national anthem jazzed up it made me think that perhaps the non Canadian production company producing the opening ceremonies should know you don't change a countries anthem especially when its broadcast to the world. Well I guess if your a non Canadian production company, that's right Canadian's aren't producing their own opening and closing ceremonies, changing the sound of an Anthem is ok to do.
 
i also agree, bad rendition of our anthem.
 
A national anthem is not the place for a singer to improvise or show his or her range or whatever. It should be sung in a proud and dignified way, showing respect for your nation.
 
A national anthem is not the place for a singer to improvise or show his or her range or whatever. It should be sung in a proud and dignified way, showing respect for your nation.
Yea we Canadians know that but the Australian Production company producing the Opening and closing ceremonies don't care it's not their countries anthem. Imagine being in the stadium trying to sing along with that version. It made me mad at a time when we should have sung along with pride. Its only our Canadian tax dollars producing the Olympics all the main work is being done by non Canadians.
 
Watching the opening cermonies and hearing our national anthem jazzed up it made me think that perhaps the non Canadian production company producing the opening ceremonies should know you don't change a countries anthem especially when its broadcast to the world. Well I guess if your a non Canadian production company, that's right Canadian's aren't producing their own opening and closing ceremonies, changing the sound of an Anthem is ok to do.

THANK-YOU!!!

Watching that drove me crazy!

Horrible Horrible Horrible :(
 
THANK-YOU!!!

Watching that drove me crazy!

Horrible Horrible Horrible :(

Feel free to contact the Australian Executive producer of the Olympic opening cermonies, who figures it's ok to change an Anthem of another country during an international event. Contact info for David Atkins is http://www.davidatkinsenterprises.com/contactus.html

You may also want to note that you don't put the long drawn out part of the atheletes walking into the stadium at the start of the broadcast, you actually produce an interesting event that people want to watch and be inspired by then after see their atheletes enter. Ya know like every other producer that has produced the opening cermonies in the world knows.......
 
Last edited:
Feel free to contact the Australian Executive producer of the Olympic opening cermonies, who figures it's ok to change an Anthem of another country during an international event. Contact info for David Atkins is http://www.davidatkinsenterprises.com/contactus.html

You may also want to note that you don't put the long drawn out part of the atheletes walking into the stadium at the start of the broadcast, you actually produce an interesting event that people want to watch and be inspired by then after see their atheletes enter. Ya know like every other producer that has produce the opening cermonies in the world knows.......

Brian Adams and Nelly Furtado lip-syncing isnt doing much for me right now either.... :S


(edit - the whale thing was cool though - and yay! Sarah McLachlan! :).... ok The post-athlete parade show is beautiful... )
 
Not much on the anthem changes either...even if it was a pretty song.
 
The Americans play with their anthem ALL the time.

Great voice on that girl.

I didn't get all wound up about it.

One of the most haunting versions of Oh Canada I ever heard was right after 911 when Natalie MacMaster played Oh Canada just on her fiddle. Brought tears to my eyes.
 
Not sure what the big deal here is, or why I've been reading quite a few complaints. I hear the Canadian and U.S. anthems toyed with all the time. Back when I was in high school, they used to play a different version over the PA every morning. Sometimes it was very traditional, but other times it was obviously more "youth-oriented".
I thought she did a fine job tonight, but I'll agree that the Furtado/Adams song was pretty uninspiring.
 
Not sure what the big deal here is, or why I've been reading quite a few complaints. I hear the Canadian and U.S. anthems toyed with all the time. Back when I was in high school, they used to play a different version over the PA every morning. Sometimes it was very traditional, but other times it was obviously more "youth-oriented".
I thought she did a fine job tonight, but I'll agree that the Furtado/Adams song was pretty uninspiring.
It is more to the fact the Anthem was changed to the point of not making it inviting to join in and sing along with. A stadium full of alot of Canadians who would probably want to sing along with the Anthem at Canada's Olympic ceremonies may not agree that making a version they have a hard time singin along with would not be a good idea. As a solo act it might be okay to toy with the song but this was an event for all and I am sure Canadians in the stadium probably were surprised when they couldn't really sing along to the Anthem because of the changes.
 
