Dieppe 65 years later

danmand said:
OK, you two, have it your way. Just remember that your fathers,
who's unquestioned bravery you take credit for, fought for free speech.


Went out to relax, had a table shower massage+ and checked out Venice Beach so I'm mellow now. Glad i didn't comment earlier on the bravery slur.

I'm not trying to take credit for any "bravery" my dad showed. He most likely was not thinking what he did was brave ( he never admitted as much but I'll guess he was scared shitless), he and his mates just did what was required. As to personal bravery. I did my time in our Army ( Armed Forces land Element) and can't help it if we were not involved in a Hot war when I was in. That being said, I hope I would have risen to the ocassion if needed.
 
LancsLad said:
Went out to relax, had a table shower massage+ and checked out Venice Beach so I'm mellow now. Glad i didn't comment earlier on the bravery slur.
Glad you enjoyed yourself.

LancsLad said:
I'm not trying to take credit for any "bravery" my dad showed. He most likely was not thinking what he did was brave ( he never admitted as much but I'll guess he was scared shitless), he and his mates just did what was required. As to personal bravery. I did my time in our Army ( Armed Forces land Element) and can't help it if we were not involved in a Hot war when I was in. That being said, I hope I would have risen to the ocassion if needed.

I was not slurring anybody. I just can't help thinking, like you pretty much say yourself, that your father would have disapproved of your public display of his bravery. That was not the style of his generation.

And I am sure you are a brave man. I have no reason to believe otherwise.
 
LancsLad said:
In the correct context yes I do make puns involving the military, everyone does. This thread was started by me as a tribute to those who went ashore on the pebble beach that morning It was a COSTLY bloody lesson and far too many died but the Allies learned a lot and put it to good use in '44. Last summer I went over to Normandy and stood on the exact beach my Dad waded ashore on early morning 6/6/44, it was heartbreaking.
Was your Dad with the British or Canadian forces? The US caught the most hell at Omaha Beach, but the other landings weren't exactly a cakewalk. Notable that the Canadian force at Juno, was the only one to reach it's objectives, and had to be pulled back to more defensive positions because they had advanced so far ahead of everyone else.
 
Asterix said:
Was your Dad with the British or Canadian forces? The US caught the most hell at Omaha Beach, but the other landings weren't exactly a cakewalk. Notable that the Canadian force at Juno, was the only one to reach it's objectives, and had to be pulled back to more defensive positions because they had advanced so far ahead of everyone else.



British, Gold Beach.

Dad told an interesting story of his brief adventure behind enemy lines that day. The front was fluid midday to late afternoon and the squad he was in were moving down a road until one of the fellows noted to him ( Dad was a Sgt.) that the km markers on the signs they passed were showing an increase not decrease . Dad had to explain to the Lt. the hard facts that revelation meant. They then left the area of the road and made their way back West to the rest of the of the group. The Lt. was newly commissioned and had only joined them just prior to the invasion. ( Thought DQ would like that point)
 
danmand said:
Do you really think there are any Vets here?????

Perhaps so.....perhaps not....but, on this special anniversary weekend, there are certainly enough family members who respect the sacrifices of their fathers, uncles and other kinfolk in WW2, a sacrifice that enabled their children and all the morons of this world to enjoy free speech and all the other glorious freedoms that many now take for granted.

By the way, I am not referring to other contributers on this board specifically with these comments! On the other hand, if the shoe fits, you are welcome to wear it!

This is my final post on this particular thread, as I know that the silent majority respect the memories of many on this sad occasion! For the rest, they are welcome to the last word, thanks to those who perished.
 
kbluejayk said:
Perhaps so.....perhaps not....but, on this special anniversary weekend, there are certainly enough family members who respect the sacrifices of their fathers, uncles and other kinfolk in WW2, a sacrifice that enabled their children and all the morons of this world to enjoy free speech and all the other glorious freedoms that many now take for granted.

By the way, I am not referring to other contributers on this board specifically with these comments! On the other hand, if the shoe fits, you are welcome to wear it!

This is my final post on this particular thread, as I know that the silent majority respect the memories of many on this sad occasion! For the rest, they are welcome to the last word, thanks to those who perished.



Well said.

I was in the Army, but never would be so bold as to claim " Veteran" status. Thats for those who have endured sustained hot deployment.

Having said that, if there are any Korean War or Cdn 'nam veterans on this board then good on 'em. Americans as well.:)
 
Until you've laced up a pair of boots, donned a helmut and been shot at, show a VET every ounce of RESPECT. Yes some of them fought for your right to be an asshole and treating everything a joke. And they would be the first one's to defend you right to "free speech".

They represent the Husbands, Brothers and Sons who Died frightend far from home. So forgive me when I get a little bent out of shape when someone tries to make lite of a day when many a brave man breathed his last breath calling out for his Mother.

So when you see a Vet or someone paying their respects, do the right thing and bow your head and say a payer of thanks to those brave souls past and present.

Thank you.
 
Don't forget to thank the brits for how well the raid turned out.


Just another in the long line of colonial cannon fodder giving their lives and making a great contribution for the empire.
 
basketcase said:
Don't forget to thank the brits for how well the raid turned out.


Just another in the long line of colonial cannon fodder giving their lives and making a great contribution for the empire.



This is not a time to try and bring in a CHEAP shot. SHAME :mad:
 
danmand said:
Do you really think there are any Vets here?????

Some time ago an RCR guy was posting one here under the name Soldierboy or something like that. I don’t know if he is still on the board or even still in the RCR, but if so, I would not be surprise if he had been in Afghanistan by now.

