Dieppe - 80 Years Ago

I saw a documentary a while back and it was being narrated by a British historian. I think it may have been about Churchill. It's been a while.

He claimed that Dieppe was the doing of Winston Churchill. And Churchill sacrificed the Canadian soldiers to prove to the Americans that 1942 was not the right time to invade Europe. When the USA entered the war after Pearl Harbor, the American military brass were chomping at the bit to take the fight to Germany. Their logic was pretty straight forward. Shortest distance to Berlin. Invade, march to Berlin, war is over. Makes sense. But Churchill wanted nothing to do with that. He wanted to preserve the British empire and then defeat Germany. If the Americans were allowed to go ahead with their plan, the war would have been over in a year. Churchill didn't want that and so he figured to show the Americans how fruitless an immediate invasion would be, he figured he needed to LOSE an invasion. But he didn't want to risk sacrificing British lives. The memories of the carnage of WW1 were too fresh in the British memories. So he chose instead to sacrifice Canadians. Too far away was Canada, the British population would not care and he set us up for a fall simply to delay an European invasion.

Interesting theory.
 
There is an excellent film on the Navaho code starring "the world's greatest actor" called Windtalkers - worth watching.
The video didn't say it explicitly. Cage was under orders to kill Beach if Beach was about to be taken alive by the enemy.
 
The Dieppe raid is significant in our neck of the woods, Windsor, Ontario.
On August 18, 1942, 553 officers and enlisted men from the local Essex Kent Regiment descended from their landing craft onto the shale beach of Dieppe amid heavy fire from German MG-34s and howitzers. After losing almost half of the men on the beach dead or wounded, they attempted to scale a wall to enter the town but were not successful. The British returned to evacuate the survivors but the Germans were far too numerous and made evacuation hazardous. Of the 553 who started this mission, 51 men returned to England.
Although the regiment was decimated, it was soon reconstituted and landed on Juno Beach almost two years later and fought throughout Europe until VE Day.
The Dieppe raid is significant to many folks in Windsor because the Essex and Kent Regiment comprised most of the young men of our small city. Our next door neighbour at the time lost his son. One of my cousins survived the raid and returned to England wounded.
 
Last edited:
In 1942, the Allies stood a good chance of losing WWII. It's been suggested that Dieppe was a show of force to keep Stalin in the war. It was feared that he would give up European Russia and retreat into deep Siberia. It became top priority that Rhinehard Heydrich be eliminated, he was as clever as he was evil. The rest of the Nazi top brass were common thugs...pieces of shit on legs.

How badly did the Reichfuhrer's SD fail in early winter 1942/43. General Paulus had no idea that General Zhukov's Siberian Divisions had crossed the Volga until his own reconnaissance told him. He requested a withdrawal from Stalingrad to more defensive ground, his request was denied. Hitler's fevered brain couldn't envision that Zhukov was setting up the biggest Cannae in human history.

 
In 1942, after the Allied defeat of German forces in North Africa, 10,000 German POWs were shipped from Cairo, Egypt, to New York, transferred to the Canadian Pacific Railway and moved to Ozada camp on the Alberta prairie. Prisoners were sheltered temporarily under canvas until two large camps were built at Lethbridge and Medicine Hat. In time, these two camps held 12,500 prisoners each. Smaller camps housed POWs in other provinces.

All POWs were legally protected under the terms of the Geneva Convention, and were adequately provisioned and housed as required by the Convention. Canadians living near the camps believed the POWs received better food than they themselves enjoyed under wartime rationing. Veterans Guards, and later, the Canadian Army soldiers who guarded the camps, had the same provisions but said the POWs had better cooks and more time to prepare meals.
Why was Rommel defeated at El Alamein - DailyHistory.org
There was a big Nazi POW camp in Bowmanville. There was also a big jail break in early 1941, when the US was still neutral. Some Nazi's managed to get to the US and were able to rejoin the German war machine. However, most stayed because it was better than fighting on the Eastern front.

 
There was a big Nazi POW camp in Bowmanville. There was also a big jail break in early 1941, when the US was still neutral. Some Nazi's managed to get to the US and were able to rejoin the German war machine. However, most stayed because it was better than fighting on the Eastern front.

I also heard that some of these POW's married local girls. True?
Also, heard that some POW's returned to Canada as legal immigrants after the war.

Bear in mind that both Canada and the U.S. have a huge ethnic German population.


  1. Were German POWs who were housed in the USA allowed to stay …
    ...
    There was a POW camp on Galveston Island. It's common knowledge there that some inmates stayed after war, never going home. Supposedly some married local girls and stayed right there on the island. Sure, there were rules, Geneva Convention, and all. But Galveston has always been like it's its own country.
 
German Americans in WWII.

"Many Americans of German ancestry had top war jobs, including General Dwight D. Eisenhower, Admiral Chester W. Nimitz, and USAAF General Carl Andrew Spaatz. Roosevelt appointed Republican Wendell Willkie (who ironically ran against Roosevelt in the 1940 presidential election) as a personal representative. German Americans who had fluent German language skills were an important asset to wartime intelligence, and they served as translators and as spies for the United States.[100] The war evoked strong pro-American patriotic sentiments among German Americans, few of whom by then had contacts with distant relatives in the old country.[26][1"

After the war, Admiral Nimitz was offered $500,000 (big money back the) to write his autobiography. He declined the offer saying that the glory and honour belong to the men and women who served with him.
 
In 1942, after the Allied defeat of German forces in North Africa, 10,000 German POWs were shipped from Cairo, Egypt, to New York, transferred to the Canadian Pacific Railway and moved to Ozada camp on the Alberta prairie. Prisoners were sheltered temporarily under canvas until two large camps were built at Lethbridge and Medicine Hat. In time, these two camps held 12,500 prisoners each. Smaller camps housed POWs in other provinces.
This part is of particular interest to me as my father, who was at that time a Lieutenant in the Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry had the task of escorting said POW's from Halifax to Alberta via CP rail. He never saw any action in WW2 but saw action in Korea as a Captain with the PPCLI.
 
This part is of particular interest to me as my father, who was at that time a Lieutenant in the Princess Patricia's Canadian Light Infantry had the task of escorting said POW's from Halifax to Alberta via CP rail. He never saw any action in WW2 but saw action in Korea as a Captain with the PPCLI.
Interesting. When I was growing up in rural Quebec. I met a gentleman who did pretty much what your father did.

He said the German POW's were young, tall and handsome. Many were blue eyed blondes. He said life in the camps (prison?) was pretty good. They got 3 squares a day. On Saturday night they would attend a dance with the local ladies (as many young Canadian males were overseas). Is this all true?