dogfights - which was the best?

Best fighter of WW2

  • Supermarine Spitfire

    Votes: 18 41.9%
  • Messerschmitt ME-109

    Votes: 9 20.9%
  • Focke-Wulf FW-190

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • North American P-51 Mustang

    Votes: 10 23.3%
  • Grumman F4F Hellcat

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • Mitsubishi A6M Zero

    Votes: 2 4.7%
  • Republic P-47 Thunderbolt

    Votes: 2 4.7%
  • Curtiss P-40 Warhawk

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    43

dj1470

Banned
Apr 7, 2005
7,701
0
0
I've been watching this series called Dogfights which has been discussed here before but every time I watch it they are constantly saying that the "american" fighter was the best of the war. I was wondering what everyone else thought. I know that this will only appeal to history buffs like myself but I was bored and got to thinking about trivial stuff. For me it was the Spitfire.
 
I never watched "Dogfights!" It seems like it is pro-American or biased.

There are other documentaries, also produced by Americans, that present a more factual account of aerial warfare in WW2.

In fact, in these documentaries, historians and even veteran American pilots admit that the Zero was superior in a dogfight. However, while the Zero had superior maneuverability, it was poorly armored, and could not withstand much damage.

And yes, from the perspective that the Spitfire was often outnumbered by the Messerschmitts, the Spitfires provided excellent overall performance.

The American P-51 was definitely the speed king while the US P-47 Thunderbolt was a flying tank.

So in summary, all these planes had good and bad points, and there is no clear cut winner. The training of the pilots is also a very important factor.

For example, in the Korean War, even though the US F-86 Sabre was inferior to the Soviet Mig-15, the American pilots has superior training.
 
Spits by far. They went thru so many Marks during the war.

The trusty Hurricane was always the underrated Ugly Sister to the Spit but thank God we had 'em when we did.
 
It is not commonly known that the P-51 Mustang was in fact originally an RAF project. It’s true genius was again sparked by the RAF which suggested substituting a Rolls Royce Merlin Engine (latter made under license by Packard) for the original Allison Engine.

I recommend the following biography of Air Chief Marshal Sir Wilfrid Freeman who is quite properly described as having been one of the single most important influences on the rearmament of the Royal Air Force in the years leading up to and during WW II. More perhaps than anyone else Air Chief Marshal Freeman was not only responsible for the procurement of the P-51 but also the Supermarine Spitfire and the De Havilland Mosquito.

Wilfrid Freeman: the genius behind Allied survival and air supremacy, 1939 to 1945
http://www.amazon.com/Wilfrid-Freem...=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1203388777&sr=8-1


* in the shades of a world past he was never promoted to Marshal of the Royal Air Force, made Chief of Air Staff, nor granted a peerage largely because he had divorced and remarried.
 
The ME 262 was the best
 
danmand said:
The ME 262 was the best

Yeah, I love those experimental planes by the Germans and the Japanese.

The Me 262, the Me 163 Komet, and the Kyushu Shinden ... all cool stuff.

There was another good documentary on the History Channel called Secret Weapons of the Luftwaffe. Some bizarre ideas in the last days of the war.
 
Aardvark154 said:
It is not commonly known that the P-51 Mustang was in fact originally an RAF project. It’s true genius was again sparked by the RAF which suggested substituting a Rolls Royce Merlin Engine (latter made under license by Packard) for the original Allison Engine.

Have to agree with this.

As much as I love the Spitfires and they were a truly remarkable plane (except in a negative G dive when their carbs would fuel starve), the P-51 was a superior plane.

It was as you stated a real dog till the British put Merlins in them.

An interesting thought, in its day, the Merlin was positively the state of the art. It was high tech. The British GAVE the designs to the Americans (Parkard) to produce in quantity under license to Rolls Royce.
 
As stated, all the early fighters had their good points and bad, back in the day you could design a plane to do a couple of things well, but at the cost of something else.

Now only the planes used in the ETO have been mentioned (other than the zero)...what about the grumman hellcat? The corsair? and the P-38 lightning?

I think the kill ratio on the hellcat vs zeros was 4 - 1 or something like that and I seem to recall that there was only like 10 corsairs shot down in the air throughout the war....

