discount broker account question

newtohobby

New member
Jul 22, 2006
445
0
0
I;m opening an account with a discount broker. they ask u if your unemployed, student or employed. Will they turn u down if your unemployed?

I was working but recently got laid off.

Also they ask your what your net worth is, how accurate do you have to be? Can I give them a lower ammount of what I'm worth? why do they ask that?
 
newtohobby said:
Can I give them a lower amount of what I'm worth? why do they ask that?

It is the KYC (know your client) rule. There was a story a while back about a guy who was buying an inter-listed stock on the NY exchange and selling the same stock on the TSX. He got a call from his broker reminding him that the stock listed on the NY exchange is priced in USD's and the same stock listed on the TSX is priced in CAD's.
 
SkyRider said:
There was a story a while back about a guy who was buying an inter-listed stock on the NY exchange and selling the same stock on the TSX. He got a call from his broker reminding him that the stock listed on the NY exchange is priced in USD's and the same stock listed on the TSX is priced in CAD's.

A lot of people do that, it's a good way to change US dollars into Canadian dollars. Your broker can journal over the Canadian and US trades to cancel them out and you're left with what amounts to a currency exchange, usually at a much lower rate than a currency broker would offer you.

My guess is the front line monkey who placed the call was unaware that this is commonplace and/or allowed and, since he didn't understand it, started harassing the client.

All brokers have front line monkeys who are clueless, I automatically ask for a manager whenever I need to do something as it's just too frustrating trying to educate the front line guys on how to do their jobs.

Usually once you escalate one or two levels up the pay scale you do reach someone who understands the system.
 
fuji said:
it's a good way to change US dollars into Canadian dollars. Your broker can journal over the Canadian and US trades to cancel them out and you're left with what amounts to a currency exchange, usually at a much lower rate than a currency broker would offer you.

This is interesting. Can you provide an illustrated example using an inter-listed stock of all this works? Does this work only converting USD's to CAD's?
 
SkyRider said:
This is interesting. Can you provide an illustrated example using an inter-listed stock of all this works? Does this work only converting USD's to CAD's?

Buy BNS on the NYE and sell it on the Toronto Exchange. Many Canadian stocks have listings on both exchanges. GB
 
SkyRider said:
This is interesting. Can you provide an illustrated example using an inter-listed stock of all this works? Does this work only converting USD's to CAD's?

Ostensibly you could do it in any currency combo as long as you could find a single stock traded on the two desired exchanges.

I'd be interested in the details too though, as it seems to me that the commissions involved might negate any exchange rate advantage. Any pattern of this activity might also raise Anti-Money Laundering and/or Tax Authority eyebrows.

If I'm not mistaken SkyRider, I thought your original post was pointing out the stupidity of the "newbie" who thought he was arbitraging by buying the stock at 85 and seeling it at 100 (not realizing it was USD vs. CAD), and NOT proposing an alternative system for foreign exchange.
 
SkyRider said:
This is interesting. Can you provide an illustrated example using an inter-listed stock of all this works? Does this work only converting USD's to CAD's?

Pick any interlisted stock. Say Royal Bank. Buy on the TSX and then immediately sell on the NYSE (or the other way around). You now have a long position in your Canadian account and a short position in your American account. Call your broker and have them journal over the positions to cancel them out.

The front line monkeys may give you grief at a few points:

1. They may refuse your order to sell the stock short on the grounds that you don't have enough margin. Escalate the call to a manager and point out that you are not short.

2. They may have no idea how to journal the stock over at the end of the transaction. Again, escalate to a perosn who has a fucking clue.

This is most often done when someone is selling a house in one country with plans to buy in the other country where the sums are significant enough that the few percentage points that a currency broker would charge repesent a lot of money.

It's probably worthwhile calling in advance of the trade, walking it through with the broker, and escalating your call to the point where you get someone who understands what you are doing. Get that person's direct contact information and keep it handy when you are running the process.

In most cases the brokers hire retards to answer the phones, people who don't have a clue how markets work, have completed some minimal training, and only really know how to follow the prompts on the computer screen in front of them.

The point being that "know your client" is bullshit since the people who "know" the client are retards to begin with. There is no value in "knowing" your client unless you are also smart enough to do something with the knowledge.
 
viking1965 said:
pointing out the stupidity of the "newbie" who thought he was arbitraging by buying the stock at 85 and seeling it at 100 (not realizing it was USD vs. CAD), and NOT proposing an alternative system for foreign exchange.

Yes, I heard that story from a friend who might have heard it from another friend. Could be an urban myth. FUJI brought a foreign currency exchange angle to the story that is really interesting.