dogfights - which was the best? PART 2

Best fighter - 50's and 60's

  • North American F-86 Sabre

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • MIG 15 "Fagot"

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • McDonnell Douglas F-4 Phantom

    Votes: 6 50.0%
  • Northrop F-5 Tiger

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • MIG 21 "Fishbed"

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Vought F-105 Thunderchief

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Republic F-8 Crusader

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Dassault Mirage 1

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • MIG 23 "Flogger"

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • MIG 25 "Foxbat"

    Votes: 2 16.7%

  • Total voters
    12

dj1470

Banned
Apr 7, 2005
7,701
0
0
Geez, great to see so many with the knowledge behind the aircraft. Personally I am learning a lot watching the show. I was always more into the tanks myself. Tiger vs. Sherman, Panther vs. T-34, etc, etc, etc. Thought it would be fun to leave the 30's and 40's and venture into the 50's and 60's since the show seems to go there as well. I know they are from different generations and technology but just looking for overall performance. For me it's the Phantom just on reputation alone.
 
Sorry but your poll is impossibly vague.
Mirage 1? (you mean F1? which may be operationally late)
The range and roles of aircraft is too large. There is quite a difference between early 50's and late 60's aircraft.
Also some of your choices are not fighters, but are attack aircraft.
 
Not another Michael Vick thread!?! :D
 
stang said:
Sorry but your poll is impossibly vague.
Mirage 1? (you mean F1? which may be operationally late)
The range and roles of aircraft is too large. There is quite a difference between early 50's and late 60's aircraft.
Also some of your choices are not fighters, but are attack aircraft.

So sorry. Just trying not to be bored. Just looking for some lively discussion. Next time I'll leave you alone. Sorry for being such a f**king idiot I didn't realize you were an expert.

I was just choosing the aircraft from the series. All were involved in dogfights at some point. As for the Dassault. I was referring to the first variant. Simply known as Mirage 1 on the series.

Again sorry for being an uneducated idiot.

You the man.
 
F-86/Mig-15: The Mig was more maneuverable and had bigger guns. But the Sabre was better armored. It's a toss-up between these two.

F-4: This was a widely used, versatile platform, used by both the Air Force and the Navy. This set the precedent for the modern fighters of the 80s and onward. However, pilots in Vietnam always complained that early models had no gun, which would prove essential in Vietnam because of the rules of engagement and the way in which the Vietnamese pilots would engage.

F-5: It's a fine plane, but never really caught on. It was originally designed for ground attack, but too small and underpowered for that. Eventually, the Navy uses them for Top Gun training. In the movie Top Gun, as most aviation buffs know, the "MiG-28s" are actually F-5s.

Mig-21: This was the Vietnamese counterpart to the F-4. By this time, while the Americans concentrated on larger, hi-tech, missile-carrying platforms, the Soviets were still sticking with maneuverable, tried-and-true technology.

F-105: This is not so much of a fighter, but more of a fighter bomber used by the USAF in the 'Nam. Something that could deliver bombs and possibly outrun SAMs.

F-8 Crusader: The predecessor to the A-7 Corsair II. A fighter bomber used by the Navy for fast, light bombing missions in the 'Nam.

Mirage F1: A French jet. Still used by the Iraqis in Gulf War I. A bit too modern for this poll.

Mig-23: The successor to the Mig-21. Also too modern for this poll. In the 80s, Libyan Mig-23s had a run-in with US Navy F-14s.

Mig-25: A high-speed interceptor developed by the Soviets to meet NATO attack, as well as show the West what technology the Soviets were capable of. The design of the MiG-25 led to the US F-15.

You should make a part 3 poll with the Mirage F1, Mig-23, and Mig-25, that are actually 70s, 80s, and early 90s aircraft.
 
The interesting thing I find about the Dogfights series is that enemies don't seem to be able to just swarm an enemy and overwhelm him with sheer numbers. In one of the episodes an American ace talks about how you can only have one enemy on your six at any time so being faced by 40 enemy aircraft wasn't as bad as it sounds.

I would have thought that swarming a great pilot with 40 mediocre ones would produce better results for the latter. But it doesn't appear so.
 
ig-88 said:
F-86/Mig-15: The Mig was more maneuverable and had bigger guns. But the Sabre was better armored. It's a toss-up between these two.

Then why was the kill ratio something like 50 to 1 for the Sabre against experienced Russian pilots?
 
You are really covering three decades the Mig-15 and the Sabre early 1950's while the Mig-23 and Mig-25 are really more 1980's aircraft. Therefore realistically it is impossible to compare them.

If you made me choose I'd opt for the F-4 Phantom II however, as has already been pointed out in a classic example of the problems that can be caused by 'group think' it originally didn't have a cannon. After all 'everyone knew' that there was no need for cannon in an age of air to air missiles that could be fired from miles away.

In some ways the Mig-21 although a lot less technologically sophisticated was a superior dogfighter and an inspiration for the F-16.
 
Last edited:
Keebler Elf said:
The interesting thing I find about the Dogfights series is that enemies don't seem to be able to just swarm an enemy and overwhelm him with sheer numbers. In one of the episodes an American ace talks about how you can only have one enemy on your six at any time so being faced by 40 enemy aircraft wasn't as bad as it sounds.

