Does anyone believe that Al-Ahli Arab Hospital was hit by the HAMAs?
- Thread starter dirtydaveiii
- Start date
Was the hospital in the area ordered by Israel to evacuate ? If so why were there civilians there ? In urban warfare you must attack civilian locations which will result in civilian casualties. There is no other way to counter attack.
Isn't the source of the article the same fake news and corrupt government that lies to get trump ?
Please provide proof of this claim that doesn't come from the IDF.
Explain how this is happening if Israel is only targeting Hamas.
70 percent of killed in Gaza are women, children, elderly: Ministry
80 percent of Gaza burns victims are children, but no dressings available: Doctor
Explain this.
Israeli army warns anyone refusing to leave Gaza City will be considered a ‘terrorist’
Private homes can be ‘legitimate’ targets: Israel military
This is an excuse for Nakba 2.0, the ethnic cleansing of Gaza.
When it comes to attacks on civilians, HAMAS can dish it out, but they can't take it...
you do not understand. Of course they knew. The entire point was to provoke Israel. They exploit death and destruction to fan the flames of hate against Israel and Jews.
When it comes to Palestinians, its genocide.
A Textbook Case of Genocide
Israel has been explicit about what it’s carrying out in Gaza. Why isn’t the world listening?
Wow. I’m impressed that people like Frankfooter can be so delusional. Wrong every single time. Promote lies and ignore all facts. It is indeed impressive.
I'm sure Franky will say something about Jewish control of the media but AP's analysis agrees with every other analysis that a failed rocket is by far the most likely cause.
apnews.com
But they use the Al Jazeera video that Frank claims doesn't exist.
The AP reached its conclusion by reviewing more than a dozen videos from news broadcasts, security cameras and social media posts, and matching the locations to satellite imagery and photos from before the explosion.
A key video in the analysis came shortly before 7 p.m. local time, when the Arabic-language news channel Al Jazeera was airing live coverage of the Gaza City skyline. As a correspondent speaks, the camera pans to zoom in on a volley of rockets being fired from the ground nearby.
...
AP photos taken the morning after Tuesday’s explosion showed no evidence of a large crater at the impact site that would be consistent with a bomb like those dropped by Israeli aircraft in other recent strikes. The hospital buildings surrounding the outdoor area at the center of the explosion were still standing and did not appear to suffer significant structural damage.
A small crater photographed in the hospital’s parking lot appeared to be about a meter across, suggesting a device with a much smaller explosive payload than a bomb. While Israel’s extensive arsenal includes smaller missiles that can be fired from helicopters and drones, there has been no public evidence of such missile strikes in the area around the al-Ahli Arab Hospital on Tuesday night.
New AP analysis of last month's deadly Gaza hospital explosion rules out widely cited video
The Associated Press is publishing an updated visual analysis of the deadly Oct. 17 explosion at Gaza’s Al-Ahli Hospital.
apnews.com
But they use the Al Jazeera video that Frank claims doesn't exist.
The AP reached its conclusion by reviewing more than a dozen videos from news broadcasts, security cameras and social media posts, and matching the locations to satellite imagery and photos from before the explosion.
A key video in the analysis came shortly before 7 p.m. local time, when the Arabic-language news channel Al Jazeera was airing live coverage of the Gaza City skyline. As a correspondent speaks, the camera pans to zoom in on a volley of rockets being fired from the ground nearby.
...
AP photos taken the morning after Tuesday’s explosion showed no evidence of a large crater at the impact site that would be consistent with a bomb like those dropped by Israeli aircraft in other recent strikes. The hospital buildings surrounding the outdoor area at the center of the explosion were still standing and did not appear to suffer significant structural damage.
A small crater photographed in the hospital’s parking lot appeared to be about a meter across, suggesting a device with a much smaller explosive payload than a bomb. While Israel’s extensive arsenal includes smaller missiles that can be fired from helicopters and drones, there has been no public evidence of such missile strikes in the area around the al-Ahli Arab Hospital on Tuesday night.
So are you now going to condemn the Palestinian faction that launched the rocket?
...you hate Israel and need to find a way to blame the Jews for everything, including Hamas war crimes and crimes against humanity.
Wait, are you now trying to claim that Kautilia is really and Israeli and all his
And you think Butt and younger are Israelis too? Is everyone who disagrees with you a secret Jew? As I said, you really need to take a mental health break.
The numbers have varied. Franky claimed 800, Hamas claimed 500, other estimates are 100-300 which could be accurate based on the burst from blazing propellant seen in the videos.
Frank will claims that's Jewish propaganda no matter what Hamas actually says.
