Direct Payment Question

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
Let's say you've got a bank account from which you have authorized a company to withdraw X amount of dollars per month (e.g., a gym membership).

Then you notify the company that you want to change the withdrawal from one account to another. You do this in writing and they confirm that the change will be made. You have records to prove all this.

Then the company doesn't make the change and you incur insufficient funds charges because the old account does not have sufficient funds in it.

1) Is there a way to either stop payment or otherwise compel the company to stop taking the funds from the old account?

2) Is there a way to be reimbursed for the insufficient funds charges? (aside from Small Claims Court)
 
I don't have an answer for the OP but have a related question.

Has anybody ever successfully set up a pre-authorized debit with ROGERS?
 
You can put a stop payment on the amount and the date of regularly scheduled withdrawal. However, if the biller (gym) changes the amount or the date they try and make the withdrawal, it may still go through your account.

If it does go through and is honoured, then keep in mind that under the Canadian Payments Association (CPA) guidelines, you have 90 days from the date the PAD was put through your account to have it returned by your bank as unauthorized.

http://www.cdnpay.ca/faqs/debits.asp#How_do_I_cancel_a_PAD_agreement.

With regards to the NSF fee, although you do not appear at fault, neither is your Financial Institution. Therefore, they are not required to reimburse the NSF fee. However, if you are a good customer of your bank, this is an isolated (one-time) incident (ie. you are not demanding fee reversals every 2-3 months for various things), and you can show them you have confirmation that the biller (gym) acknowledged your request to change the billing account, I would be very surprised if they did not reimburse the NSF fee.

You will need to closely monitor your account for at least the next 6 months to insure no further payments from the GYM go through your account. If you see one, notify your bank immediately to have it returned. The 90 day window for doing so is absolute!

Good luck Keebler!

P.S. You should also immediately follow up with the Gym in writing and insist that no further payments attempt to be taken from the wrong account.
 
It's actually not a gym. I just used that as an example. This company is more reputable than a gym, but we'll see...
 
This is why, if I can in any way avoid it, I never set up pre-authorized payments. I much prefer systems where I can set it up as an online bill payment where I am in control of when or whether it gets paid.

If your letter to the gym said that the payments should be changed by a specific date and they confirmed agreement to that, it does not matter what is in your contract, as your new terms will supercede that.
 
I agree.... preauthorized payments for ANY reason leave one wide open to errors, abuse, etc. Its sad... almost every bill I pay wants me to set up pre authorized payments.

I will never do that...I don't even issue post dated cheques.