Divorce Court Mayhem

I suspect that the Toronto Star doesn't get it. In fact the special intetrest groups that wrote the legislation don't get it.

IMHO I am aware of several men who just stopped working because having a job was a money losing proposition. I have two male relatives who are in that position.

One has children and simply won't hold a paying job and the other chooses to be underemployed. He even put his entire inheritance into gold, for the simple reason that no Court can touch it.

Men just have to understand that this country is against them. I realize it is easy to say "I won't have children". But becoming a parent is a very strong natural desire for some people. Hard to overcome.

EU
 
I just like to know how any sane judge can say to someone:you make 4000 a month? well you have to pay your wife 3300.00 and all the while she goes out and buys another house and he's living in his parent's spare room?

FUCK once again I thank god that I never got married......
 
Now for the "other" side

I have a buddy- been married to the same woman for 22 years...

A few years back he "innocently" intercepts a text from his wife that was obviously NOT meant for him! Turns out she was having an affair with one of their mutual friends! (The dumb bitch sent the text to him instead of the boyfriend! LOL) Anyway it was a very messy situation... but she ends up leaving him and their 5 CHILDREN! (The youngest is 13 now) They both earn about the same amount of $, but because SHE was the "guilty" party- and SHE left the kids, SHE has to pay child support to him!

I just thought you guys might wanna hear about one that went the other way...
 
Cycleguy007 said:
I have a buddy- been married to the same woman for 22 years...

A few years back he "innocently" intercepts a text from his wife that was obviously NOT meant for him! Turns out she was having an affair with one of their mutual friends! (The dumb bitch sent the text to him instead of the boyfriend! LOL) Anyway it was a very messy situation... but she ends up leaving him and their 5 CHILDREN! (The youngest is 13 now) They both earn about the same amount of $, but because SHE was the "guilty" party- and SHE left the kids, SHE has to pay child support to him!

I just thought you guys might wanna hear about one that went the other way...

What jurisdiction was that in ? In Ontario the No Fault aspect would mean it doesn't matter. I think the key points as to why she pays is that they both earned the same and he is raising the kids. In those circumstances it's logical that she should pay to him her portion of the child support.

I want to see what happens if a long time "house-husband" gets divorced after the kids are grown up. I'm betting he somehow wouldn't get as much as a woman in the same situation.
 
Mikehorn said:
I take way more Advil than that. A quarter of an Advil is nothing. Might as well take a quarter of a Smartie. How do you even divide it into quarters?


Exactly, and the Courts believed this bullshit.

EU
 
Mikehorn said:
I take way more Advil than that. A quarter of an Advil is nothing. Might as well take a quarter of a Smartie. How do you even divide it into quarters?

never mind quarters...how would you divide it into dimes????

As for cycleguy's example of the other side of the coin. I've heard of situations like that too (where the wife was having an affair) but fought and won custody of the kids even though the husband was always faithful and a good father and provider.

I think in CG's case the only reason the husband retained custody was because the wife (from the sounds of it) abandoned the kids.

I think this No Fault divorce is a crock. From the sounds of it the departing/cheating spouse can do whatever and still come out ahead.
 
I think that article does a good job in communicating the simple yet often overlooked fact that if you condone dependency, you can't just up and change your mind down the road.

If you condone your wife staying home and doing nothing but being a housewife, then you're putting yourself on the hook to support her for a heck of a long time if you get divorced.

While I agree the system is now too tilted in favour of women, I do believe that it should be tilted in favour of women to some degree. Why? Because if there isn't a disincentive to divorce men will just get rid of their wives as soon as something hotter comes along. And a society full of abandoned "old" women isn't a good thing. We're pretty much done away with religious/societal pressures to stay married so all that's left is a financial penalty.
 
tboy said:
I think in CG's case the only reason the husband retained custody was because the wife (from the sounds of it) abandoned the kids.

Drug use and/or engaging in prostitution are other criteria. I know of a dancer who lost her kids basically because she's a stripper (and her ex- had a better lawyer).
 
This is why I think its so important for a husband to encourage his wife to have a career, or at least to continue her education throughout the marriage. Honestly, what the hell do housewives do all day when the children are at school?? I mean, start a small company, work from home, bag groceries part time... just do SOMETHING
Not to mention.. I would feel bad just sitting around all day, then spending my husband's money. And thats how I would see it - his money, not mine or ours!

I hear of so many single-income divorces where the wife just expects to be taken care of the rest of her life. If she is young (say 30's or even 40's) she has ample time to get an education and get a J-O-B! The husband should only have to support her until she is able to support herself.

And if its an older couple on the verge of retirement... just have an open marriage! lol
 
tboy said:
As for cycleguy's example of the other side of the coin. I've heard of situations like that too (where the wife was having an affair) but fought and won custody of the kids even though the husband was always faithful and a good father and provider.

I think in CG's case the only reason the husband retained custody was because the wife (from the sounds of it) abandoned the kids.

I think this No Fault divorce is a crock. From the sounds of it the departing/cheating spouse can do whatever and still come out ahead.

To be clear, the wife made NO ATTEMPT to gain custody of the children involved. The father, who is a good friend of mine (we get together for drinks and pool pretty much every weekend), is totally devoted to his kids and ex-wifey knows this, so this is for the best I suppose. Their youngest daughter; now 13 is best friends with our daughters, and their 2 boys are very good friends with our son- so we fully understand their mindset. The older 2 girls want nothing to do with their mother now. (They are ALL fully aware of the situation...)

The thing that pisses me off is, (and tboy touched on this subject as well), what kind of a woman does she have to be to turn her back on her kids like this. Although the Ex-wifey has to pay child support, she walks away and gets her little "fantasy life" with her new boyfriend... and makes few feeble attempts if any to even visit with her kids.:mad:
 
Cycleguy007 said:
The thing that pisses me off is, (and tboy touched on this subject as well), what kind of a woman does she have to be to turn her back on her kids like this. Although the Ex-wifey has to pay child support, she walks away and gets her little "fantasy life" with her new boyfriend... and makes few feeble attempts if any to even visit with her kids.:mad:

I find this statement interesting on a couple of levels. First thing that strikes me is WHY are you pissed off or surprised by this. I notice you made a point of sayin "woman", as if gender determines personality characteristics like nurturing, empathy, selflessness.

Secondly, the statement reminds me of the stereotypical attitude usually reserved for men after they separate from the family. A popular perception acted upon by the Family Law system by encumbering men with punitive support payments and restrictive access.

What is actually worse is when the courts give custody to these types of women and force men to underwrite the womans existence while she neglects her responsibilty to the children. Your friend should count himself fortunate that she is cognizant of her ability or inability to care for the kids and has let him care for them. There are hundreds if not thousands of men who would love to have half of that opportunity.
 
First, as a broad and sweeping generality it is frequently difficult to make intelligent comments based on a newspaper report.

That said: This is an area of the law where Canadian and U.S. law have diverged. In the U.S. (it should be remembered this is a state, not a federal area of lawmaking) alimony has become a temporary, not a permanent remedy the idea being to get the weaker party on their feet and the trend is towards a lump sum payment. Now I'm not saying that in the U.S. a spouse in a long term marriage who has medical problems might not get the same result as in the case of the Tippetts but I don't believe it would be so automatic.

Secondly Canada does not have nearly as strong protections against ex post facto law as does the U.S.

Finally, I would certainly agree with Mr. Epstein's statement in the article "I think most family law lawyers now regard going to court as a failure, of both them and their clients. A failure to be reasonable," and would add that certainly mediation is by far preferable to a trial.
 
Sexy_Dave said:
I find this statement interesting on a couple of levels. First thing that strikes me is WHY are you pissed off or surprised by this. I notice you made a point of sayin "woman", as if gender determines personality characteristics like nurturing, empathy, selflessness.

Secondly, the statement reminds me of the stereotypical attitude usually reserved for men after they separate from the family. A popular perception acted upon by the Family Law system by encumbering men with punitive support payments and restrictive access.

What is actually worse is when the courts give custody to these types of women and force men to underwrite the womans existence while she neglects her responsibilty to the children. Your friend should count himself fortunate that she is cognizant of her ability or inability to care for the kids and has let him care for them. There are hundreds if not thousands of men who would love to have half of that opportunity.

I used the term "woman" because well, she IS a woman. But the attitude can be just as easily be used if the tables were turned. I ALSO have very little respect for a MAN that does the same thing. As a self respecting father I cannot in good conscience relate to a man or woman that turns his or her back on their own children. I have ZERO tolerance of those types of people.

As for your other comments, I don't believe she IS cognizant of her ability or inability to care for the kids. I think she just doesn't care enough, or cares MORE for her "fantasy life" with the new boy friend instead... and THAT is why her attitude pisses me off.
 
A little surprised ...

Keebler Elf said:
While I agree the system is now too tilted in favour of women, I do believe that it should be tilted in favour of women to some degree. Why? Because if there isn't a disincentive to divorce men will just get rid of their wives as soon as something hotter comes along. And a society full of abandoned "old" women isn't a good thing. We're pretty much done away with religious/societal pressures to stay married so all that's left is a financial penalty.

nobody has commented on this yet, would have expected at least a few howls of outrage. Suspect this is one reason why there seem to be a lot of "got skinned" divorce experiences on this board. In at least a few cases the court sided with Mrs. primarily because Mr. was pretty much of a lying, cheating scumbag!:rolleyes:
 
y2kmark said:
In at least a few cases the court sided with Mrs. primarily because Mr. was pretty much of a lying, cheating scumbag!
Well, it's not actually that simple.

Apparently, the courts aren't supposed to take into account the reasons why the divorce action was started in the first place unless physical abuse was involved. That is, it makes no difference who cheated on who; the divorce judgement should be the same.

The reality, though, is quite different.

In the cases that I know of personally, when the woman has cheated the woman's actions aren't considered when the judge made the ruling. But when the men cheated, the judge made note of that in her judgement and ruled accordingly.