But I believe the pilots (on both sides) would contend that the P-51D (with fuel injection) was THE premier fighter of it's time. Not only was it the fastest but when it got into a fight with the ME-262 it didn't lag much in the top speed department and was far more maneuverable. I also believe the twin 20MM cannons made it deadly......

As all these shows being "pro" american when discussing the planes, well, in WWII they did produce most of the best aircraft.....

Now as for the zero, it was a great plane but difficult to fly and early in the war it was the best aircraft but as stated on wikpedia, after the americans got production and R & D going, they produced planes that handled as good or better, had better firepower, were more powerful and were better armored.

Like the FW109, it could outturn most british and early american aircraft but it's rate of climb was pitiful. If you dove on a target you'd have to use that stored energy of altitude to climb back to a reasonable altitude after a dive......
 
ig-88 said:
For example, in the Korean War, even though the US F-86 Sabre was inferior to the Soviet Mig-15, the American pilots has superior training.

There is no way the Mig was superior to the Sabre. It has now been reported that the Mig's were actually piloted by Russian pilots, with considerable WW2 experience and their kill ratio was something like 20 to 1, if not higher! The Russians were suicidal not to get shot down in South Korea as this may have expanded the war. The Americans had pressurised suit, the Mig's did not, a huge advantage. Yes the Americans were well trained!

Most historians agree the Mustang was the best fighter of WW2. While being outstanding in all areas, its long range was the defining factor. I believe, when Gering (sp) saw them escorting bombers over Berlin, he knew the war was over. No other fighter could escort bombers from London to Berlin and return. The biggest downfall of the ME 109, was after leaving France, it could only fight over London for 15 minutes before having to return to France.
 
tboy said:
Now only the planes used in the ETO have been mentioned (other than the zero)...what about the grumman hellcat? The corsair? and the P-38 lightning?

But I believe the pilots (on both sides) would contend that the P-51D (with fuel injection) was THE premier fighter of it's time. Not only was it the fastest but when it got into a fight with the ME-262 it didn't lag much in the top speed department and was far more maneuverable. I also believe the twin 20MM cannons made it deadly
Of Allied WWII fighter aircraft I think the top three in no particular order were the Supermarine Spitfire, the North American P-51 and the Chance Vought F4U Corsair. Arguing which of the three was the best is somewhat like arguing about the ideal spouse. Of course Axis aircraft like the Me 262 were of an other category - fortunately they were only available in very small numbers before the war ended and were misused.
 
Last edited:
Most of the above went through many different variants through the War and some of the variants were more competitive with their contemporaries than others. The end of war Spit XIV was excellent. OTOH, the mid war Spit V was so useless that RAF Fighter Command almost ceased offensive ops because the FW190's were so superior that it verged on butchery.

As well, all the a/c had their good and bad points. For example, an aircraft with a large wing area has a large amount of drag and is thus slower than a small-winged a/c. OTOH, it turns far better. Or some a/c are optimized for high altitude (particularly USAAF planes), some for low altitude.

So....

Spitfire - usually competitive or better speed-wise than its German competitors. Good rate of turn. Great armament - gotta luv those twin 20mm Hispano-Suizas! Very short range, except for Mk VIII. Poor roll rate. Competitive at all altitudes. Probably the best all round.

Me-109. Generally competitive speed, except for the 109G-6 variant which was a dog vs other late '43 early '44 variants. Adequate, but not brilliant turn rate. Notably excellent acceleration, dive and climb rates. Decent armament. Good at all altitudes.

FW-190 - excellent speed. Incredible armament - FOUR 20mm's! Excellent roll rate. Low turn rate. Very tough. Bad high altitude performance until D-9 variant in late 44. Would rate along with Spit, up to 20,000 feet.

P-51. Ludicrously over-hyped by the very pro-US tv show. Best speed in WW2. Average armament, but since the USAAF wasn't shooting at bombers, it didn't matter. Lousy turn rate. Lousy roll rate. Incredible long range - which was its big selling point. Good at high altitudes. The TV show's low point (for me) was "informing" us that the P-51 could outmaneuvre a 109. It couldn't. Period.

