Don't Call It A Trade Deficit

TOVisitor

New member
Jul 14, 2003
3,305
0
0
Max Sawicky is a very astute economist.

February 14, 2006
DON'T CALL IT A TRADE DEFICIT
http://maxspeak.org/mt/archives/002001.html

So says the new Economic Report of the President, signed by our new Federal Reserve Board Chairman Ben Bernanke, in a chapter entitled "The U.S. Capital Account Surplus." "Surplus" sounds much better, don't you think? We've got a surplus in the capital account. Capital is flowing in. It shows foreigners love us, they really love us. Not like those dreary deficits in the Federal budget.

Capital account surplus means foreigners are taking increasing ownership of U.S. dollar-denominated assets, since we buy more from them than we sell to them. It's like this: if you own your home free and clear and take out a mortgage to buy skittles and beer, you've got yourself a capital account surplus.

We learn in this chapter about the movements of capital, that the best thing the U.S. can do about the surplus is to raise national saving. Turns out that "At 13 percent of GDP," say Ben and his boyz, "the U.S. domestic saving rate is the lowest among the advanced economy countries," them Euro-socialist countries with the big, bad tax systems. Much else can be done to reduce our trade deficit capital account surplus, according to the report, but it all must be done by other countries. Diplomatic initiatives will commence with invitations to the world's finance ministers -- I know you're way ahead of me here -- to a Dick Cheney hunting party.

Worse, the savings rate has decreased since 1995, the bad old days of sky-high Clintonian Euro-socialist taxes. One component of this rate is the rise in the Federal deficit after 2001. We all know what's up with that. Another is the personal savings rate. It's gone down too.

What about the excellent tax cuts after 2000? The reductions in the top marginal rates and the special preferred rates on dividends and capital gains are the jewels in the crown of supply side tax policy. They are supposed to raise saving. How can you not get more saving if you increase the returns to saving? It's like a law of physics, goddamn it.

Alas, it was not to be. The savings rate has not returned to the level of the bad old days of 1995. The actual modern swan dive in savings occurred after 1980, along with the excellent Reagan era supply-side tax cuts.

Clearly there is more work to be done, as long as the savings rate is above zero. The Administration is pledged to pound that sucker into the dust with yet another round of tax cuts, as proposed in the latest Bush budget.

Don't call it savings. It's really the reverse of Indentured National Servitude Credits, and George Bush is fighting to get us into positive territory.

Max also gives us his preview of the new book by Bruce Bartlett:

Impostor: How George W. Bush Bankrupted America and Betrayed the American Legacy

Sample chapter titles:

"I Know Conservatives, and George W. Bush Is No Conservative"

"Why the Bush Tax Cuts Didn't Deliver"

"The Worst Record on Trade Since Hoover?"

. . . and perhaps the lowest blow of all:

"On the Budget, Clinton Was Better"

You look at the clowns warming seats at all the well-oiled conservative think tanks in town and consider that there is no place for Bruce. Which leads us to 3M, the MaxSpeak Meme of the Millenium:

The Republican Party has utterly rubbished its principles for the sake of political power, and the intellectual standing of its apologists has descended to the level of sea slugs.

Reviews of Barlett's book are instructive:

From Publishers Weekly
Liberal commentators gripe so frequently about the current administration that it's become easy to tune them out, but when Bartlett, a former member of the Reagan White House, says George W. Bush has betrayed the conservative movement, his conservative credentials command attention. Bartlett's attack boils down to one key premise: Bush is a shallow opportunist who has cast aside the principles of the "Reagan Revolution" for short-term political gains that may wind up hurting the American economy as badly as, if not worse than, Nixon's did. As part of a simple, point-by-point critique of Bush's "finger-in-the-wind" approach to economic leadership, Bartlett singles out the Medicare prescription drug bill of 2003— "the worst piece of legislation ever enacted"—as a particularly egregious example of the increases in government spending that will, he says, make tax hikes inevitable. Bush has further weakened the Republican Party by failing to establish a successor who can run in the next election, Bartlett says. If the Reaganites want to restore the party's tradition of fiscal conservatism and small government, he worries, let alone keep the Democrats out of the White House, they will have their work cut out for them.