I saw that episode. What happened was they didn't know he was there and when he started to pick them off from behind, the group had no way of knowing it was just one guy. That's a distinct advantage and played a big part in it. And yes, like a man on a bridge, the 40 just get in eachother's way. If he had to fight all 40 or if they got the drop on him, he'd be dead.
 
Keebler Elf said:
The interesting thing I find about the Dogfights series is that enemies don't seem to be able to just swarm an enemy and overwhelm him with sheer numbers.
As Gospodin Ulyanov (a.k.a. V.I. Lenin) famously said “quantity has a quality all its own.”
 
ig-88 said:
F-5: It's a fine plane, but never really caught on. It was originally designed for ground attack, but too small and underpowered for that. Eventually, the Navy uses them for Top Gun training. In the movie Top Gun, as most aviation buffs know, the "MiG-28s" are actually F-5s.
The USAF T-38 Talon was and remains the worlds only supersonic trainer. The F-5 was developed from it, and although never used in frontline service by the USAF was used in frontline service by the CAF. As I recall the now defunct base in Chatham, New Brunswick flew F-5's (a.k.a. CF-116's).
 
Aardvark154 said:
You are really covering three decades the Mig-15 and the Sabre early 1950's while the Mig-23 and Mig-25 are really more 1980's aircraft. Therefore realistically it is impossible to compare them.

It's the Dogfights series as well as other sites like Janes (defence.janes.com) that group these 10 together among others. They were all either developed/prototyped in the 50's/60's or in active service. Just because some buttf**k coutnries like Libya still flew the MIG-25 in the 80's doesn't mean it wasn't around in the 60's.

EARLY JET FIGHTER AIRCRAFT

First generation (1945-1953)

Canada
Avro CF-100 Canuck
Germany
Heinkel He 280
Messerschmitt Me 262
Heinkel He 162
Arado Ar 234
Horten Ho 229
France
Dassault Ouragan
Dassault Mystère IV
Soviet Union
Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-9 'Fargo'
Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-15 'Fagot'
Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-17 'Fresco'
Yakovlev Yak-25 'Flashlight'
United Kingdom
Havilland Vampire
Gloster Meteor
United States
Lockheed P-80 Shooting Star
Republic F-84 Thunderjet
North American F-86 Sabre
Northrop F-89J Scorpion

Second generation (1953-1960)

Canada
Avro Arrow
France
Dassault Étendard IV
India
HAL HF-24 Marut
Sweden
Saab Draken
Soviet Union
Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-19 'Farmer'
Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-21 'Fishbed'
Sukhoi Su-7 'Fitter-A'
Sukhoi Su-9/11 'Fishpot'
United Kingdom
English Electric Lightning
De Havilland Sea Vixen
Gloster Javelin
Hawker Hunter
United States
Chance-Vought F-8 Crusader
Grumman F-11 Tiger
North American F-100 Super Sabre
Convair F-102 Delta Dagger
Lockheed F-104 Starfighter
Republic F-105 Thunderchief
Convair F-106 Delta Dart

Third generation (1960-1970)

France
Dassault Mirage F.1
Dassault Super Étendard
Iran
IAMI Azarakhsh
People's Republic of China
Shenyang J-8
Soviet Union
Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-23 'Flogger'
Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-25 'Foxbat'
Sukhoi Su-15 'Flagon'
Sukhoi Su-17 'Fitter'
Tupolev Tu-28 'Fiddler'
United States
McDonnell Douglas F-4 Phantom
North American F-101 VooDoo
Northrop F-5
 
hungry said:
Then why was the kill ratio something like 50 to 1 for the Sabre against experienced Russian pilots?

Also enjoying the show. Think the Sabre had radar targeting for the guns on a heads up display. Small technology advances would make a big difference in battle.
 
hungry said:
Then why was the kill ratio something like 50 to 1 for the Sabre against experienced Russian pilots?

It probably has something to do with the fact that you're crazy. There weren't enough Migs or Russian pilots for 50:1, you're the only person on the Earth to suggest 50:1, and you can't get solid numbers on pilots that "weren't there" anyway. Some credible sources (as credible as any) claim that Russian flown Migs came out on top by as much as 2:1, though this figure probably includes non-Sabre fighters.
 
cypherpunk said:
It probably has something to do with the fact that you're crazy. There weren't enough Migs or Russian pilots for 50:1, you're the only person on the Earth to suggest 50:1, and you can't get solid numbers on pilots that "weren't there" anyway. Some credible sources (as credible as any) claim that Russian flown Migs came out on top by as much as 2:1, though this figure probably includes non-Sabre fighters.

Agreed. I surprised to learn on the show that Russian pilots were actually in the Korean War secretly. American pilots called them "honchos". They were often the flight leaders of North Korean or Chinese squadrons and were quite noticeable by Sabre pilots in the way they flew. On the show many Sabre pilots said that they would not fight the "honchos" but take out the lesser experienced NK/Chinese pilots first and then dash. On the show the ratio of NK/Chinese flow MIG's shot down to Sabres was about 6:1 but in estimated dogfights with "honchos" it was about 1:1. Interesting the Soviets were there to apparently get experience with American technology and tactics to prepare for the upcoming WW3 that a lot of people thought was inevitable.
 
I'll just go with the list...

And again I'll simply pick my fav's

MiG 25 - more a 70's jet but what the heck.I was never that much into jet fighters then until one of that flew and landed in Tokyo back in the 70's and totally peaked my attention.

Mirage 1
F-4 Phantom
MiG 15 - those little shit did some damage initially during Korean War.