Does anyone out there use "Google Cloud" as their network / email ?

james t kirk

Well-known member
Aug 17, 2001
24,059
4,068
113
In recent discussions at the employ, we were dicussing our computer system, means of improving, etc. etc.

It has been suggested, then recommended, that we switch to Google Cloud. We had a bit of a presentation and I must say, parts of it seem intriguing, but it is a huge departure for most of us as we have all "grown up" in a windows environment / conventional network.

Google cloud basically means that you are storing your information on "the internet" and you can access your network from anywhere in the world if you can get on line.

Cool.

Well, sort of.

But everything is completely different, yet seemingly the same.

Obviously if it takes off, Microsoft will be killed off.


I'm wondering if anyone out there in the peanut gallery has made the switch to Google Cloud, or any other cloud system and what you think of it?

What are the disadvantages?

Advantages?
 
As much as I love the internet and technology, this whole cloud idea seems to be given a lot more stature than it deserves. Ok, maybe once there's 100% internet penetration everywhere it will be viable, but that's not the case nor will it be any time soon. Why would I want to have to deal with my important documents or even my favourite music when it requires me to have an internet connection? What if I need access when I'm on a plane, in a subway, on a cruise ship? What if there's a power cut and your laptop is working but nothing else is? What if your ISP is down? How can you be sure of the security of your data? Who has access to that data? Do they have reliable backups?

Where "cloud computing" does make sense is on an internal intranet setting with main server hooked up to a bunch of what are essentially dumb terminals. Internet based cloud computing is fucking stupid IMO.
 
As much as I love the internet and technology, this whole cloud idea seems to be given a lot more stature than it deserves. Ok, maybe once there's 100% internet penetration everywhere it will be viable, but that's not the case nor will it be any time soon. Why would I want to have to deal with my important documents or even my favourite music when it requires me to have an internet connection? What if I need access when I'm on a plane, in a subway, on a cruise ship? What if there's a power cut and your laptop is working but nothing else is? What if your ISP is down? How can you be sure of the security of your data? Who has access to that data? Do they have reliable backups?

Where "cloud computing" does make sense is on an internal intranet setting with main server hooked up to a bunch of what are essentially dumb terminals. Internet based cloud computing is fucking stupid IMO.
What happens is that you continue working on the documents on your laptop and then sync up with the cloud when the connection is restored.

Do you really think Google didn't think about this?!
 
It'd be very useful. It sounds similar to what Dropbox.com does and I've used that before. Not sure I'd want to store very important files someplace on the internet though. You just know hackers are going to find ways to undermine its security from time to time.
 
They say that "cloud computing" will be the next big thing.

I don't want to sound negative however I don't want my personal info to be "on the cloud".

Believe it or not, my internet presence is almost zero except for 2 dead end links.

Just not comfortable with the whole idea.
+1 !!!

They claim everything is secure and encrypted but there is always some sort of 'backdoor' available.

Just not comfortable yet in putting important personal stuff on the cloud....:eyebrows:
 
It is not a big departure from Windows... I do not see it being that much different than using anExchange Server with OWA

Costs are much lower.

AFAIK, you need to pay for the Exchange Server licensing plus for licensing for every desktop to run Outlook.

This is on top of Windows Server, the hardware and any administration support.

http://www.microsoft.com/exchange/en-us/licensing-exchange-server-email.aspx

I'm talking about hosting the Exchange solution within the company. MS offers their own cloud services, too. I'd recommend evaluating both (and I'm sure Mr. Kirk will).

I wonder how big the company in question is and details on the workflow (ex. how are documents shared? is there collaboration? any telecommuting? mobile workers in the field?).
 
Documents are shared, yes.

Definitely we have multiple people editing the same document - which Google cloud allows you to do.

Yes, we have people working all over Canada - hence a HUGE advantage that the "network" so called is now full accessable quickly and easily to all. Our existing network is accessable as well, but unless you are at head office, it's fucking complicated, slow, unpredictable and a collosal pain in the ass with all kinds of shitty software that never does its job and constantly involves calls to our IT contractor (who is another collosal pain in the ass)

From a network point of view, I can see it being hugely useful to us.

I'm not really THAT worried about security as we are not dealing in military secrets, nor are we the Royal Bank. I suppose the competition would love to hack our network, but they aren't that sophisticated.

The PAINS that I see are:

1. The email sucks compared to Outlook (it operates very differently than how I have been operating for the last 15 years.) Though it does allow you to catalogue your emails using labels and store multiple copies of emails (via the labels) In reality, all emails are stored in "Mail" and you just save a label wherever you want. (Unlike Outlook where each email is a separate file that you can catalogue and store how you like.)

2. Existing word, excel, autoCAD files etc. are not compatible (despite what google tells you) with the software that comes with it.


Currently, Google is leading the way in Cloud technology. Microsoft is also getting into the cloud business, however, according to the "Google guy" they are light years behind (and he seems to take great pleasure in this too). Even Amazon.com is offering cloud services. (Apple too, but so far, they are just getting into it.) So google is invested in it in a big way. Mr. Google guy seems to think that MS is going to die a slow protracted death as they aren't even close.

Google has the search engine, the cloud, Android - all of which ties together.

MS has Windows technology from 15 years ago that still is DOS at its heart, a shitty search engine (BING = Boy It's Not Google) that no-one uses and no smart phone at all.
 
Bottom line: Until internet access speed = hard drive access speed, "cloud computing" will be at a disadvantage.

And that still doesn't take into account other factors related to internet access, such as having to log onto wifi, or trying to get a cell signal in some locations.

And "cloud computing" is just another industry buzz term. There is no "Google Cloud". There's online storage of files, and online apps, with Google being one of the leading providers of these services.
 
Documents are shared, yes.

Definitely we have multiple people editing the same document - which Google cloud allows you to do.

Yes, we have people working all over Canada - hence a HUGE advantage that the "network" so called is now full accessable quickly and easily to all. Our existing network is accessable as well, but unless you are at head office, it's fucking complicated, slow, unpredictable and a collosal pain in the ass with all kinds of shitty software that never does its job and constantly involves calls to our IT contractor (who is another collosal pain in the ass)

From a network point of view, I can see it being hugely useful to us.

I'm not really THAT worried about security as we are not dealing in military secrets, nor are we the Royal Bank. I suppose the competition would love to hack our network, but they aren't that sophisticated.

The PAINS that I see are:

1. The email sucks compared to Outlook (it operates very differently than how I have been operating for the last 15 years.) Though it does allow you to catalogue your emails using labels and store multiple copies of emails (via the labels) In reality, all emails are stored in "Mail" and you just save a label wherever you want. (Unlike Outlook where each email is a separate file that you can catalogue and store how you like.)

2. Existing word, excel, autoCAD files etc. are not compatible (despite what google tells you) with the software that comes with it.


Currently, Google is leading the way in Cloud technology. Microsoft is also getting into the cloud business, however, according to the "Google guy" they are light years behind (and he seems to take great pleasure in this too). Even Amazon.com is offering cloud services. (Apple too, but so far, they are just getting into it.) So google is invested in it in a big way. Mr. Google guy seems to think that MS is going to die a slow protracted death as they aren't even close.

Google has the search engine, the cloud, Android - all of which ties together.

MS has Windows technology from 15 years ago that still is DOS at its heart, a shitty search engine (BING = Boy It's Not Google) that no-one uses and no smart phone at all.

I also have the same question as I have a database created by access that I would also like to convert to an online database. I was told that this web hosting company may be a fit http://accesshosting.com/ but don't want to spend the money without knowing how effective it is first. On another note access host does provide a free trial though so it may be to your benefit