FromBooklist
Bartlett, an economist and former Reagan administration official, attacks the Bush administration hard but from the political Right. Challenging Bush's conservative principles of operation and credentials, Bartlett actually gives former president Clinton more credit for following conservative economic principles. In contrast, the Bush administration has been marked by shortsightedness, if not anti--intellectualism, too willing to reward friends without regard to competency and to punish as enemies those who deviate from the party line. Bush's shortcomings include his drug bill, trade policies, and expanded regulatory requirements. Interestingly, Bartlett concludes that Bush's relentless effort to cut taxes will leave an unenviable legacy for a conservative--the need for America's largest tax increase. Bartlett also takes the administration to task for corruption that violates the principles of difference the Republican Party declared during the campaign against Clinton. This is a worthy critique, one that the administration will not be able to dismiss as liberal propaganda.
 
how would you put the US in a stronger position when it comes to trade???

Should NAFTA be scraped as well as trade with countries with questionable labor histories?
 
You post these articles and have absolutely no clue as to what they are talking about. All you know is they slam Bush, so they must be cool. Off the top of your head, what is bad about running a capital account surplus? Tick. Tick. Tick.
 
Here is what a Von Mises economist thinks:

http://www.mises.org/story/1955

...snip Opting for a relatively free-market system, the United States appears to have succeeded in providing an environment more conducive to investment and growth than other currency regions, most notably Europe and Japan. This is evidenced, for instance, in its higher growth and capital return rates. In the words of Mises, "[…] the tremendous progress of technological methods of production and the resulting increase in wealth and welfare were feasible only through the pursuit of those liberal policies […]" [2] That said, the current deficit in the United States may very well be a result of its adherence to a more efficient economic model than many other currency areas....

...It is often said that a rising trade deficit will lead to a depreciation of the US dollar. However, data paint a very different picture. Figure 2 shows the real effective external value of the US dollar and the US trade deficit as a percentage of GDP from the middle of the 1970s to Q1 05. It shows that a rising (shrinking) trade deficit has been, on average, accompanied by an appreciation (depreciation) of the real value of the trade-weighted greenback...

In summary, under the prevailing flexible exchange rate regime, the US trade deficit should not be viewed as a worrisome economic "imbalance" that will inevitably have to be corrected. So far, the US trade deficit seems to be a reflection of the US economy's strength vis-à-vis its trading partners. [9] And it might well be that the US trade deficit will continue to widen in the coming years — which would be the case if the United States' trading partners prove to be unsuccessful in making their economies more conducive to investment and growth compared with the status quo...

...So the essential issue about the future of the US trade deficit is whether and how the current relative growth performance constellation in the world trading system will be changing in the coming years. As long as the United States keeps its preference for a free market regime, it might well retain, or even increase, its competitive advantage in allocating scare resources more efficiently than currency areas where relatively wide-spread government interventions have become a characteristic of societal organization. In today's world of flexible exchange rates, the United States' competitive edge is reflected by a capital surplus, i.e., a trade deficit.
 
TOVisitor said:
Reviews of Barlett's book are instructive:

So if I post a scathing review of his book on amazon.com you will find it "instructive"? How about reading the book for yourself and drawing your own conclusions?

TOV, you are the gift that keeps on giving. Never change.
 
TOV, your actually on to something here. The U.S. trade deficit is due to the United States consuming more than it consumes. That would be great if it could continue forever. Who would not want to spend more than they earn if they never had to worry about repayment? Of course foreigners are only willing to finance it if they receive with debt or equity in return (the capital account surplus your quote speaks of). Either way, eventually foreigners will eventually want to collect their IOUs, and the U.S. will have to start producing more than it consumes. In other words, working more and consuming less. What they need to do is to increase taxes, cut spending and somehow address the low private savings rate (this last part is likely the most difficult). However, in the sort run, the American public seems to believe that it is possible to get something for nothing forever. I can’t see them electing a more responsible government that would address the government deficit in the near future. Eventually they will be force to do so and the longer they delay the more difficult the adjustment. However, it seems to me that the American public is a long way from even recognizing that there is a problem.
 
someone said:
TOV, your actually on to something here. The U.S. trade deficit is due to the United States producing more than it consumes.
Must be new math.

Ps That thing he is "on to" is called crack.
 
arclighter said:
Must be new math.

Ps That thing he is "on to" is called crack.
I have not had my morning coffee yet. I'll edit it now.
 
