Does speed really kill...?

kono

Member
May 19, 2009
523
0
16
The media and the cops sure seem to think so. Distracted pedestrians and drivers is what's to blame. And occasionally driver's who are under the influence. Braking technology has come a long was since 1950's. If a driver is alert and paying attention to the road you would almost eliminate accidents altogether.
Lowering speed limit will only increase the rate of accidents. This has been proven by numerous studies. Look at Europe for instance (excluding the UK). It's well known and documented that they have very few accidents. And their speed limits are considerably higher then ours. We have some of the lowest speed limit in the developed world. This seems like a recurring thing for Canadians. Cell phone, cable, internet service are also some of the highest in the developed world. :D

Here's a very well done video RE: speed limits in Canada. Backed up by actual news coverage. It really makes police officers look stupid.


What are your thoughts guys?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
With all due respect, this is the most moronic thing I've read here in some time. All of the "if only"s you list will never happen... People drive like idiots. They text, do their hair, scratch their asses, read, mess with tunes, talk on the phone, light cigarettes, eat and every other effing thing. Shit, most people can barely stay between the lines much of the time.

Add "speed" and the the number of accidents increases. The severity of accidents increases.

Although, much like falling from high places, technically "speed" doesn't kill... It just multiplies the number of severity of the "sudden stops" at the end...

I'm not really sure what the video has to do with anything.... some idiot complaining about speed limits. I've never heard of anyone getting a speeding ticket for driving with "the flow".
 
I am not sure. Most doing studies of any kind have agendas, or don't understand how to do studies well. For example, I doubt most of us would disagree that if there is a collision, faster moving vehicles would usually suffer more damage.

Anecdotal experience is questionable. Mine is that more confident and better drivers tend to drive a bit faster. If I am in the passenger seat, I would prefer such a driver. But if they get beyond that, then there can be a problem. The best driver in the world is still dangerous at too high a speed.

In the meantime, please don't be one of those that zoom up my residential street at 30 above the limit. there are kids, cats and others that we cherish :)

z
 
With all due respect, this is the most moronic thing I've read here in some time. All of the "if only"s you list will never happen... People drive like idiots. They text, do their hair, scratch their asses, read, mess with tunes, talk on the phone, light cigarettes, eat and every other effing thing. Shit, most people can barely stay between the lines much of the time.

Add "speed" and the the number of accidents increases. The severity of accidents increases.

Although, much like falling from high places, technically "speed" doesn't kill... It just multiplies the number of severity of the "sudden stops" at the end...

I'm not really sure what the video has to do with anything.... some idiot complaining about speed limits. I've never heard of anyone getting a speeding ticket for driving with "the flow".

I know it's wishful thinking to think that you can eliminate distractions on the road. The point is, that's what's really causing most / if not all accidents on the road today.
Lowering speed limits only frustrates / anger drivers. Does it not? It only adds to the problem. More and more speeding tickets (extortion).
How would you feel if they reduce speed limits to 40km nation wide excluding highways? Because that's the direction we're heading whether you like it or not.
There's already been talk about it.
 
I am not sure. Most doing studies of any kind have agendas, or don't understand how to do studies well. For example, I doubt most of us would disagree that if there is a collision, faster moving vehicles would usually suffer more damage.

Anecdotal experience is questionable. Mine is that more confident and better drivers tend to drive a bit faster. If I am in the passenger seat, I would prefer such a driver. But if they get beyond that, then there can be a problem. The best driver in the world is still dangerous at too high a speed.

In the meantime, please don't be one of those that zoom up my residential street at 30 above the limit. there are kids, cats and others that we cherish :)

z

I'm not talking about excessive speed increases here. Speed limits should take into account the average braking distance of the average car of today. Not archaic car technology of the 50's. Which the current speed limits are based on.


Doesn't seem like anyone watched the video I posted I guess......?
 
Way over-broad a question. Does traveling say 45 km/h over the speed limit on say the 401 pose a great threat in light traffic in the day with a dry road - probably not. Then again does going 45 km/h over the speed limit on a winding rural road with tight turns pose a great threat - you better believe it does.


The video, however, does make some good points.
 
Last edited:
I'm not talking about excessive speed increases here. Speed limits should take into account the average braking distance of the average car of today. Not archaic car technology of the 50's. Which the current speed limits are based on.

Doesn't seem like anyone watched the video I posted I guess......?

Human reaction time, not braking technology, is the issue. And yeah, speed does kill, there are simple physics here, the faster you are traveling, the less survivable an impact. Even with airbags and seatbelts the impact forces become radically more lethal with speed.

But here is the way to implement your proposal: you say with various improvement we can eliminate accidents almost entirely therefore we can raise the limits.

Ok. So let's do that: once accidents have been virtually eliminated I agree we can raise the speed limits! However, I was on the road yesterday and I am sad to say passed two bad accident scenes on just one two hour drive. One a total wreck and the other a three car pileup, with one car upside down and totalled.

We aren't ready to raise the limits yet.
 
Speed is not the culprit... (case in point- German autobahn's...)

Speed variance is the real problem. (i.e. a slow guy in the fast lane... people have to slow down, move around to pass, change lanes etc... and THAT'S when problems start...)
 