Mashaal: Hamas ‘well aware of consequences’ of attack, liberation demands ‘sacrifices’
Questioned by critical Saudi interviewer citing 'Hamas transgressions against Israeli civilians,' terror group's former leader falsely claims it doesn't target non-combatants
www.timesofisrael.com
None of the reports are conclusive, basketcase. All say they can't tell for sure.I'm sure Franky will say something about Jewish control of the media but AP's analysis agrees with every other analysis that a failed rocket is by far the most likely cause.
New AP analysis of last month's deadly Gaza hospital explosion rules out widely cited video
The Associated Press is publishing an updated visual analysis of the deadly Oct. 17 explosion at Gaza’s Al-Ahli Hospital.
But they use the Al Jazeera video that Frank claims doesn't exist.
The AP reached its conclusion by reviewing more than a dozen videos from news broadcasts, security cameras and social media posts, and matching the locations to satellite imagery and photos from before the explosion.
A key video in the analysis came shortly before 7 p.m. local time, when the Arabic-language news channel Al Jazeera was airing live coverage of the Gaza City skyline. As a correspondent speaks, the camera pans to zoom in on a volley of rockets being fired from the ground nearby.
...
AP photos taken the morning after Tuesday’s explosion showed no evidence of a large crater at the impact site that would be consistent with a bomb like those dropped by Israeli aircraft in other recent strikes. The hospital buildings surrounding the outdoor area at the center of the explosion were still standing and did not appear to suffer significant structural damage.
A small crater photographed in the hospital’s parking lot appeared to be about a meter across, suggesting a device with a much smaller explosive payload than a bomb. While Israel’s extensive arsenal includes smaller missiles that can be fired from helicopters and drones, there has been no public evidence of such missile strikes in the area around the al-Ahli Arab Hospital on Tuesday night.
So I'm going with the multiple reports from the hospital that Israel hit it the day before with two warning shells and then warned the hospital.
Do I need to post the FB posts from the day before stating that doctors were injured by Israeli shells?
The US says lower numbers and they also say they are against anyone investigating.
Of course, since it was likely their weapons that were fired they want to block it.
Yet you claim to be 100% sure that Israel did it even though every analysis says an high or extremely high probability its was a failed Gaza rocket.
You excuses are getting dumber every day. Do you really think that FB and tweets are more reliable than full video and image analysis by experts?
BTW. Are you still denying that Al Jazeera filmed the whole thing?
It has happened in all the wars, the rockets fall down in Gaza and then hamas decries it was Israeli strike. The picture show damage to the parking lot, some glass from the windows of the hospital and that's it. There was no 500 dead and it was Ham asses fault.
Footage shows: Failed rocket launches fall within Gaza
IDF source confirms: 550 failed launches fell inside Gaza since the start of Hamas' war with Israel two weeks ago.
Since the beginning of the war, the IDF has identified about 550 failed launches that fell inside Gaza, an IDF source said.
According to the IDF, "The Hamas terrorist organization uses the residents of the Gaza Strip as human shields, and launches rockets from civilian infrastructure, areas and buildings in the Gaza Strip."
"Since the beginning of the war, the IDF has identified about 550 failed launches fired by Hamas that landed inside the Gaza Strip."
Earlier this week, Hamas claimed that Israel attacked a Gaza hospital, killing hundreds of civilians.
The claim was later debunked, by footage and other evidence proving that the blast had been caused by a misfired Islamic Jihad rocket which fell in the hospital parking lot, and not by an Israeli airstrike.
www.israelnationalnews.com
Footage shows: Failed rocket launches fall within Gaza
IDF source confirms: 550 failed launches fell inside Gaza since the start of Hamas' war with Israel two weeks ago.
Since the beginning of the war, the IDF has identified about 550 failed launches that fell inside Gaza, an IDF source said.
According to the IDF, "The Hamas terrorist organization uses the residents of the Gaza Strip as human shields, and launches rockets from civilian infrastructure, areas and buildings in the Gaza Strip."
"Since the beginning of the war, the IDF has identified about 550 failed launches fired by Hamas that landed inside the Gaza Strip."
Earlier this week, Hamas claimed that Israel attacked a Gaza hospital, killing hundreds of civilians.
The claim was later debunked, by footage and other evidence proving that the blast had been caused by a misfired Islamic Jihad rocket which fell in the hospital parking lot, and not by an Israeli airstrike.
Footage shows: Failed rocket launches fall within Gaza
IDF source confirms: 550 failed launches fell inside Gaza since the start of Hamas' war with Israel two weeks ago.
www.israelnationalnews.com
It's like the evidence for that assassination in BC. If they told you they would have to kill you. Facts surrounding the missile strike exist and will come out eventually. So far, it's all speculation...