Hellcat. Decent mid War design. Reliable. Faster and tougher than its opposition, the Zero. Effective in its time and place, but not an All Star. Later USN a/c, the Corsair was faster.

Zero - fragile. Slow. Incredibly maneuverable. If it got on your six, you could say "sayonara". Otherwise, do what the USN did: Stay high and fast and fight in tandem with your buddy and you'd kill the Zero 9 times out of ten.

P-47 Thunderbolt. Massive with a huge engine. Heavily armed. Totally unmaneuvrable below 20,000 feet. A killer above 20,000 where sheer horsepower was more vital than aerodynamic design. Fast at any altitude, your speed and the sheer bulk and toughness of the beast could keep you alive even on the deck. An interesting, but very extreme design.

Curtis P-40. Average-ish early War design. The Americans sold a lot of them to the Commonwealth where they were easy pickings for the Me-109's in the Desert. Lots of dead Aussies flew P-40's.... for a little while.

The series leaves out a lot of good planes, like the Ki-84 Hayate which could kill any USN or USAAF design at low level. Or the Russian Lavochkin-7, indisputably the best low-altitude killer of the War. (The Soviets liked their fighting down on the deck and were very, very good at it.)
 
The problem with this poll is you're comparing aircraft from different periods of the war. Obviously the Zero is inferior to the later US aircraft.

That being said, I picked the Me-109. It's comparable to the Spitfire and I've never seen anything that definitively puts one over the other. It's always either too close to call or one marginally better than the other. But the reason I picked it is because it's one of the few aircraft that was in production from the start of the war to the end and was effective throughout. It was one of the most produced aircraft of the war.

I love the Dogfight series but the American bias is almost unbearable. I did notice, however, that it wasn't as bad as it was in Season One. The show would be so much better if it showed American aircraft getting their ass kicked once in a while. A champion is so much grander if it can be shown that it's beatable. At times season one was almost unwatchable as it was just Americans kicking ass over and over ad nauseum, especially in the Vietnam/Korea episodes. Season two was much better (and I found it more interesting as well).

Another little gripe I have is the comparison table they do for the different aircraft. They always balance it out and they're never consistent in the criteria they pick (they always pick something that can be used to balance it out). I'd rather they stick to a set criteria or at least allow there to be an imbalance. In two seasons I think I've only ever seen one imbalance in the comparisons.
 
oagre said:
P-51. Ludicrously over-hyped by the very pro-US tv show. Best speed in WW2. Average armament, but since the USAAF wasn't shooting at bombers, it didn't matter. Lousy turn rate. Lousy roll rate. Incredible long range - which was its big selling point. Good at high altitudes.
However, extensively flown by the RAF, RCAF etc. . . and the RAF was largely responsible for it coming into production. Don't underestimate the importance of it's range - Generalfeldmarschall Göring is supposed to have said “When I saw Mustangs over Berlin, I knew it was all over.”
 
Aardvark154 said:
More perhaps than anyone else Air Chief Marshal Freeman was not only responsible for the procurement of the P-51 but also the Supermarine Spitfire and the De Havilland Mosquito.

Interesting fact about the De Havilland Mosquito;

In Canada, fuselages were built in the Oshawa, Ontario plant of General Motors of Canada Limited. These were shipped to De Havilland of Canada in Downsview for mating to fuselages and completion.
 
Mustangs where a more advanced fighter, but the spitfire won the war. The mustang had range and speed on its side. Nothing at the time had the finesse of the spitfire. Its THE classic fighter design. If you have ever seen one fly you will know what i mean. The car comparison would be: Mustang-81 Iroc commaro with a shaker on the hood. Spitfire-Lotus Exige
 
I can't really say which was the best , but from the list here are my fav's and in that order:

- German 109
- US Mustang P51
- US P47
- UK Spitfire

Off the list :

- UK DH Mosquito ( interesting shape, and guys , remember that war flick about the bouncing bombs )

- German Junkers 87 ( absolutely fugly )

At times season one was almost unwatchable as it was just Americans kicking ass over and over ad nauseum, especially in the Vietnam/Korea episodes.

Bias aside, I found that MiG Alley episode was pretty good.