Among the people referenced on the Von Mises site are Lew Rockwell and Paul Craig Roberts.

Rockwell:

If you follow hate-filled sites such as Free Republic, you know that the populist right in this country has been advocating nuclear holocaust and mass bloodshed for more than a year now. The militarism and nationalism dwarfs anything I saw at any point during the Cold War. It celebrates the shedding of blood, and exhibits a maniacal love of the state. The new ideology of the red-state bourgeoisie seems to actually believe that the US is God marching on earth – not just godlike, but really serving as a proxy for God himself.

Along with this goes a kind of worship of the presidency, and a celebration of all things public sector, including egregious law like the Patriot Act, egregious bureaucracies like the Department of Homeland Security, and egregious centrally imposed regimentation like the No Child Left Behind Act. It longs for the state to throw its weight behind institutions like the two-parent heterosexual family, the Christian charity, the homogeneous community of native-born patriots.

In 1994, the central state was seen by the bourgeoisie as the main threat to the family; in 2004 it is seen as the main tool for keeping the family together and ensuring its ascendancy. In 1994, the state was seen as the enemy of education; today, the same people view the state as the means of raising standards and purging education of its left-wing influences. In 1994, Christians widely saw that Leviathan was the main enemy of the faith; today, they see Leviathan as the tool by which they will guarantee that their faith will have an impact on the country and the world

In short, what we have alive in the US is an updated and Americanized fascism. Why fascist? Because it is not leftist in the sense of egalitarian or redistributionist. It has no real beef with business. It doesn't sympathize with the downtrodden, labor, or the poor. It is for all the core institutions of bourgeois life in America: family, faith, and flag. But it sees the state as the central organizing principle of society, views public institutions as the most essential means by which all these institutions are protected and advanced, and adores the head of state as a godlike figure who knows better than anyone else what the country and world's needs, and has a special connection to the Creator that permits him to discern the best means to bring it about.

The American right today has managed to be solidly anti-leftist while adopting an ideology – even without knowing it or being entirely conscious of the change – that is also frighteningly anti-liberty. This reality turns out to be very difficult for libertarians to understand or accept. For a long time, we've tended to see the primary threat to liberty as coming from the left, from the socialists who sought to control the economy from the center. But we must also remember that the sweep of history shows that there are two main dangers to liberty, one that comes from the left and the other that comes from the right. Europe and Latin America have long faced the latter threat, but its reality is only now hitting us fully.

What is the most pressing and urgent threat to freedom that we face in our time? It is not from the left. If anything, the left has been solid on civil liberties and has been crucial in drawing attention to the lies and abuses of the Bush administration. No, today, the clear and present danger to freedom comes from the right side of the ideological spectrum, those people who are pleased to preserve most of free enterprise but favor top-down management of society, culture, family, and school, and seek to use a messianic and belligerent nationalism to impose their vision of politics on the world.

Roberts:

"In the ranks of the new conservatives, however, I see and experience much hate. It comes to me in violently worded, ignorant and irrational emails from self-professed conservatives who literally worship George Bush. Even Christians have fallen into idolatry. There appears to be a large number of Americans who are prepared to kill anyone for George Bush. ... Like Brownshirts, the new conservatives take personally any criticism of their leader and his policies. To be a critic is to be an enemy."

The right -- exemplified by Rockwell, Roberts, and Bartlett -- all find the phallic worship of the Shrub to be appalling.

So do I.

By the way... I don't do trolls.
 
Here's some data from December 2005, with references.

WAGES

American families have consistently seen their incomes decline during the Bush Presidency—even when calculating only from the end of the last recession.

• For 2005, average real weekly wages fell 0.4% from $552.75 in December 2004 to $550.60 in December 2005. Since the end of the recession, they are also down 0.4% from $552.58 in November 2001. [BLS]

• For 2005, average real hourly wages fell 0.4% from $16.40 in December 2004 to $16.34 in December 2005. Since the end of the recession, they have been effectively stagnant, dropping one cent from $16.35 in November 2001. [BLS]

• Since the 2003 tax cut, real hourly wages have fallen 2.2% and real weekly wages have fallen 1.6%. [BLS]

• Real median household income has fallen each year Bush has been in office and by nearly $1,000 since the recession 2001 [U.S. Census Bureau, Income Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2004, Aug. 2005, Table A-1.]