I agree wholehearedly, it was awful, I hated it and I hate that style of singing where the words are delayed so they dont coincide with the music. And the tempo and R&B style I hated too.
 
Not to be disrespectful but based on the posts here I expect the ANTHEM will soon be I HAVE BECOME COMFORTABLY NUMB
 
.
The young lady who sang the song made it very clear ,in an interview , it was not her idea to modify the anthem .
She just sang it as she was directed to . I agree it was a shame that it was very difficult for the crowd to sing along .

Loved the opening ceremonies .
 
Brian Adams and Nelly Furtado lip-syncing isnt doing much for me right now either.... :S


(edit - the whale thing was cool though - and yay! Sarah McLachlan! :).... ok The post-athlete parade show is beautiful... )

I had to laugh when I saw Sarah McLachlan listed as proudly being from Halifax.I dated a girl about 15 years ago who was best friends with her in their teens.She fucking HATES Halifax!!.....Hates it....When she left in her late teens she did not come back for 10 years and that was only on a tour stop.She considers Vancouver her home.She was picked on as a kid and could not wait to leave.
 
Because I read this thread before I saw the opening ceremony on delay from the US West Coast, I was prepared for a version of the National anthem akin to the Sex Pistols' version of "God Save the Queen" or Jimi Hendrix's famous rendition of "The Star Spangled Banner." I was pleasantly surprised! Nikki Yanofsky's version of "O Canada" was neither offensive nor outrageous and was well within the limits of the genre in which she sings. It actually sounded like "O Canada." Keep your eyes on Nikki. She will eventually become the greatest contribution that Canada has ever made to the music and entertainment world (with the possible exception of Glenn Gould). What was more distracting was the overly mournful rendition that K.T. Lang (my she's put on weight) made of Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah", an already mournful song that only Cohen can sing with real effectiveness and Mischa Bruggergosman's over-the-top version of the Olympic Hymn, a song that is more military than operatic and really deserves a gigantic chorus like the Toronto Mendelssohn Choir or some such organization. As for the visuals, they were well and creditably done. I only wonder what happened to the Industrial Heartland?

AVO
 
Because I read this thread before I saw the opening ceremony on delay from the US West Coast, I was prepared for a version of the National anthem akin to the Sex Pistols' version of "God Save the Queen" or Jimi Hendrix's famous rendition of "The Star Spangled Banner." I was pleasantly surprised! Nikki Yanofsky's version of "O Canada" was neither offensive nor outrageous and was well within the limits of the genre in which she sings. It actually sounded like "O Canada." Keep your eyes on Nikki. She will eventually become the greatest contribution that Canada has ever made to the music and entertainment world (with the possible exception of Glenn Gould). What was more distracting was the overly mournful rendition that K.T. Lang (my she's put on weight) made of Leonard Cohen's "Hallelujah", an already mournful song that only Cohen can sing with real effectiveness and Mischa Bruggergosman's over-the-top version of the Olympic Hymn, a song that is more military than operatic and really deserves a gigantic chorus like the Toronto Mendelssohn Choir or some such organization. As for the visuals, they were well and creditably done. I only wonder what happened to the Industrial Heartland?

AVO

It was more that the anthem was changed from being inclusive where everyone one could sing along with pride to being exclusive where only the girl singing the anthem knew the melody to sing along. One comment in the Toronto Star put it well "it changed the anthem from being paitriotic to being a lounge act." I know there are rendition changes to the anthem but if ever there was a time that perhaps all the Canadians in the stadium would like to have sung along to our anthem the opening cermonies was one of them. Like I said it was about making the anthem exclusive to one singer rather than keeping it inclusive so everyone could sing along to an anthem in a style they knew.
 
Last edited:
The Americans play with their anthem ALL the time.
And most get just as pissed off about it as most of us are about the mangling of Oh Canada.

My belief is this all started going to Hell, when having the entire audience stand and sing the National Anthem was replaced by having someone "warble" it at us!

.
 
Last edited: