Do those Brita filter water pitchers work?

rafterman

A sadder and a wiser man
Feb 15, 2004
3,504
101
63
I know what refined and sensitive palates TERB members have. Just wondering if there is any noticeable difference between plain tap water and filtered water or are there any other brands that are recommended.
 
I have used a PUR filter on my tap for years and do notice the difference
 
Had one for years... yes they do make a difference. Now I have a system from Rainsoft attached to my sink so I don't have to remember to refill the Brita pitcher and only have to change the filters every couple years.
 
Rather depends on your palate, don't you think? In high summer when TO sometimes ups its chlorine because of algae bloom, a filtered pitcher got rid of the chlorine smell. But so did letting a pitcher stand for a half-hour or so. Rest of the time we don't notice the chlorine, so after a coupla years of using it for the coffee and changing filters every four months, we've consigned the pitcher to this year's yard sale pile.

Your taste may vary.
 
I have an electric hot water kettle. I have notice that by using the PUR filtered water I have no mineral buildup in the pot.

Take it for what it is worth but that does show it cleans the water.
 
I use the Brita water pitcher and I love it. The only thing I'd do differently is buy the larger pitcher because I can only get two large glasses of water out of the slim version so I'm constantly refilling.

I used to drink bottled water and now I've almost completely switched over. Better for the environment and the water tastes cold and fresh.
 
I use the Brita water pitcher and I love it. The only thing I'd do differently is buy the larger pitcher because I can only get two large glasses of water out of the slim version so I'm constantly refilling.

I used to drink bottled water and now I've almost completely switched over. Better for the environment and the water tastes cold and fresh.

I bought a Brita pitcher when they first came out.

Loved the water but hated the time it took to filter. That was the primary reason I went to a PUR tap filter.
 
I have an electric hot water kettle. I have notice that by using the PUR filtered water I have no mineral buildup in the pot.

Take it for what it is worth but that does show it cleans the water.

Impossible.

The calcium is disolved in the water. A filter cannot remove contaminates in solution, all they can do is remove particles. If you want to remove chemicals in solution, you have to use other chemicals to react (or precipitate) them out. That's how come water softeners use salt. The cl ions react with the Fe ions in solution to form a precipitate (FeCl which is a solid) which is flushed out of the system.

Eg. if you disolve sugar in water, you cannot remove it with a filter, or salt for that matter. Usually, you have to boil the water off leaving the contaminate.

Brita filters only remove particles from the water.
 
Works ok initially, taste is different. Couple of weeks can't tell the difference. I just go to nimbus water and get reverse osmosis water $1.80 for 3 gallons..tastes great.
 
Impossible.

The calcium is disolved in the water. A filter cannot remove contaminates in solution, all they can do is remove particles. If you want to remove chemicals in solution, you have to use other chemicals to react (or precipitate) them out. That's how come water softeners use salt. The cl ions react with the Fe ions in solution to form a precipitate (FeCl which is a solid) which is flushed out of the system.

Eg. if you disolve sugar in water, you cannot remove it with a filter, or salt for that matter. Usually, you have to boil the water off leaving the contaminate.

Brita filters only remove particles from the water.

Only partially correct.... While it is true that a filter cannot remove dissolved substances, it is untrue that Britas are only filters. The filter actually consists of two parts in addition to the physical filter:

1. The activated carbon filter eliminates bad odor and the taste of halogen compounds that chlorine makes when present in tap water.
2. The exchange ion resin lowers the concentration of calcium carbonates, accordingly softening tap water.
 
I know what refined and sensitive palates TERB members have. Just wondering if there is any noticeable difference between plain tap water and filtered water or are there any other brands that are recommended.

The Brita water pitchers work amazing for the company that sells them. LOL..

As some have said it depends on your taste. I had one a long time ago, but I could not be bothered refilling them everytime it ran out.
 
Only partially correct.... While it is true that a filter cannot remove dissolved substances, it is untrue that Britas are only filters. The filter actually consists of two parts in addition to the physical filter:

1. The activated carbon filter eliminates bad odor and the taste of halogen compounds that chlorine makes when present in tap water.
2. The exchange ion resin lowers the concentration of calcium carbonates, accordingly softening tap water.

I don't really know the engineering behind the Brita filter to be honest, however even a charcoal filter will not removed Cl ions in solution. In truth, Cl will flash off on its own.

I'm sure there's a lot of particulate matter in tap water (not the least of which is simply rust from old cast iron watermains - though since human blood is based on iron, drinking some rust isn't going to hurt you) and the Brita may work to remove those particles suspended in the water.

I often wonder about the various organic compounds in the water to start with, as well as the compounds PVC watermain is made of.
 
For those who don't like waiting very long for the water to refill there is also the Clear2O that hooks up directly to the tap.

http://coffeetea.about.com/od/water/gr/clear2o.htm

First saw these on the shopping channel at some ridiculous price but then saw them at Oceans(an Asian store in Brampton) for $10 and think they are now $5. Replacement filters like all other systems are expensive though.

Like with gillette razors, these companies don't make much on the initial pitcher and filter but they make a killing on the the subsequent purchases of filters.

We have relatively clean water leaving the processing plants in Toronto but the quality may diminish once it gets to your home depending on the type of pipelines in the your area and how old they are for example some areas still have lead pipes in the older houses so water filter system may be beneficial.

In places like Kingston where the water has a boiled chicken type smell and taste again it may be useful for the squirmish.
 
I used to have a waterwise countertop distiller. Lasted about 5 years, made about 4 litres of water a cycle which was about all I needed. Great at purifying the water and making it taste and smell fantastic once chilled. Best $300 I ever spent, but a little bit of a hassle to clean it out and refill it once a day - usually took about 5 minutes. I'm thinking of going to Sears to see if they sell personal water distillers.
 
I have used both the Brita filter water and PUR filter system for your tap. I think the PUR filter system is more convenient over Brita pitchers.
 
I notice it less in Toronto but in Ottawa where the water has a swampy river taste, the Brita charcoal improvest the flavour.