LancsLad said:
British, Gold Beach.

Dad told an interesting story of his brief adventure behind enemy lines that day. The front was fluid midday to late afternoon and the squad he was in were moving down a road until one of the fellows noted to him ( Dad was a Sgt.) that the km markers on the signs they passed were showing an increase not decrease . Dad had to explain to the Lt. the hard facts that revelation meant. They then left the area of the road and made their way back West to the rest of the of the group. The Lt. was newly commissioned and had only joined them just prior to the invasion. ( Thought DQ would like that point)
An uncle of mine told one story of his experiences. He was responsible for driving back some of this buddies from some R&R in France after D day but had had too much to drink himself. At some point they realized that they were in a town behind German lines. He said that he had never sobered up so fast in his life.
 
basketcase said:
Don't forget to thank the brits for how well the raid turned out.

Just another in the long line of colonial cannon fodder giving their lives and making a great contribution for the empire.

You don't have a clue.

The raid was planned for the early morning hours but was intercepted by some German patrol boats causing it to be delayed with the Germans getting forwarning of the assualt. The raid was important, it was hoped that they would come away with some prisoners, learn how best to take and hold a position from the Germans and give the people back home something to cheer about.

They did meet with some early success but with their time table thrown off and the Germans forewarned, they were able to get additional troops and turn the tide of the British and Canadian troops.

The Canadians were spoiling for a fight, to get in "on it" and to prove to the people back home that they were doing something. And the British had to prove to the Canadians that they needed more training before they could take on the Wehrmacht.

The Canadians had a reputation to up hold from WWI, they were better equiped, paid and fed than their British counterparts. The British and the Commonwealth needed some good news, something to prove that the Germans could be beat.

Lord Mountbatten didn't throw away their lives, he had to live with a lot of decisions that caused men to die. Public opnion also was negative against the crown beause of their German heritage. They and the British goverment had to prove that they were not going to roll over for the Germans, that they could and would strike back. And this was one plan to do so.
 
danmand said:
Do you really think there are any Vets here?????
my dog has an ichy bum... and i don't want it draging it's ass on the carpet...
 
There is a great book called " Green Beach" about a detachment from the South Sask. on that day.

They took a radar tech ashore as his "protective" escort during the raid to inspect a German radar facilty and remove evidence of how well developed their system was.
 
Sure the Canadians wanted to get in the action but the Brits screwed them out of the naval and air support they needed to be successful. The Canadians were backed into a corner and had to proceed without it.

WinterHawk said:
And the British had to prove to the Canadians that they needed more training before they could take on the Wehrmacht.
Doesn't this contradict your point? This implies that the British wanted a failure to prove a point.

The Canaidian soldiers did a hell of a lot and tons was learned from it but that information could still have been learned without the military disaster that happened.
 
basketcase said:
Sure the Canadians wanted to get in the action but the Brits screwed them out of the naval and air support they needed to be successful. The Canadians were backed into a corner and had to proceed without it.

Doesn't this contradict your point? This implies that the British wanted a failure to prove a point.

The Canaidian soldiers did a hell of a lot and tons was learned from it but that information could still have been learned without the military disaster that happened.

Earlier in the thread I mentioned "Raid on Dieppe" was on the History Channel.

The program covered these points nicely (including interviews with soldiers) and you are correct.
 
Thanks for the freedom

I've had the privelage of visiting Dieppe, as well as the Normandy beaches and a handful of WW I sites. Moving, yes, but in particular the cemeteries were challenging to visit, in an emotional sense, no matter what nationality they were. You'd have to be a robot not to tear up when walking through row after row after row after row of poor sods buried in Northern France. As horrible as the current wars are, thankfully the losses are not comparable, at least in terms of numbers.
 
I've never seen it....

CapitalGuy said:
Moving, yes, but in particular the cemeteries were challenging to visit, in an emotional sense, no matter what nationality they were. You'd have to be a robot not to tear up when walking through row after row after row after row of poor sods buried in Northern France. As horrible as the current wars are, thankfully the losses are not comparable, at least in terms of numbers.

...in person, but I have on TV. Amazing. And sad.

I think EVERY leader of a free world nation should be forced to visit those sites, along with watching the first several minutes of "Save Private Ryan", before taking office. I truly, truly believe our current leadership, most of whom have never seen combat themselves (or even served) take war and the associated deaths far too casually and cavalierly.

It is real easy to say "its the price we pay for our freedoms" when all you know of that price are the numbers...

I am not Canadian, but I am ABSOLUTELY grateful to every man, regardless of his country of origin, who fought for my freedom...and more so for those who died.
 
I am late to this thread, but thank you Lanc's for putting such a solemn note on this board, where most of the time, we act like imbeciles and debate everything. It is because of brave men such as those who went through the hell of Dieppe that we can do this.

My only regret is a sizeable number of people spit on this memory by their words and actions, but again, they have the right because we are free country. Something we would NOT be without our vets. I shudder to think what we would do if Canada ever were really attacked. I suspect half the population would just surrender...because they don't get that freedom is sometimes fought for.
 
Second Front

Only Bomber Command could STRIKE BACK.
Albert Speer, Hitler's Minister of Armaments was unequivocal about this:

"the real importance of the air war was that it opened a second front long before the invasion of Europe. That front was the skies over Germany...The unpredictibility of the attacks made the front gigantic...Defence against air attacks required the production of thousands of anti aircraft guns, the stockpiling of tremendous quantities of ammunition all over the country, and holding in readiness hundreds of thousands of soldiers...As far as I can judge from the accounts I have read, this was the greatest lost battle on the German side."