EMPLOYMENT GROWTH

The President focused on job creation in both recent speeches, but employment growth in the current recovery has been the weakest on record.

• Monthly private employment growth has averaged a meager 59,700 per month even excluding the last recession and the months leading into it—the weakest monthly average for any recovery of this length. [BLS]

• The 4. 5 million job growth in the last two and a half years that the President brags about is weak by historical standards. In the last three recoveries, the economy created 7.9 million jobs during the corresponding 30 month period—3.4 million jobs more than we’ve seen in the last two and a half years–even with a smaller workforce and smaller population. [BLS]

• The only reason the unemployment rate has fallen to 5% is that a smaller share of the population is working or actively seeking work today compared to before the recession. If labor force participation were as high today, as it was before the recession the unemployment rate would be 6.6%–1.6 points higher than today’s official number [BLS]

• Indeed, this is the first time on record that portion of the population holding a job is down 48 months after the end of a recession.

POVERTY

After seeing enormous gains in the fight against poverty under President Clinton, the poverty rate has risen each of Bush’s years in office, as an additional 5.4 million people have fallen into poverty since 2000. [Census, Aug. 2005, Table B-1]

• The poverty rate has risen each year since the end of the recession—from 11.7% in 2001 to 12.7% last year as 4 million people fell into poverty. [Census, Aug. 2005, Table B-1]

• African American poverty has also jumped—from 22.7% in 2001 to 24.7% in 2004 as nearly 1 million (864,000) African Americans have fallen under the poverty line. [Census, Aug. 2005, Table B-1]

• Child poverty rate is on the rise—jumping from 16.3% in 2001 to 17.8% in 2004. As 1.3 million children under 18 have fallen into poverty [Census, Aug. 2005, Table B-2]

• This is the only recovery on record where poverty increased from the second to third year after the recession. [Census, Aug. 2005, Table B-1]

SAVINGS

Though incomes have fallen, consumer spending growth has continued to propel the economy. Unfortunately, this combination has pushed the personal savings rate to historic lows, debt burdens to historic highs, and exacerbated our already unsustainable current account deficit.

• The personal savings rate has plummeted this year, hitting -2.18% in August—a level not seen since the Great Depression. [Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA)]

• Americans now pay a record 13.6% of their disposable income to service their debt. Since we’ve had to borrow at record rates to spend beyond our means, debt burdens have risen considerably. [Federal Reserve]

• Thanks in part to our recent fiscal deterioration, net national savings have dropped from 4.9% when Bush took office to -1.0% last quarter– its lowest level since the Great Depression. [BEA]

The transition from budget surpluses to budget deficits was a major factor in this shift to dissavings. In January 2001, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projected a more than $5 trillion 10 year surplus. Today, Goldman Sachs predicts a $5 trillion cumulative deficit over the next 10 years. They cite the extension of the tax cut as the “single biggest factor underlying” that prediction.

• The current account has deficit exploded—hitting a record $199 billion in the first quarter this year and on pace to top $800 billion this year. [BEA, Global Insight Inc. projection in Greg Hitt, “Trade Gap Eases, but Deficit Poised to Break a Record,” The Wall Street Journal, 9/17/05]

• We now have to borrow about $3 billion from abroad every business day to support our habits.

Hey, but the economy is great under the Shrub.

Republicans: Spending recklessly and mortgaging our future, all while screwing the middle class.
 
TOVisitor said:
Among the people referenced on the Von Mises site are Lew Rockwell and Paul Craig Roberts.





The right -- exemplified by Rockwell, Roberts, and Bartlett -- all find the phallic worship of the Shrub to be appalling.

So do I.

By the way... I don't do trolls.
This is news to you? Have you been living under a rock? Lew Rockwell isn't the "right" you moron. He is a libertarian. Actually more of an anti-war.com anarcho-capitalist. Please stop sharing your ignorance with us. We have had our fill.

Ps Bush isn't a conservative.
 
Paul Craig Roberts again

It's embarrassing when conservatives mock Bubble-boy with a Nazi reference.

Conservatives Endorse the Fuhrer Principle
Our leader über alles
by Paul Craig Roberts


Last week's annual Conservative Political Action Conference signaled the transformation of American conservatism into brownshirtism. A former Justice Department official named Viet Dinh got a standing ovation when he told the CPAC audience that the rule of law mustn't get in the way of President Bush protecting Americans from Osama bin Laden.