I think one of the biggest dangers on our roads is the amount of people who are clearly not comfortable driving on 400 series highways yet they're still utilizing them. Merging onto these highways is a risky business when the driver in front of you does not realize that they should be at least matching speeds to the flow of traffic.
 
Speed is not the culprit... (case in point- German autobahn's...)

Speed variance is the real problem. (i.e. a slow guy in the fast lane... people have to slow down, move around to pass, change lanes etc... and THAT'S when problems start...)

Quite honestly idiots are the problem. Slow vehicles are not a problem if they stay right and overtaking vehicles behave sensibly.

But that is not what happens.

The overtakers do not slow down and pass safely. They come flying up and swerve from lane to lane half the time with no signal. The slow driver isn't the problem there.

Passing a vehicle in a right lane while you drive by in the left is extremely safe. Swerving from lane to lane to go around other cars, cutting two meters in front of them is not.
 
Quite honestly idiots are the problem. Slow vehicles are not a problem if they stay right and overtaking vehicles behave sensibly.

But that is not what happens.

The overtakers do not slow down and pass safely. They come flying up and swerve from lane to lane half the time with no signal. The slow driver isn't the problem there.

Passing a vehicle in a right lane while you drive by in the left is extremely safe. Swerving from lane to lane to go around other cars, cutting two meters in front of them is not.


Isn't a slow moving vehicle in the left lane a problem then?

The real problem is the rise in population of the GTA in the last 20 years and the only major highway built is an obscenely expensive toll road.
 
Human reaction time, not braking technology, is the issue. And yeah, speed does kill, there are simple physics here, the faster you are traveling, the less survivable an impact. Even with airbags and seatbelts the impact forces become radically more lethal with speed.

But here is the way to implement your proposal: you say with various improvement we can eliminate accidents almost entirely therefore we can raise the limits.

Ok. So let's do that: once accidents have been virtually eliminated I agree we can raise the speed limits! However, I was on the road yesterday and I am sad to say passed two bad accident scenes on just one two hour drive. One a total wreck and the other a three car pileup, with one I'd the cars upside down and totalled.

We aren't ready to raise the limits yet.

Even when you take into account the average reaction time the limit's are still to low.
I'm not talking about excessively rising the limit. 10 - 20km depending on the area.

That accident you speak of, what was the cause? And by "cause", I don't mean twisted medias facts. The person driving that car could have easily been doing the speed limit. He takes his eyes off the road to read a txt. Bang, you have your accident.
- The primary cause of the accident.... More then likely, distracted driving
- Secondary cause whether he was doing the speed limit or not, was speed

I probably should have clarified what I was trying to get at here. PRIMARY CAUSE OF ACCIDENTS - more then likely isn't speed. Rather, distracted driving or a distracted pedestrian.
 
The Bear has driven many times on the Auto Strada in Italy. The Auto Strada is a massive highway system covering most of Italy. Have seen very few accidents while driving on it. I thought Italian drivers were out of their minds when I first drove in Italy. However it took me two trips there to understand they are excellent drivers. Going 160KPH is normal on the Auto Strada going faster is not out of the norm. The Auto Strada is designed for high speed. I feel safer on the Auto Strada doing 160-220KPH than doing 100KPH on our 400 series highways.
 
Quite honestly idiots are the problem. Slow vehicles are not a problem if they stay right and overtaking vehicles behave sensibly.

But that is not what happens.

The overtakers do not slow down and pass safely. They come flying up and swerve from lane to lane half the time with no signal. The slow driver isn't the problem there.

Passing a vehicle in a right lane while you drive by in the left is extremely safe. Swerving from lane to lane to go around other cars, cutting two meters in front of them is not.

The slow driver most certainly IS the start of the problem. If he/she wasn't in the "fast lane" to begin with the overtaker would not have to do anything. (the fact that the overtaker is an idiot as well, is another matter entirely...)
 
Isn't a slow moving vehicle in the left lane a problem then?

A minor problem, it is an inconvenience to others, not a safety issue. The safety problem is caused by the individuals who decide that crazy swerving is the appropriate response to a slower vehicle in front. Honking if the slow car doesn't eventually move right would be a better response.

In my experience the slow vehicles do eventually change lanes if you wait a minute or two. If they don't there is always a safer way to pass them than the swerving maneuvers most speeding drivers pull.

Upgrading a minor inconvenience into a major safety issue is the fault of the speeders who swerve around them.
 
That accident you speak of, what was the cause? And by "cause", I don't mean twisted medias facts. The person driving that car could have easily been doing the speed limit. He takes his eyes off the road to read a txt. Bang, you have your accident.

Until we solve these other problems, like distracted driving, it is obvious the speeds we have today are too fast for the drivers we actually have on our roads, and should be lowered.

At slower speeds distracted drivers and others around them have more time to react to these errors.

Speed magnifies the other problems.
 
fucking nonsense

Of course you can't explain why. It is very obvious that a distracted driver has a better chance to recover at a slower speed. Similarly others around him.

If we had better quality drivers we could have faster limits. But the drivers on our roads aren't good enough even for the speeds we have.