Do People Have Free Will?

stinkynuts

Super
Jan 4, 2005
8,939
3,220
113
Sometimes I feel like I am just a passive pawn in life, and that God is controlling my destiny. Do you think we have free will and are actually making choices, or are we just reacting to circumstances, and have no choice in what we do?

Discuss.
 
Well, if you decide to simply be reactive instead of proactive, then yes, you are directed by circumstance.

From the moment we are born we are faced with choices. It is up to us to either choose a path, or not choose a path. Either way you've still made a choice.

On the other hand, if you react to all the various media inputs we are inundated with everyday, you are simply a pawn of big business. THey tell you what to buy, what you need and what you should have.

To answer your question a little more specifically: To really be "free" I guess you could say to exercise free will is to proceed along your chosen path no matter what circumstances are placed before you. For eg: a kid who grows up in a low income household decides to be a doctor/nurse/electrician. In our society if you want something bad enough, you can get it (for the most part).
 
Sure I believe we have free will but then every time I hear a bell I have this overwhelming urge to feed my dog.
- Pavlov -
 
I love how on Terb, there is the potential for a discussion on free will to peacefully coexist with queries about teabagging.
 
Hey we are a community of diverse individuals, and your analogy just highlights that lol
 
I can understand the feeling of being a pawn. There are so many rules and laws in our society that we are almost forced to go in the same direction as all the other pawns, straight to the end of the board one step at a time. Want to move left or right? Try saying you're a communist or a fascist or that you support al qaida. You'll learn pretty quick that being different is bad. Sure we have free will, as long as we make the choice that is 'acceptable'.
 
tboy said:
From the moment we are born we are faced with choices.

It may seem like we have choices, but we don't.

We come into this world crying, not because we choose to but because crying is a biological reaction. We don't choose to be hungry, sleepy, or horny. But when we experience these feelings, we seek food, sleep, or sex.

We don't choose to fall in love, it's the emotion thrust upon us by an invisible force that wants us to procreate. We have no choice but to work in order to survive, and we have no choice but to go to school so that we can get a good job.

In the end all of our actions seem to be driven by needs we have no control over. We are all marching through life like pawns.

I strongly believe that the mass murders of Charles Manson and the scientific achievements of Einstein were the result of the same force ... call it God if you like. They, like us, had no choice in what they would do, they were mere puppets being controlled by the Puppeteer. Events like the Holocaust were meant to happen. Hitler was merely the chosen agent who brought about God's plan. He had no choice.
 
Either that or help somone with his school essay.

spatial_k said:
I love how on Terb, there is the potential for a discussion on free will to peacefully coexist with queries about teabagging.
 
Yes there are two paths

If there's a bustle in your hedge-row, don't be alarmed now. It's just a spring clean for the May Queen. :rolleyes:
 
stinkynuts said:
It may seem like we have choices, but we don't.

We come into this world crying, not because we choose to but because crying is a biological reaction. We don't choose to be hungry, sleepy, or horny. But when we experience these feelings, we seek food, sleep, or sex. .

Not always, the free will that you are asking about gives us the ability to ignore these biological needs.

stinkynuts said:
We don't choose to fall in love, it's the emotion thrust upon us by an invisible force that wants us to procreate. We have no choice but to work in order to survive, and we have no choice but to go to school so that we can get a good job..

Not true, love is an emotion that can be controlled with free will. As love is basically another biological function if you exercise self control, you can prevent yourself from "falling in love".

Work in order to survive: Again, not true. THere are millions of people on this earth who choose not to work and do survive. (just look at all the millions on welfare!). As an example you could simply learn to live off the land and move to the wilds of northern ontario or BC.

School: You do have a choice, you only have to go until you're 16 and even before that you can be home schooled. You also don't have to be educated to get a job, and you don't have to have a "good" job. You can get a job you enjoy. For eg: a lawyer goes fishing on his vacation, where a fisherman does it for a living. I used to have a high pressure office job and did cabinetry and carpentry as a hobby. I left the corporate world to do it full time.

stinkynuts said:
In the end all of our actions seem to be driven by needs we have no control over. We are all marching through life like pawns.

I strongly believe that the mass murders of Charles Manson and the scientific achievements of Einstein were the result of the same force ... call it God if you like. They, like us, had no choice in what they would do, they were mere puppets being controlled by the Puppeteer. Events like the Holocaust were meant to happen. Hitler was merely the chosen agent who brought about God's plan. He had no choice.

What you are really describing (IMHO) is your ability to exercise your free will. If you are finding you don't have the willpower to live your life as you'd like it to be, I'd suggest you get some help in developing this ability.
 
I like the general idea of The Matrix. What I mean by that is what if we lived our lives over and over and over, same time, same place, same circumstances (note this is not the reincarnation theory as some might think it is). A pawn, god, choices, proactive etc etc. Nope in fact I have probably written this piece at least 100 times before, I just dont know it.

Wouldn't that be interesting?
 
I think this is not a yes/no questions. Is there free will? Sometimes.

Even an act that you might think of as having free will over may change depending on the context. For example, we choose not to commit murder but in the case of self defense we may have no other choice (assuming we want to live).

The presence of a choice is not static.
 
We have free will but there are things that we dont have a choice with...like we did not choose our parents and what they have given us.
 
Could someone please post the correct answer?
 
stinkynuts said:
It may seem like we have choices, but we don't.

We come into this world crying, not because we choose to but because crying is a biological reaction. We don't choose to be hungry, sleepy, or horny. But when we experience these feelings, we seek food, sleep, or sex.

We don't choose to fall in love, it's the emotion thrust upon us by an invisible force that wants us to procreate. We have no choice but to work in order to survive, and we have no choice but to go to school so that we can get a good job.

In the end all of our actions seem to be driven by needs we have no control over. We are all marching through life like pawns.

I strongly believe that the mass murders of Charles Manson and the scientific achievements of Einstein were the result of the same force ... call it God if you like. They, like us, had no choice in what they would do, they were mere puppets being controlled by the Puppeteer. Events like the Holocaust were meant to happen. Hitler was merely the chosen agent who brought about God's plan. He had no choice.


I hope you aren't serious . There is a difference between biological needs such as eating and Hitler.
Hitler chose to hate , I can choose to hate someone or forgive.