Former Republican congressman Bob Barr, who led the House impeachment of President Bill Clinton, reminded the CPAC audience that our first loyalty is to the U.S. Constitution, not to a leader. The question, Barr said, is not one of disloyalty to Bush, but whether America "will remain a nation subject to, and governed by, the rule of law or the whim of men."

The CPAC audience answered that they preferred to be governed by Bush. According to Dana Milbank, a member of the CPAC audience named Richard Sorcinelli loudly booed Barr, declaring: "I can't believe I'm in a conservative hall listening to him say Bush is off course trying to defend the United States." A woman in the audience told Barr that the Constitution placed Bush above the law and above non-elected federal judges.

These statements gallop beyond the merely partisan. They express the sentiments of brownshirtism. Our leader über alles.

Only a few years ago this same group saw Barr as a conservative hero for obtaining Clinton's impeachment in the House. Obviously, CPAC's praise for Barr did not derive from Barr's stand on conservative principle that a president must be held accountable if he violates the law. In Clinton's case, Barr's principles did not conflict with the blind emotions of the politically partisan conservatives demanding Clinton's impeachment.

In opposing Bush's illegal behavior, Barr is simply being consistent. But this time, Barr's principles are at odds with the emotions of the politically partisan CPAC audience. Rushing to the defense of Bush, the CPAC audience endorsed Viet Dinh's Fuhrer Principle over the rule of law.

Why do the media and the public allow partisan political hacks, like Viet Dinh, to define Bush's illegal actions as a national security issue? The purpose of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act is to protect national security. FISA creates a secret court to which the president can apply for a warrant even after he has initiated spying. Complying with the law in no way handicaps spying for national security purposes. The only spying handicapped by the warrant requirement is spying for illegitimate purposes, such as spying on political opponents.

There are only two reasons for Bush to refuse to obey the law. One is that he is guilty of illegitimate spying for which no warrant would be issued by the FISA court. The other is that he is using "national security" to create unconstitutional powers for the executive.

Civil libertarian Harvey Silverglate writing in the Boston Phoenix says that Bush's grab for "sweeping, unchecked power in direct violation of a statute would open a Pandora's box of imperial possibilities." In short, it makes the president a dictator.

For years, the Republican Federalist Society has been agitating for concentrating more power in the executive. The members will say that they do not favor a dictator, just a check on the "imperial Congress" and "imperial judiciary." But they have not spelled out how the president can be higher than law and still be accountable, or, if he is only to be higher than some laws, but not other laws, and only in some circumstances, but not all circumstances, who draws the line through the law and defines the circumstances.

On Feb. 13, the American Bar Association passed a resolution belatedly asking President Bush to stop violating the law. "We cannot allow the U.S. Constitution and our rights to become a victim of terrorism," said bar association president Michael Grecco.

The siren call of "national security" is all the cover Bush needs to have the FISA law repealed, thus legally gaining the power to spy however he chooses, the protection of political opponents be damned. However, Bush and his Federalist Society Justice Department are not interested in having the law repealed. Their purpose has nothing to do with national security. The point on which the regime is insisting is that there are circumstances (undefined) in which the president does not have to obey laws. What those circumstances and laws are is for the regime to decide.

The Bush regime is asserting the Fuhrer Principle, and Americans are buying it, even as Bush declares that America is at war in order to bring democracy to the Middle East.

The American Bar Association? You mean that looney organization that Bush cited as endorsing his nomination of Scalito?
 
TOVisitor said:
It's embarrassing when conservatives mock Bubble-boy with a Nazi reference.



The American Bar Association? You mean that looney organization that Bush cited as endorsing his nomination of Scalito?

Are you implying Lawers are not worthy of opinions?
 
papasmerf said:
Are you implying Lawers are not worthy of opinions?

Naw, I shoulda putta /sarcasm after my statement.

The ABA endorses Scalito and the WH goes whoopy. The ABA says that the Shrub is breaking the law and all you can hear are crickets chirping.
 
TOVisitor said:
Naw, I shoulda putta /sarcasm after my statement.

The ABA endorses Scalito and the WH goes whoopy. The ABA says that the Shrub is breaking the law and all you can hear are crickets chirping.

Can't have it both ways

Are lawers good or bad?

should an Association of lawers be allowed to voice opinions?